MTG Salvation

Quote from Slothful »

Btw Grape, just to clarify:

Was proposal 5.4 accepted by the majority of players?
Or was 5.4 rejected, leading to 5.5 for KJ, and an automatic scum victory?

We didn't have a majority of votes yet but I didn't bother waiting because the proposal was a loss for town if accepted and KJ's was also a loss for town if Rhand's was rejected.

I agree with everyone saying that the game dragged. It was exacerbated by my spotty modding but I think that it would have been too long regardless.

I really enjoy resistance and think it can work on forums but we definitely haven't cracked it here and I'm low on idea's to revamp. Quicker would be better but I don't know if our playerbase who remains interested in Resistance could support a 24/12 or a 12/12. Definitely a game that benefits from a quick pace and tight modding and I just didn't provide the latter which made the former impossible even with several quick nominations and most players being very prompt with submitting their votes.

GG town! You dunked us. Sorry for replacing out and shooting us in the foot further.

Edit: One funny thing is that my initial super strong town read of Umami was an attempt to powerwolf. I had my wires crossed on which ongoing game she was scum in (turns out it was resistance and not this) and had to just turn it into a meta read based on her being new to scum when I knew she was more capable than my meta read was allowing. It was a very awkward balance to walk.

With that proposal the game is locked for the spies. The Spies, Killjoy, Shadowlancer, and Umami, have won because Rhand proposed a mission with at least one spy and the spies mission will be automatically accepted.


Thank you all for sticking with this game. I am so sorry for all of the delays, but I hope you managed to enjoy it anyway! I know I enjoyed reading it.

I want to thank Silver specifically for stepping in and lending me a hand when things were getting away from me a bit.

Vaimes has nominated: Vaimes, Sloth, Rhand, GJ

You have a hard deadline 24 hours to vote. A soft deadline of 12 hours exists as well. If all votes are received by then I will move forward immediately. Please do not rely upon changing your vote at the last minute.

Voting on GJ's proposal has finished.

GJ Nominated: GJ, Umani, Sloth, KJ

Yes (1): KJ
No (6): GJ, Rhand, Shadow, Sloth, Umami, Vaimes

It is now Vaimes' turn to nominate.

GJ Nominated: GJ, Umani, Sloth, KJ.

Given the massive delays I have PM'd everyone who hasn't voted yet and will move the game along as soon as all votes are received.

I apologize for all the delays. I know that has sapped a lot of energy from the game and I'm sorry.

Umami nominated: Rhand, Sloth, Shadow, and Umami for mission 5.

Yes: Rhand, Shadow, Umami
No: GJ, KJ, sloth, Vaimes

The mission has been rejected. It is now GJ's turn to nominate. He has 72 hours to propose a team.

12 hours from now. This is the proposal. I'll make it tidy tomorrow. You all know the drill.

Quote from Umami »

Proposal 5.1: Rhand, Sloth, Shadow, Umami

@KJ can you claim your trigger since the plan is to activate today anyway?

Quote from Vaimes »

I mean he's ~kind of locked himself into a claim that he now has to prove this phase. Softing to dodge a daykill isn't exactly a long-term solution.

The role I'm thinking of would buy him a full phase and I'm very confident he's not the role I'm thinking. There are other possibilities but they don't really fit his criteria.

And given the excellent position we're in I doubt scum are thinking long term at the moment.

@Vaimes I very much don't think that he's the most obvious conditional day ability that could be used toDay but only if Rhand's shot doesn't end the day.

I think he's softing to make sure he's not the shot.

Hrmmm... Something isn't adding up then.

Anyway vague softs are the worst, that said town having a conditional role to mirror Tubba's would scratch any designers symmetry itch.

Quote from tomsloger »

I guess with a desperado, waiting for a claim doesnt matter

And claiming vanilla is just another way jacks response today is objectively prowolf...

Agree with all of this.

Just waiting for Rhand to blast someone so we can get on with the day.