Player A casts Merciless Eviction, choosing the "exile all planeswalkers" mode. Player B casts Aethersnatch, targeting Merciless Eviction. Aethersnatch resolves and Player B gains control of Merciless Eviction. Player B then announces that he or she is choosing the "exile all artifacts" mode instead. Is this play legal?
I've been on Pucatrade for almost a year now. I have a dozen or so KTK fetches I'd like to send out in the near future. I have noticed many users offer bounties for them. Unfortunately, I have thousands of trade matches for them and sorting through user IDs and profiles is aggravating. Is there a short cut to find the best bounties available?
Assuming I do find someone offering a bounty, what is the protocol? Should I expect them to send the extra points after I deliver? Is there anyway to guarantee I get the bounty? I have already seen at least two users complain about other users not honoring their bounty offers.
The following situation came up during an EDH game I was watching. Player A controls Roon of the Hidden Realm and Elvish Visionary. He casts Progenitor Mimic, copying the Visionary and drawing a card. During his next turn, he makes the token from the Mimic, draws his extra card, then blinks the Mimic with Roon. When the Mimic returns, he chooses to copy the token. He draw his extra card for it and passes the turn. At the beginning of his next turn, he tries to put two tokens into play. He tells the table that the Mimic has two instances of the token making ability, one from the token it copied and one that it gave itself. He also states that the tokens that the Mimic is making this turn will have that ability twice, so that when he blinks the Mimic and copies one of the tokens, it will now have the token-making ability three times.
Someone called the judge over. The judge ruled that the ability stacking was legal, but, because the Mimic was copying a token, it was a token and wouldn't make any tokens.
Pile A:
Mana Confluence
Life's Legacy
Reclamation Sage (Foil)
Pile B:
Scrubland - Collector's Edition. There is significant edgewear on all four sides, front and back, extending between 1/16" and 1/8" onto the borders of the card. The corners have been trimmed badly. They are cut diagonally instead of roundly. I don't believe the corners can be retrimmed to create round corners.
I recently acquired a foil 9ED Coat of Arms. The description that accompanied the card is below. The card looks HP to me. Scratches, clouding, and significant edgewear on all four sides, front and back. Am I way off base on my grading or did someone send me trash? Thanks for your help.
"The card itself appears NM, but I like to be conservative and will call it SP since the edges aren't as crisp."
I understand the loop quite well. I suppose what I meant to say is that, other than serving as a sacrifice outlet, the only element Sadistic Hypnotist brings to the table is the discard. To be honest, Vish Kal, Blood Arbiter is a much better sacrifice outlet.
I'm probably not going to cut any of the cards in question. I've had all of them in the deck for some time without any issues. I make a point to not tutor for any of them, which has kept the games fair. I've only played the Saffi/Lark/Guide combo once in the past few months. Somebody thought it would be fun to Hinder/Tunnel Vision the graveyard-based deck.
I've been on Pucatrade for almost a year now. I have a dozen or so KTK fetches I'd like to send out in the near future. I have noticed many users offer bounties for them. Unfortunately, I have thousands of trade matches for them and sorting through user IDs and profiles is aggravating. Is there a short cut to find the best bounties available?
Assuming I do find someone offering a bounty, what is the protocol? Should I expect them to send the extra points after I deliver? Is there anyway to guarantee I get the bounty? I have already seen at least two users complain about other users not honoring their bounty offers.
Someone called the judge over. The judge ruled that the ability stacking was legal, but, because the Mimic was copying a token, it was a token and wouldn't make any tokens.
Was the judge's ruling correct?
Mana Confluence
Life's Legacy
Reclamation Sage (Foil)
Pile B:
Scrubland - Collector's Edition. There is significant edgewear on all four sides, front and back, extending between 1/16" and 1/8" onto the borders of the card. The corners have been trimmed badly. They are cut diagonally instead of roundly. I don't believe the corners can be retrimmed to create round corners.
Which side is best, and by how much?
Interacts with the graveyard and takes your opponents' stuff. Toss in some Cards Like Phyrexian Arena and Grave Pact and you're good to go.
Master of the Wild Hunt has been pretty solid for my Ghave deck.
Sprout Swarm can be a little slow, but does a lot of work when games go long.
"The card itself appears NM, but I like to be conservative and will call it SP since the edges aren't as crisp."
I'm probably not going to cut any of the cards in question. I've had all of them in the deck for some time without any issues. I make a point to not tutor for any of them, which has kept the games fair. I've only played the Saffi/Lark/Guide combo once in the past few months. Somebody thought it would be fun to Hinder/Tunnel Vision the graveyard-based deck.
Nantuko Shade can be activated any number of times.
Phyrexian Battleflies can not.