Oh no! I have spent my magic the gathering life here.
I came here looking for safe haven after I got laughed at for my terrible janky deck ideas on the official forums but I cam here and found a community willing to help me improve as a deck builder.
And through your help I have turned so many janky dreams into real decks
Thank you everyone :'(
In: Rosie Cotton of South Lane out: knighted Myr Both weak bases with big upside.
In: Shire Shirriff out: fearless fledgling I have a lot of tokens in my cube.
In: Meneldor, Swift Savior out Teferi's time twist more blink.
In: Stern Scolding out Ominious Seas The card got a lot worse after I removed blue proliferate.
In: Gothmog, Morgul Lieutenant out: Bone Picker why have 1 death touch flyer when I can turn all my spirit tokens into deathtouchers?
In: Gimli, Counter of Kills out: Ravenous Giant basically everything else I have in this slot has trample.
In: Rally at the Hornburg out: Forbidden friendship strictly better.
In: Entish Restoration Out: Harrow it is rare that etb untapped matters. unless I remove Kodama's reach instead.
In: Denethor, Ruling Steward Out: Fleshtaker the issue was that all my WB cards were the same mana cost.
In: Shadowfax, Lord of Horses out: Rip Apart I have been removing removal from my dual slots, also there are actually some nasty positions this can put an opponent in even if it seems too slow.
in: Shire Terrace out: Terramorphic expanse diversity.
I like but not quite good enough.
Elrond, Lord of Rivendell I might have if not for hating the ring tempts you.
Saruman the White would have been amazing if it was every spell not every second.
Mirkwood Bats don't understand the hype.
Troll of Khazad-dûm maybe if I had the typed duals, but I have the Death Corona void bringer that will always have memories.
Éomer of the Riddermark if only it had trample.
Fiery Inscription the pull to replace guttersnipe is strong, it might make it in there but my 3 drops in red is looking thin.
Grishnákh, Brash Instigator tempting but I'd really want more ways to make armies.
Generous Ent I prefer the straight ramp of tanuki.
Quickbeam, Upstart Ent the more I looked at it the more I was starting to get convinced but its not like I have a lot of treefolk it gives a weird signal in draft.
The Mouth of Sauron needs a keyword.
Old Man Willow is big and kills things but then it just gets chumped, needed a keyword.
Rally the Hornburg going straight in
With your commander, you can basically work with Card draw, cantrips. I am not 100% on rituals it really depends how consistently you can reuse them.
I think you need far more protection for your commander and where is underworld breech?
Saiba Cryptomancer --> Merfolk trickster They are doing different things but it's basically a counterspell for 2 mana that can be easily reused.changed my mindXerex Strobe-Knight --> Cloudkin seer there are enough blink targets and I don't like 1 toughness creatures.
Unseal the Necropolis --> Dreams of steel and oil This was the kind of card I was looking for after BRO, mill and recur.
Khenra Spellspear --> Heartfire Immolator On top of everything else, warrior creature type is relevant.
Kami of Whispered Hopes --> Deepwood Denizen slow ramp but I want that effect in mono green.
Halo Forager --> Vohar, Vodalian Desecrator Insane card cuts are hard.
Stormclaw Rager --> Garna, Bloodfist of Keld more efficient version of a similar effect.
I also like Kami of Whispered Hopes since +1/+1 is very strong in mono green but only secondary in other colours.
Through testing, I have learnt, that sometimes you are just going to have to trust other players in group hug. I need a critical mass of creatures in the deck to make self-mill cards work. So while I am in Jund I had to cut most of my spot removal, so I am just going to have to trust that other players have spot removal and will use any spot removal I give them wisely, e.g Shriekmaw that can't hit the bullies and puts itself in the graveyard.
Drannith Magistrate
Rest in Peace
Stony Silence
Torpor Orb
Suppression field
Blind Obedence
Meekstone
Confounding Conundrum
Damping Sphere
You can have all the lands you like you just can't do anything meaningful with them, there is no fun allowed you will play fair.
I play Dragonlord Ojutai as my commander so I actually have a way to win but if you aren't interested in that GAAIV is a nastier commander.