MTG Salvation

Player Awards:

Best Town Performance (Individual) - Axelrod in Snow White. True to Axelrod form, he sort of does his own thing for Day 1 before using his role in such a way that was absolutely backbreaking for us as the scum team. Clearing Grape was huge because it was a mislunch we needed to potentially win the game and he was able to bury the cayvie slot as well due to JoeTerry's bodyguard.

Best Mafia Performance (Individual) - ZDS in Prison Block. Even though the scum lost this game, I think ZDS's only flaw this game was that he was so townie, he couldn't still be alive in the end.

Best 3rd Party Performance (Individual) - ???

Best Town Performance (Group) - Snow White Mafia. Town absolutely demolished my rag-tag scumteam and the average player quality was fairly high as well.

Best Mafia Performance (Group) - Seasons (ignore this vote if you're not counting self nominations). Team gave me the push I needed to replace in, not post for a month, and then carry it to endgame amongst a star-studded town group. To be fair, the setup also played a large part in that because we had very good control over the mechanics.

Best Town Player - Silvercrys. Every game, even when he doesn't put 100% into it, he dominates. He was operating at like 30% capacity in Snow White and he managed to even catch me in the end.

Best Mafia Player - fulcrum. She's great as town and deadly as scum (though it feels wrong to nominate someone to this when they only have one scum performance..)

Best Overall Player - Rhand. Gotta give this one to the dude who repped us this year and had great town and scum games on MU.

Best Newcomer - Slothful

Most Entertaining Player - CropCircles/Slothful

Most Improved Player - Slothful. God he threw me in such a loop in Seinen 2, even though he was dead to rights

Mod Awards:
Best Design - Snow White. Simple design but I thought it was fairly balanced.
Best Flavor -
Best Role
Best Read - Matter Mafia
Game of the Year - Matter Mafia

I'll touch this up some more later I think

Also think the setup was well balanced in that both the town and mafia had adequate tools to work with/screw the other side over, so props for that.

Need to work on my night action game, which is weird to say because normally that's the easy part.

Yeah this game's pace was real nice compared to the 5000+ post slugfests that have been common recently.

Thanks Axel, your PR usage was strong and you definitely put us in a huge bind. Idk if you read scumchat, but we wanted to speedlunch CC on Day 2 so you couldn't announce your cop result on GF, since we ended up rolecopping you N1.

Yesss talk to me about umineko

Read both of them like 3-4 years ago and I still think they're one of the best gaming/reading experiences

Also mods give me spec chat pls

Imagine rolling scum in every game on this site since 2016 though

That's what tilted me the most about this game

Yeah pretty chill and fun game, low post count which is rare these days

Hopefully I made things somewhat interesting

Certainly made some tactical errors, but pretty happy to end up in f3 after how the first 48 hours of the game started

Looking forward to reading spec chat

GGs y'all

Imagine rolling scum on this hellsite for four years straight

welp

either Amy is just gonna take this free win or I am living in a very bizarre world where HR is scum

Sorry, everyone. Looks like I won't be able to bring this one home.

HIGHROLLER UNVOTE RIGHT NOW

BEFORE AMY GETS BACK INTO THE THREAD

Will be around more tonight but just wanted to say: GD Amy what a frickin brilliant game you and Rodemy played

Not really sure how you planned to off CC/Jack within hours of you replacing in, but it worked and I find myself in yet another "Rhand in Winterfell" situation

Doubt that HR is going to listen to what I have to say but I have to try regardless. Was just really hoping Silver would flip W and the game would be over from there

Glgl y'all

Silver, did we win?

Quote from Highroller »

And yet you continually play follow-the-leader with others and bandwagon? Doesn't work for me.

Again, you're getting way too much right to be trying to take your cues from other people.

I don't really understand why you're accusing me of "bandwagonning" when most of the players in this game have been following each other around. ZDS started suspecting CC; I actively did my own work to try and figure out CC's alignment. Even though I was wrong, I outlined the case on JoeTerry near EoD1, and so on and so forth.

Quote from HR »

I was talking about you.

Yes, you tunneled ZDS, but I felt like you genuinely believed that ZDS was going to flip scum, rather than the shade that CC was posturing.

Vote Silver

Silver, I hope to god you flip scum.

Willing to wait for Amy to answer HR's question, and GF to finish his ISO of me, but I'm still of the opinion that lunching Silver just ends the game in a clean sweep after D1