2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Day 1 - The seven crying dwarves
    I was talking about CC's posts 302 to 304

    And I'm not trying to shade you, I was just hoping to understand why you picked out the posts you did
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Day 1 - The seven crying dwarves
    cayvie are you fully caught up?

    I can sort of understand your thought process looking at the posts you made today, but the posts you pulled out feel a little scattershot.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Day 1 - The seven crying dwarves
    Hello Wake and cayvie.

    We'll see about possible deadline extensions but kind of just want to give replacements room to breathe and then move from there

    Quote from cayvie »
    i feel like i'm missing something, prophylaxis

    are there supposed to be more posts quoted or linked there?
    What post(s) specifically do you have trouble understanding?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Day 1 - The seven crying dwarves
    Quote from Silvercrys »
    He's not saying "Silver you should read CropCircle's posts I think he's a wolf" he's saying "Silver, I think you're suspicious because you aren't town reading CropCircles who is being voted by all of your wolf suspects"

    This is like, kind of why I'm continuing to wolf read you, too, the things you post just do not track with what I'm reading at all.

    It's whatever the opposite of a mind meld is. A mind schism, maybe?

    re: CC, I haven't really gotten anything from his posts so far, no.
    Sure, he's said that he suspects you fairly recently, but from relatively early on in the game he was focused on CropCircles and pressuring him. You don't think he believes that, is what I'm trying to say?

    -----------

    Quote from Ampharos »
    also leaning town on silvercrys, largely for how he responded to the early proph post that caused such a stir. he nailed the sweet spot of what i'll call "measured skepticism", where his reaction to proph looks like legitimate doubt - not a conspicuous underreaction, not a forced overreaction, but a legitimate natural questioning brought on by reading the posts. tl;dr villagery reaction
    Okay, so I can buy that his reaction in 53 looks like legitimate thought, but I don't really follow why you think it's a villagery reaction. Like, I can see worlds where scum Silver is confused about what I'm saying but wants me to say more. Can you expand a little more on this (and also what you think of the rest of Silver's posts)?

    FTR I have Silver as a hard null right now/maybe very slightly leaning scum

    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Day 1 - The seven crying dwarves
    Quote from Grapefruit21 »

    At the time Terry being so low, ZDS being so low, Rod and DK being so high were the main things.

    Because it would have been really easy to ignore that vote by Rod due to the posting restriction and Rod's general reputation. Digging deeper shows a nice curiosity.
    dk was kind of in the smack middle there, you think that was "that high"? I guess maybe since you actively think he is mafia

    Fair point on JT, not completely sure if I buy it but I thiiiiiink I like your thought process coming to that read?


    -----

    okay so here's CC's three big posts of content

    idk if I buy it? his town/scum list feels fairly inoffensive to me - it's hard to really track his thoughts wrt his townreads of me, silver, and GF. the real intriguing part of his readslist to me, and the part where you can sorta see the wheels churning in cropcircle's head, is the section on JT

    the part about JT being slightly defeatist/defensive tracks with how he ended his posts on both me and Silver:

    Quote from JoeTerry »
    Come on, Silver, you know deep down inside what I'm saying is true. You probably feel self-conscious about it and that's why you're voting me right now. You wish you've been posting a bit better but haven't got bitten by this game yet.

    Quote from JoeTerry »
    Hope that helps, I doubt it will because you already seem like you're tunneled. It's almost a sure thing that anyone who posts anything substantial like I did to catch up, will be attacked because it's content, content that people can like or dislike. You can like or dislike what I said, but I'm putting myself out there and giving my thoughts, I'm not hiding.


    don't really know how i feel when CC posts stuff that warrants JT suspicion but ends it on the "i'll give it a pass for now". like, if they're buddies, this has to be... like TOO blatant

    I will say that he brings up solid reasoning for suspecting dkings and Jack. It's a shame that both replaced out because then I can't really track how CC interrogates people he suspects. Ehhhh.

    The fact that it's taken CC this long to provide some sort of content is kind of telling, and he's still not very inquisitive or scumhunting really? I'll keep reading on but I wouldn't cry if he was lynched. Idk if this is the right word for it but his post feels.. a little crafted? [here are some inoffensive townreads], [some people who I also suspect who are generally suspected by the players at large besides dkings]?

    I'd appreciate more thoughts on his trio of posts there.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Day 1 - The seven crying dwarves
    following up to JT's responses to my Qs

    Quote from JoeTerry »
    1) Ok, first off it's post 20, are you really diving that deep? That being said, I didn't feel drawing a distinction between Highroller's claim and Rod's justified a vote on ZDS, which he straight up says was to end RVS, which could be interpreted as forcing.
    uhhh, i'm a little confused here

    You're saying that drawing the distinction between Rodemy's roleplaying and Highroller's claim could be interpreted as forcing? You literally said that you thought it "seemed forced". Why are you now saying "it could be interpreted as forcing"? It could be me misunderstanding things but the fact that you're wording this from a third-party POV "it could be interpreted as forcing" doesn't make me feel good

    Got it, re the posts you are agreeing with me on. Kind of a nitpicky question but why did you highlight specifically post 130? I reread that post and it was me bringing up Rodemy meta from 6 years ago, calling myself a ZDS stan, and then asking CC some questions. Don't specifically see what exactly in that post is so agreeable unless you liked my questions or something? (Or the "ignoring Rodemy because he's Rodemy", though I suppose that point is moot now that he is Amy)

    Quote from JT »
    4) Jack's catch up looks like he's analyzing the game. You don't have to agree with him but you could at least see that he's looking critically at the game.
    I.. really don't think he was thinking about the game super duper critically? I and others have pointed out a fair number of problems with his posts.

    I guess you can call me tunneled but I think that's fine for Day 1? Interrogate someone, find problems with their responses, and force them to explain themself is what I've been doing for most of Today and I think it's provided me with some success (depending on what you/CC/Jackslot flips I guess)
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Day 1 - The seven crying dwarves
    Can we get a DL extension with all these replacements
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Day 1 - The seven crying dwarves
    I request that vote count simply be redone by hand rather than using the outdated vote counter

    Will respond to stuff when I'm not on mobile, but ZDS - I meant something a little different when I asked Silver if he disagreed with your main argument. I'll explain more later

    Just from a quick skim I like Amy's posts and content
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Day 1 - The seven crying dwarves
    That vote count is all sorts of wrong lmao

    I voted CropCircles a while back and haven't moved my vote since then

    Plus JT is listed as not voting CC when he is, dkings is supposed to be voting for me instead of voting GF
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Day 1 - The seven crying dwarves
    Yoooooooooooooooooooooooo

    Have we actually played together before Amy? (Also can I still call you Wals?)
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Day 1 - The seven crying dwarves
    Thanks Grape for the kind words. Smile I always try to make collaboration the most important part of my playstyle, because I think it's more important to have the town communicate clearly and work together rather than focus too much on reads accuracy.

    Points noted on CC, did not consider that. Can you answer the other two questions I had in that post? (what exactly you disagree on re Silver and why you liked JT's call out of Rodemy)

    I see JT responded to me, I'll take a look at that after work hopefully
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Day 1 - The seven crying dwarves
    Silver: so uhh, you don't agree/understand the central premise of zds's argument? (that cropcircles is a bad guy and deserves to be looked into more)

    again, the intentionally vague thing makes it hard to figure out exactly what you're thinking, but do you have any thoughts on CC's 10 or so posts thus far? i see you have him as a null read but i don't recall you talking about him, skimming through your ISO

    Quote from Axelrod »
    You sucked up to me! Or just complemented my later game.

    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Day 1 - The seven crying dwarves
    talk to me about why you think zds is still scum? like, his posts haven't moved the needle for you at all?

    (also mods, is deadline friday?)
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Day 1 - The seven crying dwarves
    All fair points.

    Was just trying to put myself in the shoes of scum JT there and thought "would scum!JT really pick a fight with one of the more townread players in this game"

    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Day 1 - The seven crying dwarves
    Quote from CropCircles »
    Well you did refer to me as a living legend.

    Not disagreeing with the sentiment, just saying.

    Currently rereading, but it is late. Will compile my thoughts tomorrow.
    Link

    I am eagerly waiting for your thoughts.

    ------------------------------------

    kinda fine with cc/jack wagons, really not sure why people are voting zds and i think there's a decent chance there's scum on that wagon (cc/rod/maaaybe silver?)

    hottake is that if cc is scum, jt is bussing him

    feels kinda weird that the two players that i'd like to interrogate most (jack/cc) have mostly been silent for the past 2-3 days or so

    kinda side-eyeing rodemy for bringing up the same point from rvs continuously as a reason to pressure zds, and i'm not sure exactly why silver is voting ZDS (other than to consolidate wagons?) given that silver hasn't really engaged with ZDS past rvs

    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.