So my case turned more into a re-read, which is full of quotes and largely inconclusive. LMNOP didn't play at all, and Prophy barely played, with most of his posts being largely void of content.
Prophy certainly isn't on my town-side, but he hasn't done anything overtly scummy.
I have to agree with AthiestGod, Rhand's post against the mass name claim definitely seems suspicious. That being said, I do have to agree with him that a name claim would not be useful because even with the little knowledge of the flavor I have, I know that everyone wants the headmaster dead so names would probably not matter.
Barns AG, repeats something that's already been said re: flavourgaming. One of two "content" posts.
So my main scum reads are IB, PG and Tom. IB is just active lurking and barning everybody as well as doing nonsensical posts. I hated PG's active lurking and strange posts early game. Also he's fencesitting hard. Tom failed to vote Iso because he thought he was scum until FO backed him up for the Iso vote, and with an ally on his side Tom votes Iso. 289.
EtR's posts feel like "going down the wall of posts, offering comments on each one". I originally thought him as scum because he tried to pick off low hanging fruit. His posts are looking better, so I have him as null for now.
Iso will always be null to me. I have no idea how to read this guy. He plays insane as scum and town.
Misting's early posts are town to me, but I don't really like Mistings short but content filled posts, inherently scummy to me. Town don't need to craft big posts, because they don't need to seem town. They are town!
I don't really understand the FO case but I skipped Iso's post 660, I will read it when I have more time.
I also skipped the PG v. Rhand court case enclosed in a cute little spoiler. I really don't care for arguments that are formatted bold in quotes.
What is a townslip?
Ehh, for Rhand, I found one of his posts scummy (187) but his later posts haven't pinged my scumdar.
Those are the players that jumped out to me. When I have more time I'll case IB, but I don't think I will be able to accurately pursue a case on him until Day 2. I'm willing to vote Tom - his later posts basically are replying to other people, "ISO IS SCUM !!1" and defending himself.
I support a lynch on Tom. If he flips scum, then Iso IMO is confirmed town and that's a huge boon for us; if he flips town, then that will give us a wealth of information on Iso and other players that I can't name on the top of my head.
Vote Tom
@AG: "no content"? Also, can you please point out specific Wessel posts at how he's running the game behind the scenes? I have him marked down as leaning town for the Tom case, but I don't really remember the rest of his posts.
@Tom: I understand where you're coming from. Iso's really good at just chomping you up so that you're left with zero morale to post. See Triskelion Mafia Day 3 for an example of this.
I feel like the questions you've been making are technicalities and still concerning yourself, though. "Why do you consider it a waste?" "How is that scummy, exactly?" "What would you call my last two posts, then?" "How am I twisting your words?" "So you stating it makes it true? Also, if not legitimate, why do you yourself refer to it as a 'slip'?" are ones I scoured around page 24 for.
Also right now any mention of "Iso's case" you've been making translated into my brain "Wessel's case, which Iso barned".
@EtR: Judging by his blog, only in pinkfloyd's game.
@PG: Sometime on Day 2 (or even right now, if you have time), point out AG's "bull and blanket statements", please?
Information lynches are typically scum-motivated, but I can see where you would be coming from on this particular one.
Unless we can get a group collaboration to shift all of our votes to PG/IB, my vote will remain on Tom. I think my vote will be rendered useless if I vote for PG or IB. I don't really see the FO case and I can't read Iso. Tom's earlier posts still bear a lot of weight on me, in particular 297.
I'll case up IB during the night, but I noticed that he was active lurking and barning everybody as well as doing nonsensical posts while I was doing my initial trek through the thread.
Tom, why are you deflecting your lynch?
Still offering to case me. Still no case. Null, but I'd like to see the case.
@Wessel: Talking about the speed of wagons is scummy. Pushing against an overwhelming lynch is an easy way to look pro-town as scum, which makes me think that you know what he flips.
This has sorta shifted my perception of Wessel. I'll have to reread him over night.
This post is the opposite. Analyzing the speed of a very fast wagon is scummy enough to shift your perception? He was my number one town read all game, so that seems very off to me.
@Rhand: I stated the reason in my post. "I didn't want to vote pg today because we already had 2 claims and I believe strongly that one of them is scum.
But since pg claimed anyway, I don't see a reason not to hammer him." is super scummy.
I mean, you didn't even announce that you were going to hammer PG. You just showed up and hammered out of nowhere.
Vote Rhand
Rhand quickhammers, Prophy votes Rhand day 2. Still no other content. This post is fine, but worth noting for later interactions between Prophy and Rhand.
Sorry for all the hullabaloo about making a case when it's totally inconclusive. Also, I need to stop procrastinating my homework.
Oh, the "pretty much" thing is as bad as Tom's fractions. It's absurd. The only reason Iso would be scum is WIFOM.
<3 you Iso. You're probably scum this game anyway, because I'm sure you're town.
Proph case is still being worked on; I have about three hours of homework to trudge through (Critical Annotated Bibliography, anyone?) so once I finish that, I'll wrap up my case on Proph.
@EtR: I said I was willing to consider TMCT and KCC as town because I was assuming TMCT's role and actions claimed were true. That said, the most recent events out all of our PRs which I don't really like.
-_-
I'm still in favour of a Maokun/DDS/Shark scumteam. That seems the most reasonable to me.
Hey there. Try going up to Xanadu in Arbutus or down to Games and Stuff in Glen Burnie. Both are great shops with loads of people who love to test. Don't let those among us who are a little abrasive put you off.
Welcome to Sally!
My mafia time has become suddenly limited because of new responsibilities at work. I would, however, like everyone to know I'm building an LMNOP/Prophy case.
Wessel, I looked at your MTG case, and all those posts you called Tezz scum for are scummy. I've found him scummy since I replaced in tho, so maybe I'm not the right person to ask this from.
About Kankennon: You've got a very good point in that he would've been on the Maokun wagon if he was scum and not his buddy. That narrows down my list of possible scum teams, which is good
New list of possible teams: Team 1: KCC, TMCT and MTG-DDS Team 2: Maokun, iPot, MTG-DDS Team 3: Maokun, Kankennon, MTG-DDS Team 4: iPot, IB, MTG-DDS Team 5: iPot, EtR, MTG-DDS Team 6: iPot, IB, EtR Team 7: IB, EtR, MTG-DDS
He's reasonably experienced. At least as experienced as I am, if not more.
I begrudgingly accept this condition. -_-
Prophy certainly isn't on my town-side, but he hasn't done anything overtly scummy.
I quoted this one for lulz and because it's a prototypical LMNOP post, completely void of content.
Barns AG, repeats something that's already been said re: flavourgaming. One of two "content" posts.
Unvotes AG because RVS, restates the top suspects for everyone, and says that they're his top suspects. Cool.
I think there was another post (or two) in here where Prophy basically says "I'm not caught up, I'll post more later". Whatever.
Offers to case me, still waiting for case.
Information lynches are typically scum-motivated, but I can see where you would be coming from on this particular one.
Still offering to case me. Still no case. Null, but I'd like to see the case.
I actually really, really like this post and it is the number one reason I'm questioning my read.
This post is the opposite. Analyzing the speed of a very fast wagon is scummy enough to shift your perception? He was my number one town read all game, so that seems very off to me.
Rhand quickhammers, Prophy votes Rhand day 2. Still no other content. This post is fine, but worth noting for later interactions between Prophy and Rhand.
Sorry for all the hullabaloo about making a case when it's totally inconclusive. Also, I need to stop procrastinating my homework.
<3 you Iso. You're probably scum this game anyway, because I'm sure you're town.
Proph case is still being worked on; I have about three hours of homework to trudge through (Critical Annotated Bibliography, anyone?) so once I finish that, I'll wrap up my case on Proph.
-_-
I'm still in favour of a Maokun/DDS/Shark scumteam. That seems the most reasonable to me.
Same. Sies.
Welcome to Sally!
I always knew ZDS was a Seppel gimmick.
/replace (but not if Maokun is /in. Ew. <3)
Only if you'll be our third.
Quinten Hoover
/barn this.
That's quite the 180, scumkun.