You do realize that white and red are the only two colors that Wizards consistently gives LD too, right? Sundering Titan gives more to blue than to R and W.
sharum is a creature that dies. artis and noble create a similar effect kill all. also while the combo is not going off they provide something other than a useless 1/1
If you're playing Sharuum you probably have more artifacts than creatures. Also 1/1>0/1
The same thing that prevents us from running 4 of each card in EDH. It's against the rules. Saying "well I'll just pick and choose the rules" isn't a game. It's the same as playing chess and having your pawns move like knights. Sure you can...but you're not playing at that point.
Ban list is suggested. EDH is player-based format. Yada, yada, yada.
Disciple of the Vault kills. All-out combo would probably include Ordeal and Artist too though.
also it has time sieve and artifacts. plus most of hegemons pieses interlock, except for mike and trike. i dont know where that one came from, i have never seen before on a tuned list.
Time Sieve is normally associated with the Sword/Foundry combo. Not sure why he said Altar...
The fact that Hermit Druid still hasn't been banned makes me think that it has to be someone's pet card. 99% of the time he doesn't create interesting game states, he either gets removed or flips someone's deck over and they proceed to win the game. Sure you can play him fairly but even in decks with basics you're still essentially getting a massive self mill for pretty much free.
I've seen plenty of people play it fairly. Sure it's a powerful card even when it's not being used to combo out (e.g. Karador, Mimeoplasm), but you don't really see people playing Hermit Druid decks in casual games. If they do people just don't play with them, and then Hey, nice couple-thousand pile of cardboard you've got there.
I know players are excited about Murder because it's the first unconditional card of it's ilk, but we've had Rend Flesh for a while now. Even with it's non-spirit condition, I think it still might out-class Murder due to it's casting cost being more friendly to multi-colored decks. Only relevant Spirits I am aware of are the Star dragons and the Muses.
I like Chill to the Bone, but Murder is awesome. All we need now is a BBB: "Destroy target creature, it can't be regenerated."
I like Crusader of Odric, Archeomancer, Talrand, Smelt, Firewing Pheonix, Beast Tracker, and Ranger's Path.
It would be hilarious if Wizards gave us all of these shockland hints and then didn't reprint/make new ones.
You do realize that white and red are the only two colors that Wizards consistently gives LD too, right? Sundering Titan gives more to blue than to R and W.
If you're playing Sharuum you probably have more artifacts than creatures. Also 1/1>0/1
Ban list is suggested. EDH is player-based format. Yada, yada, yada.
Disciple of the Vault kills. All-out combo would probably include Ordeal and Artist too though.
Time Sieve is normally associated with the Sword/Foundry combo. Not sure why he said Altar...
Other people draw their decks. You don't because of your Eldrazi.
Fairly unreliable win condition because it assumes nobody else is playing Eldrazi.I've seen plenty of people play it fairly. Sure it's a powerful card even when it's not being used to combo out (e.g. Karador, Mimeoplasm), but you don't really see people playing Hermit Druid decks in casual games. If they do people just don't play with them, and then Hey, nice couple-thousand pile of cardboard you've got there.
Except without haste...
Talrand and Krenko are awesome, Yeva and Nefarox seem slightly underwhelming.
EDIT: Wait, no I don't. Here.
I like Chill to the Bone, but Murder is awesome. All we need now is a BBB: "Destroy target creature, it can't be regenerated."
I like Crusader of Odric, Archeomancer, Talrand, Smelt, Firewing Pheonix, Beast Tracker, and Ranger's Path.
It would be hilarious if Wizards gave us all of these shockland hints and then didn't reprint/make new ones.
The retrace draw spell? Oona's Grace, I think?
Meekstone is awesome.
How do you feel about? It's always put me in ridiculous positions.
Two of the coolest things I've ever done with it were:
Casting it on a Graveborn Muse
Casting it on an opponent's Primeval while I had 3 ninjas in hand.
IMO it's pretty good in the Big-Splashy-Monster format.