Well, for one thing, this is a rare. I don't think this is getting anywhere CLOSE to the best rare in limited. Did you play during fate reforged? I played during fate reforged.Quote from Faruel »I am not talking about constructed. I think the card is perfectly fine there but in limited? You will get 7 planeswalker in the Prerelease package and most player will end up with playing at least 2. This card is totally bonkers and unfair. You can't compare this with wrath of God. This is a one sited, 2 cc planeswalker wrath with upside. Even if your opponent doesn't play any planeswalker you can destroy your own to reach a ultimate. Not even a death card if your opponent doesn't play any planeswalker. I can't see why the spot removal wasn't enough for limited. There are solid removal spell even at common.
For a second thing, you just said yourself - running around 2 walkers? I mean, is plummet a hideously broken limited card? Also costs 2 and kills something most decks will have a couple of, and probably at a decent mana advantage. Sure, this can get you 2 loyalty, but that won't be a major deal unless you have a rare+ walker close to ulting, which is a lot less likely than an uncommon one where you just get decent value. And compared to flyers, they'll probably get immediate value out of their pw first, which most flyers will not.
Anytime your "broken rare" can be reasonably compared to plummet...you might be overreacting just a smidge.