2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • 1

    posted a message on The Legacy Price Discussion Thread
    Quote from itachiitachi »
    Prices hardly dropped at all for anything in MM the only thing that really dropped where causal cards and uncommons. I'm sure EMA will have an effect as legacy cards prices are more about scarcity than demand and people are buying this set based on hype/lottery tickets despite it being a losing proposition.

    I don't think I want to get too invested into the debate going on currently, but I feel the need to point out that there were several cards that dropped quite a bit due to Modern Masters. Fulminator Mages dropped to about $15-20 easily; they were closer to $30+. Now they're back up to $17-25, but if you're diligent and picked them up within the first several months, you'd have saved a decent bit. Dark Confidant is now $40 instead of the $75 it was at. Yeah, it did take 2 printings in MM1 and MM2 to lower, but the fact of the matter is it's still cheaper now. Same exact thing for Vendilion Clique, who's also sitting at $35. Spellskite was closer to $20 easily back when it got reprinted in MM2. It's up again to $30, yes, but the price did dip for a solid time. I even got a foil Skite for $30 card value 1-2 months after release. Emrakul was reaching $40-50 easily. Now it can be had for $27-30 (it's only recently been going up again because of Nahiri in Modern). Cryptic Command was easily $50 before MM1. After MM1, sadly, still remained $35-40, yes, but it still deflated some. Then from there it got reprinted a second time and is now easily had for $25. Remand used to be a $15+ card even after reprint in a Duel Deck. It's easily had for $5 now.

    Pretty much all the listings that I posted were mid values. If you wanted to buy, you can get it for a few bucks cheaper still.

    Upon the announcement of reprint, Wasteland started dropping from its ~$65 price tag to easily 50. And now? Wasteland from Eternal Masters is about $47 mid -- and if you shop around and want to spend cash, then you can actually get it for about $35-37. That's way less now. No, it's not reprinted into the ground (sure would be nice and all...I guess), but roughly $35 is much less than $65+. I remember I picked my 2 Tempest copies up a while ago for closer to $100...the card's weird because it had a tendency to cool then rise again; I think the card stabilized around $65-75 though. Anyway, there's plenty of cards that lowered. Jace, the Mind Sculptor can be had for $65 now, from its $75-80+ tag. Kinda wish Force of Wills were cheaper, but hey, it's a lynchpin card in the format -- at Mythic no less, so what do you expect?

    So...I'm not sure how low is good enough for you, but in my eyes, EMA has done its job. I wish the packs weren't so expensive; I'd really like to draft it more than like, 2 times. But all the cheap commons/uncommons had their values nuked, and the rares had a decent bit of value lost too. If nothing else, there's at least a little more supply now.
    Posted in: Market Street Café
  • 1

    posted a message on Nahiri, the Harbinger
    Quote from Equinox2793 »
    Has anyone had success with Nahiri and Ral Zarek/ Gideon Jura? Both seem to have great synergy with the tap down effect.

    Though there's never anything wrong with asking, I don't really see why a "combo" with Nahiri + Tapdown effect is necessary -- or even effective ever; the card cmc's are just pretty darn high. If you can jam Nahiri's and you still have space for some more finishers (and elect to play Gideon/Ral), then I'm sure the synergy is apparent and will more likely be incidental. Not because the combination is particularly amazing or ingenious; they just merely situationally complement each other, much like how Serum Visions and Nahiri work together well. I guess what I'm saying is, if Ral Zarek and Gideon Jura haven't already begun making waves in Modern, then I doubt Nahiri would push them any further.

    To answer your question though, Francis Cellona's 9th place list at GP LA played a singleton Tamiyo, the Moon Sage, which is a tap-down effect. I'd imagine there were scenarios that came about, where the synergy between Nahiri and Tamiyo was fine (or even better). That said, he posted in the UWR Control thread and said that Tamiyo was the worst card in the deck by far. We can deduce that Ral and Gideon would probably yield similar results.
    Posted in: Modern
  • 4

    posted a message on [Primer] Jeskai Control / UWR Control
    Quote from LeakyMana »
    I imagine the title and summary (Two-Time Pro Tour Finalist Shaun McLaren loves him some Jeskai, but the deck's stock is already falling after its recent victory! Find out why Shaun thinks this is a new reality and what lists he's brewing to counteract the metagame!) are meant to be click-bait-y, but is there anything of interest in Shaun McLaren's SCG Premium article "The Jeskai is Falling"?


    It is indeed a click bait title. I have premium from Charlotte, so I got to read it; in the comments he admits it himself (well...kinda; he's pretty serious about what he wrote; he's not trying to trick anyone -- just spun the title so that way it'd sound more interesting). To be fair, he does mention that Francis made 9th place. Here's the direct copy-pasta of the two comments:

    Sheridan Lardner · Data and Program Evaluation Manager at Alternatives, Inc.
    "I enjoyed the analysis of Jeskai as a strategy, but think the discussion about "Jeskai decks currently struggling to put up results" is really off-base. Francis missed the GP T8 by .018 on breakers, and if .018 is the difference between "struggling" and "viable" we need to re-examine our definition of competitiveness. Jeskai decks also saw more collective paper play in May than every deck except Infect, Jund, and RG Tron, and was the third most-played Day 2 deck at the GPs. The deck over-performed its Day 2 rate into the Top 32 and matched its rate going into the Top 16. Overall, Jeskai may have room to grow, but it's very well-positioned from a metagame standpoint as we go into June."
    Unlike · Reply · 4 · 16 hrs

    Shaun McLaren:
    "I agree with what you're saying I also think the deck was hyped up and failed to live up to the hype.

    If it's one of the most played decks and failing to put up Top 8's (even though it's an arbitrary cut off point) that supports that idea. But the sample size is small and not that revealing.

    From a writing standpoint I think it's more interesting if I frame it as “The Jeskai is falling! Jeskai isn't dominating here's what I think needs to happen to propel it to the top.” rather than “Everything is pretty much average, Jeskai is decent, here's my lists, carry on with your life!” Either way the meat of the article would've been the same.

    But you're absolutely right and good points!"

    Quote from toroks »
    Quote from LeakyMana »
    I imagine the title and summary (Two-Time Pro Tour Finalist Shaun McLaren loves him some Jeskai, but the deck's stock is already falling after its recent victory! Find out why Shaun thinks this is a new reality and what lists he's brewing to counteract the metagame!) are meant to be click-bait-y, but is there anything of interest in Shaun McLaren's SCG Premium article "The Jeskai is Falling"?


    What does his decklist look like? (Don't have premium)

    Three deck lists, actually. General theme is that he's trying to see if he can move away from Ancestral Vision and Emrakul, the Aeons Torn. Apparently he doesn't really like AV, and he thinks Emmy is kind of a dead draw. He'd rather sideboard the card instead; idk if that makes any sense -- I think it's a play main or bust, honestly (siding it out is fine; siding it in seems sketch).

    Jeskai Control (His personal take on Francis Cellona's list)


    Jeskai Aggro:


    Kiki Control:
    Posted in: Modern Archives - Proven
  • 1

    posted a message on [Primer] Jeskai Control / UWR Control
    Quote from jesselloyd »
    They would need multiple lords for it not to work. Other than that it doesn't hit Displacer, Kird Ape and Nacatl? And what is the exile clause relevant against? Delve isn't in colours that we want anger against anyways. Anger's exile seems good against E-witness decks but I still think it might be worth testing a singleton pyroclasm main.

    Abzan CoCo (Kitchen Finks, Voice of Resurgence, etc.). Hell, having all of their creatures exiled is good. Makes Reveillark worse. E-Witness has less options to get back.
    Dredge decks. Bloodghast, Gravecrawler, Dreg Mangler, Vengevine.
    Abzan Midrange decks: Kitchen Finks and Voice of Resurgence.
    Jeskai Ascendancy: Sylvan Caryatid.

    Kitchen Finks and Voice of Resurgences' existence alone are enough to warrant Anger over Pyroclasm. Do try Pyroclasm though and let us know how it goes. It's not inherently a bad card.

    Sidenote: One neat thing with Kozilek's Return is that it can kill Etched Champion (because of Devoid).
    Posted in: Modern Archives - Proven
  • 1

    posted a message on The Legacy Price Discussion Thread
    Quote from Sirius_B »
    I guess I't easy for people who's interest in MtG is "investment" rather than playing, to ignore when eternal players say their problem with the game isn't that they don't have the cards, but that they don't have enough opponents who have the cards to play against.

    ^100% This.

    Sure it'd be sad to have my $250+ Underground Seas tank down to $50. You know what's sadder? To have no one to play with, regardless of how much I paid to get into the format. Sometimes makes me wonder why I bothered buying into the format in the first place.

    Luckily it's summer and there's several shops nearby. But still...
    Posted in: Market Street Café
  • 1

    posted a message on [Primer] Jeskai Control / UWR Control
    Quote from esdawt »
    I have a deck I am looking for input put on please. And sorry, not a Nihiri deck.
    Sideboard (15)
    1x Supreme Verdict
    1x Negate
    1x Izzet Staticaster
    2x Disenchant
    2x Crumble to Dust
    1x Stony Silence
    1x Keranos, God of Storms
    1x Anger of the Gods
    1x Dispel
    2x Spellskite
    2x Engineered Explosives[/deck]
    Not a single match win, and it's getting frustrating. What could I do with my set up to try and tip the scales in my favour? I've got friends who say I am running too many 4CC in the deck, so I was thinking of removing a Supreme Verdict and Pia and Kiran to replace with something. What about a main deck Kitchen Finks, and one in the side somewhere? I also have a Scalding Tarn I could probably put in there too, I just wasn't sure what land to replace. Any thoughts would be most appreciated.

    What you could do in the main is go up to 4th Lightning Helix if you're really having trouble. The main issue I see your list having is that the sideboard doesn't have any anti-burn cards. Other than Spellskite, yes, but I'm thinking something more along the lines of Timely Reinforcements and Kor Firewalker. Those are traditionally pretty good at dealing with burn. Spellskite can only blank so much removal, and it also dies to Destructive Revelry. Kor Firewalker might not be as good against certain Burn/Zoo variants, because Burn and Zoo decks have gotten better about diversifying their main and sideboards to get around the card. And Skullcrack can sometimes blowout Kor Firewalker. Lastly Timely Reinforcements gets rekt by Atarka's Command and Skullcrack. So all 3 options listed do have their counters; however, with smart play, they should give you a lot of mileage against Burn. Kitchen Finks isn't bad either. Dispel and Negate are decent too. Explosives and sweepers are decent against them, though I'd rather have life gain cards. Batterskull and Baneslayer Angel are decent options too. Batterskull dies to artifact destruction, but try to have 3 mana up to avoid having it get destroyed. Baneslayer loses to Path -- if they side in any. Leyline of Sanctity from the sideboard is also pretty good.

    Quote from akwing00 »
    I'm not sure how to side against more control decks (like the mirror), combo, and midrange decks like Jund.

    Here's my deck list which I've based on a few of the lists I've seen on starcity, some of the pro's who have been streaming the deck as well, and from some comments in this thread.



    With your current setup, against control I'd side in Dispel x2, Negate x2, and Vendilion Clique. I'd side out Anger and some number of Bolts/Helix. Aven Mindcensor wouldn't be the worst thing to side in against control, because of a flash threat. But just depends if you actually have something worth siding out.

    Totally depends on the combo deck you're facing. But I'd side in more or less the same kinds of cards as if I'm playing against control (Dispel, Negate, Clique, Mindcensor for decks that like to search like Tron and Scapeshift). Crumble to Dust isn't the worst card to play against control and combo, so if you can find room, you can stick the card in.

    Midrange decks like Jund and Junk: I like Anger, Supreme Verdict, Timely Reinforcements (not the best, but not bad). Against Junk, I don't really like Bolt/Helix. Against Jund it's ok. Electrolyze is decent against Junk's Lingering Souls. I like Izzet Staticaster vs. them too. Negate isn't a bad call if you're afraid of Planeswalkers or frustrating non-creature cards.

    You don't have it in your board, but I like haymakers like Elspeth, Sun's Champion vs. basically all the match-ups you were asking about (except combo). Also, Celestial Purge is another mainstay that I personally love having access to. Counterflux and Engineered Explosives are also decent cards. Though Counterflux is odd...universally almost always good or at least never "dead." No more dead than any other counters. At the same time, it's not a silver bullet type of sideboard card that heavily slant the match-up in your favor.
    Posted in: Modern Archives - Proven
  • 1

    posted a message on [[Official]] Trade Evaluation -- Pile A versus B

    Pile A not even close. Gaea's Cradle is reserved list, meanwhile Rishadan Port is not. Cradle is foreign language...not sure if this adds more or subtracts some value. Depends from player to player.

    But man...if Sylvan Library is really Black-bordered (from Legends), then 1 Cradle + 1 Library is enough for the 3 Rishadan port. You're just giving the other cards away for free. Of course, if you NEED Ports, then it's ok, I guess because you do get 3 of the 4 you'll need. I still wouldn't trade those other stuff though.
    Posted in: Market Street Café
  • 1

    posted a message on [Primer] UWr Midrange
    Happened upon this list while skimming through all the Top 8 States lists.

    4th place list at States.
    4x Geist, Nalaar parents, 4x Serum Visions, 2x Cryptic Commands

    Main things I took away from that list. I'm too lazy to keep looking for other Geists list right now. Maybe later. For a while though, I've been really wanting to convert to either Jeskai Thopters/Kiki or Gifts Thopter though...lol they seem like loads of fun with new toys.
    Posted in: Midrange
  • 1

    posted a message on Does Jace, Unraveler of Secrets have a place in Modern?
    Quote from Cody_X »
    Jace's -2 is not as good as chandras -x. It just isnt. Thats not the point though. scry 1 draw 1 is almost always better than wheeling your entire hand. Jace even goes up in loyalty when he draws.
    At 4 plus mana, he does do an awful lot. He provides a solid amount of value, drawing you cards and getting cards you don't want off the top. He can bounce any creature so you can get value, or counter it on the way back down. His ulti, which is possibly one of the more obtainable ultimates on a walker, is pretty gamewinning in the decks I've played him in.
    Sure, if you're staring down a pair of goyfs, hes not the best top deck. Is keranos better? Is chandra better? Probably not. Planeswalkers as cards aren't equipped to deal with several large creatures if they're late to the party. There just aren't really any walkers you can play that effectively deal with situations like that, and most of the walkers that can deal with them are unplayable in other regards.
    On empty boards and stalemates, Jace is pretty strong. Decks like blue moon and faeries are both quite capable of getting the game into such a state, and playing a jace to follow up a moon, or a mistbind clique, or some such card is a very powerful play.

    Well...Elspeth, Sun's Champion can do it. Her -3 trashes on big creatures, and her +1 clogs the board hard. I also feel like on empty board states and stalemates, Elspeth just outshines most other planeswalkers. Sure, she's 1 mana more expensive, but time and again, she's proven to be solid enough to see play in mainboard and sideboard of UWx decks.

    Of course, this is assuming the deck in question is also running white.

    Quote from CryptoSC »
    i play jace as a 1 of in my blue moon deck and when i land him he usually wins me the game, not on the spot but with a additional draw aswell as a scry each turn with the potential to remove any threats that slip through the cracks i usually have no issue locking down my oponent with counters and removal untill i can ult jace at wich point i win.

    Most commonly i play him on turn 5, minus him to remove any threat my oponent might have (if not i start plussing right away), then untap and deal with whatever my oponent dropped while i was tapped out while plusing him untill he´s in ult range.

    I don´t think he is mainboard material though, i just have him there to better test him, he might replace Jace AoT in the sideboard though, he costs one more but is way better at what he does


    If you two are that adamant about him, I might just give him a spin and test him myself. I have a hard time understanding what role he falls under and why he should be played over something like Elspeth, Sun's Champion or Keranos...but I guess it's worth trying before passing final judgment.

    In your opinion, why does this one outperform Jace, Architect of Thought? I feel like the Architect's dig ability is better than this new Jace.
    Posted in: Modern
  • 1

    posted a message on Shadows Over Innistrad price speculations
    Honestly, I feel like all cards in the set are poised to fall, save for a few select ones. Simply due to more cards being opened from packs. In my eyes, only Avacyn is gonna stick around her current price point (and maybe Sorin too). But this is just a hunch. I mean, Tireless Trackers and Traverse the Ulvenwalds might stay their price too. Tireless, because he's seeing a decent bit of standard play. And Traverse just seems like a solid card. As for the cards you mentioned:

    Quote from ShadowFenril »
    Sorin, Grim Nemesis seems to be the Planeswalker to have from the set. Out of Arlinn, Jace, and Nahiri his price is the only one that doesn't seem to be budging, despite people crapping on him when he was spoiled for being too expensive and not doing anything when you're behind (which I disagree with). Is he seeing any significant play?

    I think he's seeing decent play. Not amazingly a lot, but he's seeing a fair bit of play. I would say that he's gonna stick around at $20. If anything, he might fall a little to like, $16 or something. But for the most part, I don't see him falling due to lack of play; I think he's one of the more valuable cards in the set.

    Quote from ShadowFenril »
    Jace, Unraveler of Secrets. Been called a bad Ob Nixilis, but Jace definitely has a track record of being a powerful and underrated Planeswalker. He's had a few incarnations that didn't pan out, but his +1 to scry and draw just seems so good. He's only $13 now. Ob's hanging around $10. Could Jace really go lower than that?

    I don't actually know how much play he's seeing at all. Idk, I think he's better than Jace, the Living Guildpact, but slightly worse than Jace, Memory Adept. In other words, he's..."ok." Jace, Vryn's Prodigy is probably gonna play in this guy's place. I know you can technically play both, but I doubt anyone will do it. Control shells with Thing in the Ice will still probably just run Jace, Vryn's Prodigy before they think of playing Unraveler. Unraveler of Secret's mana cost blows, and he's barely better than some of his previous iterations (Jace Beleren, Memory Adept, etc.). Get the Unraveler if you like him, but I think he'll fall a few more dollars. Probably to $10 in the short term. Really just depends on whether or not you care to save the extra few dollars.

    Quote from ShadowFenril »
    Nahiri, the Harbinger. Don't like her ultimate or the tapped restriction for her artifact exile, but a 2 mana walker that +2 to filter seems ok to me. She's $10 and slipping fast. I don't know, she just feels undervalued to me. I don't know that there's a deck that wants her right now.

    IMO she has a lot of potential to be good, but I don't think there's a shell for her yet. Nor do I think there will be a shell (at least, not until Eldrich Moon comes out). And because of this, she might fall further. To $7 or $8. Now, apparently in Legacy she's really good. Like, 4-of good. According to some testers. Slant The main gripe that people came across in Legacy though is that she doesn't quite have a shell properly built around her.

    Quote from ShadowFenril »
    Westvale Abbey. Probably my second favorite card in the set. Definitely want to build a deck with this and maybe pick up a copy or two for some EDH decks. just above $11 now, which is down almost $4 since last week. It is a dual face card so probably more being opened. Does it see Modern play yet? How long can this go? Should I pick it up now or keep waiting.
    I haven't seen it in modern. Maybe it makes a splash. Maybe it doesn't. Annoying card, but nothing too crazy. It's not a bad card though. Probably gonna remain stable at $11 though, because of standard, and it's a cool card.

    Quote from ShadowFenril »
    Thing in the Ice same as above really. My friend told me it's insane in Modern. Thought-Knot Seer was about the same price until the ban. Wait a bit longer or grab now?

    Supposedly a really good card in modern. Haven't seen it much here yet, though most people testing the card says it's good. I'd say it's a safe card to buy/trade into. It'll probably fall a little further, due to downward pressure of more supply being opened. But a spike is always possible, if it has a big breakout tournament, which, IMO will happen sometime in the future. Then again, TitI can be like Tasigur; really really good, but still somewhat cheap.

    Quote from ShadowFenril »
    The Gitrog Monster. Well, everyone loves the ol Gitfrog. Seems to have settled at $7-$8, price isn't budging much lately. Is it really good enough to see Standard and Modern play? Is it a good buy at $7 or just all hype?

    Don't know about modern. Or Standard either. He's possibly pretty good. But he also has a lot of casual appeal and commander appeal. Idk if I'd spec on any card in SOI, but he's not a bad card to buy maybe 1-2 of's just to have. Card's really cool. I think $7-8 is a reasonable and stable price for Gitgud Monster. Always possible he falls. If he were to fall though, he wouldn't fall too far; probably to $5. IMO, his fall ratio is much lower than like, say, Olivia, Mobilized for War. She's kinda dropped a lot since her release (from $15 to $11), since she's purely based on whether or not she's gonna see play in standard. Because of this, she might spike if she makes a breakout appearance. The GitRekt Monster, on the other hand, is just a really cool card people would want to brew with in Legacy, Modern, Commander/EDH, and Standard. Who knows? He might be sleeper OP. He might just make a splash. Or he might do absolutely nothing. Thing though is, he's a fun card to play with. Really neat effects. That's why he's priced as such.

    Well, these are my opinions on the cards. I may be wrong. I may be right. Take it as you will.
    Posted in: Market Street Café
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.