2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Quote from Huntzilla »
    ... And we are discussing who to kill.


    My point was, Megs isn't.

    Quite frankly, neither are you.

    A CFD at the end seems to me highly likely.


    What is a CFD?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    We are 3 and a half days into a game that lasts one week.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Quote from Megiddo »
    you guys aren't fun

    it would be funny, but this seems not to be the goal for most of you...?

    Arrow Down
    Quote from Megiddo »
    last time i was scum in a micro i posted nonsense the whole game, so i need to play against meta and post good content here


    I suppose the only way everyone else is right and you aren't scum is if this "plan" stuff was an elaborate, unfunny joke that went over my head... yet you've done nothing else so far. My vote stays
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Why are we even talking about this? It doesn't help our wincon, simple as that. Each townie would have a 1/5 chance of winning and a 4/5 chance of losing, versus getting to actually choose my top suspect.

    If Megs is town and he's advocating this plan, it's because he's not confident in his ability to accuse scum after a mislynch (like, less than random chance probability), or he's saying that he'd rather lose the game than see the scum have a chance at winning.

    I call bull***** on both of those scenarios. Megs is scum trying too hard to look like someone who hates mafia.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Quote from Megiddo »

    allow me to think for you for a second since you clearly didn't.

    the plan proposed guarantees a scum loss. Therefore, I am scum according to you. I don't really see A and B connecting here.


    allow me to reiterate my point for everyone, since I'm clearly having my words twisted.

    the "plan" megs asked the mod about that guarantees a scum loss was impractical and he knew it, therefore he only brought it up to deceptively appear town.

    Town motivation for post: none, impractical plan, wouldn't help his wincon
    Scum motivation for post: ignores impracticality to publicly appear anti-mafia
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Quote from Rhand »
    I had the exact same thoughts as Meg, but decided to dismiss them because we all become neutral if we don't lynch mafia toDay, so working together toMorrow makes no sense.


    This is my point. That strategy makes no sense. I had the idea too but immediately dismissed it too, when I came to understand that we don't win as a team on Day 2.

    Wouldn't you expect Megs to dismiss as well? He knew the idea was no good (in the question he mentions only one person winning). The only reason I see for him publicly asking the mod about it is to try to gain town cred.

    Now he's playing it off as a joke, probably his only line of defense.

    I don't think it makes Megs scum.


    It does.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Quote from Megiddo »
    @mod

    what happens if we lynch and then (assuming mislynch) all remaining players accuse each other in a chain? only one winner but mafia literally can never win, yes?


    Why would we ever want to do this? Only one random player wins and everyone else gets a guaranteed loss. There wouldd be no fun, no skill, no point.

    Yet you know this, so when you ask the question, you're not actually interested in the answer. It seems that the only reason to ask is to deceptively highlight an anti-mafia appearance. I don't see that coming from a town mindset.

    Vote Megs

    Quickest and easiest game of all time.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Quote from tomsloger »
    vote rhand

    #18 checks a lot of boxes. Bandwagoning me, buddying tom2 (my joindate is earlier), forcing megs to work for a townread.


    Your join date may be earlier, but there was no other Tom that posted much in the years that I was active. Either you were a ghost that quickly accumulated almost 8k posts in the last few years, or you changed your username, in which case I'm still the original Tom.

    Is your vote RVS or nah? Sometimes I have a hard time telling the difference.

    @D_V well maybe I'm thinking of someone else and reverse-bamboozled myself. I thought I remembered your username though. You sure we've never played a game of mafia together?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Oh boy I remember D_V now, I feel bad I didn't recognize him, probably due to an avatar change or something. Redface
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Vote: Tomsloger

    This is the most suspicious MTGS member I have ever seen. Looks like an attempted parody of myself.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Quote from Megiddo »
    Quote from Tom »
    Who is this D_V guy?

    Vote D_V
    oh ***** OG tom returns


    Aww does that mean you didn't see my joke in the signup thread?

    But yeah I actually had to have MTGS email me a new password to even log in.

    What I don't get is why there are all these people that have early join dates and lots of posts but I have no idea who they are.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Game Over - GG IT'S TOM
    Who is this D_V guy?

    Vote D_V
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Death And Taxes
    Hello, Tom here, creator of the very first primer for Modern D+T. I see there is still a link to it in this primer, which makes me happy.

    Also happy that there are still a lot of the same cards in modern versions of this deck. I haven't played magic or been on this forum in years.

    Kinda unhappy that this deck is Tier 2 now, but I guess the meta isn't as combo-oriented as it used to be.

    Just stopping by, keep up the good work and love for D+T.

    We shall rise again.
    Posted in: Aggro & Tempo
  • posted a message on One Week Mafia - Signups!
    Boy, signups are really struggling these days.

    I bet no one on this forum guessed in their wildest dreams the 7th player would be me. (in)

    Obviously haven't played for a while but I've got one week before school starts so lets give it a try.

    That is, if I'm still alive in a week. Megs, settle North Korea down a bit will ya?
    Posted in: Old Sign-ups
  • posted a message on Mafia Hosting Sign-Ups & Hosting Rules
    I need someone to review my game, so if you've got the nipples required to review, send me a PM please

    EDIT: Gentleman Johnny has got the nipples and offered, thanks
    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.