It's usefulness is directly proportional to the amount of discarding you have done, which depends on the draw spells you have been using. If most of your deck is in your hand, deck death can still occur. That's why I choose Day's Undoing & Commit // Memory, since they will recycle the most cards overall.
- Registered User
Member for 8 years, 2 months, and 3 days
Last active Mon, Feb, 18 2019 10:22:46
- 0 Followers
- 175 Total Posts
- 7 Thanks
Jan 21, 2019Posted in: Multiplayer Commander DecklistsQuote from SmauG »Have you considered abusing Toothy, imaginary Friend with (off the top): Displace, Ghostly Flicker, Essence Flux, Siren's Ruse and Illusionist's Stratagem?
When combined with just a few counters on toothy, those just go nuts. Toothy re-enters before you draw your cards. Putting back the counters you saved for another pop.
In the past I had used Deadeye Navigator with the same intent. Flickering Toothy is a valid tactic, but it does have a few drawbacks. Most draw spells are more CMC efficient than flicker effects. For those flicker effects to pay out more, Toothy already has to be pretty large. You also cannot use them as a pump spell before the combat step since they will make a new instance of Toothy.
A delayed bounce like Voyager Staff can help reset Toothy if you feel he is getting to fat. Flicker spells will just compound the problem. Remember that Toothy can get too big.
On advantage that I can see is the ability to change Toothy from tapped to untapped for use as a blocker. They can also be used to reset Toothy as an attacker to avoid a bad block you didn't see, or to avoid a Settle the Wreckage. Those combat tactics a worth one or two card slots, but I wouldn't over do it.
Dec 17, 2018Simic AscendancyPosted in: Commander (EDH)
That card is going to be broken in my Pir, Imaginative Rascal // Toothy, Imaginary Friend deck. With both commanders on the field + Simic Ascendancy, every time I draw a card I would get to put for 4 counters on the ascendancy. A card draw triggers Toothy, which then triggers Pir, placing a second +1/+1 counter. That will trigger the ascendancy twice, and Pir will trigger again providing an additional ascendancy counter to each trigger.
When I draw 5 cards, I'll get 20 counters. That is no sweat. I have no idea how ofter I would win with Ascendancy, but given how easy it is to setup, it is perfect counter spell / removal bait.
Nov 6, 2018I have taken in you feed back and made some changes. It hurts when you cut pet cards like Salvaging Station + Lotus Bloom, but overall I think the deck is much more cohesive.Posted in: Multiplayer Commander Decklists
A note worthy new addition is Mirran Spy. At worst it will untap a mana creature or my commander when I cast another artifact. At it's best I can untap Arcum Dagsson or combo it with Grand Architect to make any artifact 2 or less a free cast.
Nov 4, 2018Posted in: Multiplayer Commander DecklistsI do like the Salvage Slasher in your list. I'm just not quite artifact heavy enough to get value out of it. There is Phyrexian Soulgorger as an "alternative" to Phyrexian Devourer as well. Believe it or not, there are even situation where you want to use the sacrifice ability to get a creature into the graveyard. There are often times you'll draw a Pili-Pala, Vector Asp, etc and want it in your graveyard, for a combo. I normally play them out if I don't have discard, hoping to just block and kill them, or run into a board wipe
But Phyrexian Soulgorger does give you access to guaranteeing this.
I have Reshape, Trading Post, and Arcum Dagsson that are also solutions to that problem. I do like the interaction Phyrexian Soulgorger has with Hex Parasite. 1B is not a bad tax to keep an 8/8 trampler around for a turn or 2 in the early game. I just wish I hadn't sold my copy of that card in a big pile 2 months ago for some fetch lands. After I trying out both The Mimeoplasm and Varolz, the Scar-Striped and disliking them, I figured I would not need it again. The only reason I kept Phyrexian Dreadnought is that I thought it would be better to keep as a trader.
I do think you should run a few more counterspells. I mean if you're worried about graveyard hate, then you should also be worried about artifact mass removal, or hate.
A Vandalblast, Austere Command, Stony Silence, is going to ruin you. So I lean on a few counterspells to react to these types of spells.
I don't see those specific cards very often, but that is a meta thing could change. I do sometimes see a Merciless Eviction and many opposing Cyclonic Rifts.
Anvil of Bogardan and Unfulfilled Desires removed, Forbid and Memory Lapse added. Those are the best choices I have in my binder at the moment. I was thinking windfall instead of Unfulfilled Desires, but I have Notion Thief and I want to trigger him reliably. Anvil of Bogardan needs to stay in another deck that cares about max hand size.
One of my first thoughts was to cut Contraband Kingpin. He was mostly a falvour choice that seemed to fit. I think I'll swap him with either Lore Broker or Dreamscape Artist.
Nov 3, 2018Thank you. I never really took notice of the Let's Brew thread. I was on the fence about masticore, but I think you are right. I'll be giving him a pass.Posted in: Multiplayer Commander Decklists
I noticed you play all the Stifle effects, Nimble Obstructionist, Stifle, Trickbind. Must be pretty scared of Bojuka Bog, and rightfully so. I think I should play at least Stifle, so that I have some long term answer for it.
I have picked up a reputation among my LGS as the dedicated graveyard player, as I have yet to build a deck that does not use it in some capacity. That means everyone holds onto their grave hate just for me. Those spells also help with Planeswalker ultimates and Eldrazi cast triggers, which can always ruin your day.
How has Unfulfilled Desires been? Looks like a pretty strong card in general and I'm certainly thinking of trying it. Basically all the creatures are disposable from your hand, so for me that's about 1/3 of the deck.
I have extensive experience with this card thanks to the various incarnations of my Grimgrin, Corpse-Born deck. In that deck I has lost track of the times I have used it to dig for an answer or a win condition. I have also lost track of the number of times doing so has nearly killed me! It will keep the game interesting at least. If you are durdling and finding nothing, it is over quick.
For your deck there is possible Zur's Weirding for your Lantern theme
I like that. It allows the group to get in the action too. Unfortunately I have had to drop the lantern focus from my build. It is a strategy that still think could work but it is divergent from artifact centered build. Trying to do both causes a loss in synergy. I may put together a list that focus on Lantern control, but for now I have doubled down on artifacts.
This is my updated list. I used yours as template. One major change I had to make was the mana base. I can't afford most MOX cards, so I'll have to see if I can still make 30 land work.
I managed to finally pick up a Sensei's Divining Top in a trade. Once I did, I took you suggestion and added Magus of the Future. I am not looking back from that decision. I have dropped the Deceiver of Form plan due to complexity, but the ability to play my top deck sounds great. I also look forward to my first Magus of the Future + Sensei's Divining Top + Etherium Sculptor combo.
I added a couple of things that may interest you:
Library of Leng - We are both running enough cards with discarding as a part of the effect that I figured this might come in handy. I hate loosing my Cyclonic Rift because I had a handful of things that needed to be in the grave. A note to others: This does work with cards where discarding is part of the cost like Artificer's Intuition
Salvage Slasher - This is my back up Phyrexian Dreadnought. I know they don't seem similar, but their function within the deck is very close. In both cases it is preferable to make Lazav a copy after he has gone unblocked. Phyrexian Dreadnought is strictly better because his size is unconditional and he costs less to copy, Salvage Slasher will scale later in the game as your graveyard fills. He also isn't as recognizable as Phyrexian Dreadnought, slowing the hate he will receive in graveyard.
Noteworthy is that I have omitted Crackdown Construct from the list. I feel like he and Phyrexian Devourer were fighting for the same slot. Crackdown Construct gets bigger overall, but after Lazav becomes a 21/21 his size is not relevant anymore. In terms of a hard cast, Phyrexian Devourer does cost more, but I still prefer him for aid in top deck control and his ability to combo with other cards in the deck.
Nov 2, 2018I have been giving it some thought. The thing that is turning me off about Enhanced Surveillance is that my artifact tutors cant find it for me. I did some more research on gatherer. At first I was going to switch to Feldon's Cane, but I eventually decided on Thran Foundry. With the foundry I still have to keep mana open, but not as much, and it functions as grave hate against my opponents in a pinch.Posted in: Multiplayer Commander Decklists
What are your thoughts on masticore for this deck?
Oct 27, 2018I am not sold on Enhanced Surveillance. It has been my experience that if you want to run a card that references a keyword, you will need to run at least 10 other cards with that keyword. Exceptions can be made if your commander has the key word, but in this case Lazav only surveil's when he enters the battlefield. I don't see him triggering enough times for that.Posted in: Multiplayer Commander Decklists
If you want an effect that can protect you graveyard, Elixir of Immortality is probably best.
Oct 26, 2018I have run a Grimgrin deck for many years. My version was non-tribal but it had a heavy black mana base. I used to call it a black deck spice with blue. The majority of U/B dual lands do not help you if you are running swamps matter cards like Cabal Coffers.Posted in: Multiplayer Commander Decklists
You need everything you can reasonably use to fetch a swamp. I strongly recommend getting your hands on at least 4 swamp fetch lands. You also appear to be running too many non-basic utility lands. I would cut:
2x Island - Fetch's will make up for it. If you have an opponent who likes land destruction, don't tell them you only run 3.
Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx - Only useful when you are ahead. Better with non-creature permanents that stick around longer.
Cabal Stronghold - Does not count non-basic swamps. Best for a pure mono black deck with very fewer utility lands.
Underground River - Good but not a swamp. You are probably sad when you draw it late game with a healthy land base.
Drowned Catacomb - See above
Then I would add, Evolving Wilds, Terramorphic Expanse, Bad River, Rocky Tar Pit, Polluted Delta, and Bloodstained Mire. Four of those lands cause a land to etb tapped, but that is not big deal as long as you get the type of land you need. If you have more money you could dip into swamp fetches in enemy colours or more blue fetches.
In the main deck, I would drop Josu Vess, Lich Knight and Balthor the Defiled, then add 2 tutors. It does not matter which tutor's you choose to use, but they would be better than a sub-par zombie token maker and re-animator. I like Final Parting in particular. You can use it to fetch your Living Death and stick your favorite bomb in graveyard.
Oct 23, 2018Posted in: Multiplayer Commander Decklists
I am pursuing a lantern control style dream. The idea is to use Lantern of Insight or Wizened Snitches to grant me knowledge of my opponents upcoming draw, then I can use Codex Shredder or preferably Mindshrieker to sculpt their draws. Phyrexian Devourer is both a combo piece and a way to sculpt my draws for the better.
Now that I have finally taken the time to type this up, it looks like I am using far less artifacts than I though I was. I may have to give this list another revision. either remove the heavy artifact support, or double down and add more artifact combo pieces. I was thinking about a Salvaging Station package and Sai, Master Thopterist but that may be another entirely different deck.I could help changing the list while I was posting it. I think I figured out how to include the above.
I am running very few unblockable creatures. Instead most of them are utility creatures with either 1 power or 1 toughness that I can make unblockable with Tetsuko Umezawa, Fugitive.
I also really wanted to add Wormfang Manta so I could combo it with Deceiver of Form, but I just can't justify the space. Phyrexian Obliterator and Phyrexian Dreadnought are both sufficient.
Oct 22, 2018I am going the robot direction, but my focus is on playing with my top deck. I am trying to use phyrexian devourer / walking ballista + copy creature combo. I have supported it with Skill Borrower so that I have intel on my top deck. I also have Deceiver of Form and Volrath's Stronghold / Academy Ruins so that I can turn my small creatures into an army of Phyrexian Dreadnought's.Posted in: Multiplayer Commander Decklists
I fully endorse Artificer's Intuition. It is a great card that does very heavy lifting if you are using artifacts.
For your build I would suggest Nether Traitor and Meekstone. The traitor is another very good unblockable creature that offers some self reanimation and the ability to give Lazav haste later in the game. Meekstone can be searched with Artificer's Intuition and is pretty effective at slowing down any battle cruiser creatures your opponents may have.
Oct 17, 2018Here is an honest question. Do you need to draw more cards? or do you need your opponents to have less cards? Sire of Insanity. Force people to use Xantcha's card draw ability. For extra fun, use him with Painful Quandary!Posted in: Multiplayer Commander Decklists
Oct 13, 2018gamazson posted a message on Lazav, the Scarface, "Say hello to my low CC friends." (Let's Brew!)Wait a tick. Those Chronozoa copies will be created with Lazav's ability....Posted in: Commander (EDH)
Oct 13, 2018I have made a few changes. Master Biomancer was swapped for Forgotten Ancient. The later is simply more efficient at making utility creatures larger. I also made room for Commit // Memory because I wanted more removal and I needed a plan B in case of deck death. I had a couple games where my Laboratory Maniac found himself in exile and my library was dangerously small.Posted in: Multiplayer Commander Decklists
Changes 10/13/18Magic OnlineOCTGN2ApprenticeBuy These Cards In
1 Forgotten Ancient
1 Rites of Flourishing
1 Commit // Memory
1 Trygon Predator
1 Master Biomancer
1 Temple Bell
1 overwhelming stampede
1 Acidic Slime
- To post a comment, please login or register a new account.