I think I might try this in Journey to Nowhere's place. It's pretty close in power level and I like that it brings more "combat tricks" into the format. It plays different. We'll see id it holds up.
Karakas has been really solid for us. There have been a bunch of legendary creatures designed in the last couple of years that are cubeworthy. Strange that it didn't work for you. I will check my cube and make a count.
Played with this yesterday for the first time and well, it was ridiculous in my deck. I sneaked in Hornet Queen, used leap on those (had queen imprinted on Mimic Vat and got all sorts of Eldrazi and Griselbrands. At that point my opponent scooped. It also protected my stuff, since I could just get a new creature if an opponent tried to remove an old one.
Member details blocking first line is vwry annoying (nexus 5, chrome beta). IMO that whole line could be rolled into the block above it as a small link. No reason for it to take that big of a space on mobile.
Really happy to see a mobile version.
EDIT: after using this more, I agree that showing last reply and time would be better and more important than number of replies/views.
I will test this out for sure, hard to quantify how good it will be without testing. I wouldn't put this into my deck without any targets, but even only one would be enough. Usually the kind of decks that would want this card, will be the most happy to tutor for an equipment.
We proxied this - player who drafted it wanted to cut it, but we made him play it to test it. It never flipped or did anything other than fetched that forest. Our whole group was of the opinion that it is clearly the weakest of the bunch. It was a small sample set of testing, but I wasn't enarmored with the card to begin with.
I was originally against playing DFC's as well, but I ended up starting to use them, since there are some really nice ones. I don't like taking cards out of the sleeve and that was my original reason to exclude these cards.
My solution was to make a proxy transformed side and have them ready with the tokens. Now that I have my cube proxy free, I might actually upgrade them to a second copies of the real card and sleeve them with different color sleeves. That way they are easily recognizable and usable out of the token box.
Dragonlord Atarka has worked very nicely for us. I have seen it do some nasty things. For example: Sneak attacking it in to wipe 4 defending flyers (3 Spectral Procession and Oonas Prowler) tokens and attacking with it and other fliers to one shot kill from 13 life. Opponent was feeling pretty safe with 4 flying blockers. Also, it is nice to have something other than 4CC Gruul cards to be good
I have liked it, this is a nice card with lots of interaction and the power level is high enough as well. Supporting spell matters archetype makes this even better.
Really happy to see a mobile version.
EDIT: after using this more, I agree that showing last reply and time would be better and more important than number of replies/views.
My solution was to make a proxy transformed side and have them ready with the tokens. Now that I have my cube proxy free, I might actually upgrade them to a second copies of the real card and sleeve them with different color sleeves. That way they are easily recognizable and usable out of the token box.
Now we ran Garruk Relentless, Huntmaster of the Fells and new Liliana as a proxy. We will most likely run Jace and Gideon as well.
Orzhov
1. Vindicate
2. Lingering Souls
3. Sorin, Lord of Innistrad
4. Magister of Worth
5. Utter End
6. Sorin, Solemn Visitor
7. Unburial Rites
8. Ashen Rider
9. Gerrard's Verdict
10. Sin Collector
Golgari
1. Pernicious Deed
2. Maelstrom Pulse
3. Deathrite Shaman
4. Abrupt Decay
5. Garruk, Apex Predator
6. Lotleth Troll
7. Vraska the Unseen
8. Putrefy
9. Rakhasa Deathdealer
10. Spirit Monger
Simic
1. Edric, Spymaster of Trest
2. Trygon Predator
3. Mystic Snake
4. Kiora, the Crashing Wave
5. Shardless Agent
6. Simic Sky Swallower
7. Sagu Mauler
8. Prime Speaker Zegana
9. Simic Charm
10. Prophet of Kruphix
Izzet
1. Dack Fayden
2. Ral Zarek
3. Izzet Charm
4. Dack's Duplicate
5. Keranos, God of Storms
6. Turn // Burn
7. Electrolyze
8. Prophetic Bolt
9. Fire // Ice
10. Steam Augury
Boros
1. Ajani Vengeant
2. Figure of Destiny
3. Boros Charm
4. Lightning Helix
5. Boros Reckoner
6. Slayers' Stronghold
7. Assemble the Legion
8. Chained to the Rocks
9. Iroas, God of Victory
10. Wear // Tear