2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on Literary Characters and Color Affiliations
    I must disagree on that, and I think you might be a little biased about what Black means. Anyone who says "Every human being is selfish" is most likely at least part Black. Don't get me wrong here. I'm a big advocate for both Black and Red. I think that the Rakdos are misunderstood, and that in a way, they are the keystone that holds Ravnica together. I disagree about Black wanting others to suffer more than itself to gain, I feel that Black is the most goals-oriented of the colors. Black knows exactly what it wants, and is willing to sacrifice anything to get it. If Black wants the world, it would gladly be like Daffy Duck pushing Marvin the Martian off the one tiny scrap of remaining planet. If Black wants love (and yes, Black can love), it will find the shortest route to that person's heart.

    I've always felt that Black can be summed up by the Big Lebowski quote "You're not wrong, Walter. You're just an ********."

    This is a hypothetical, one I use to refute the "Everyone is selfish" point. Granted, this is an extreme case, but here goes. Let's say a guy met a girl who was in an abusive relationship. They fell in love, but she couldn't admit it due to her own hangups and fears. See, she of course comes from a broken home, but the kicker is she has a chronic, long-term illness like Cystic Fibrosis. He then spends the better part of a year sacrificing everything for her to prove not that he is the one for her, or that he can make her happy, but that she deserves to be happy period. Eventually she breaks up with the abusive boyfriend and they get together quickly, having grown really close already. He knows that she's not going to live long, but he doesn't care because she'll at least be happy. When the inevitable does occur, he takes it very hard and his life falls apart, but he still has no regrets because he made her happy. How does that work in the view that everyone is selfish?
    This isn't a bad Nicolas Sparks ripoff. This is me, and Tuesday is the 1 year anniversary of her death.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on Literary Characters and Color Affiliations
    I've been watching mystery shows lately. I pegged Castle as a Black hero originally, but shifting to R/W over time (and character development). However, there's a far, far better example: Shawn Spencer, from Psych.

    Even after much character development, he is still a selfish jerk who's as averse to the truth as Vampire Superman is to a kryptonite cross. He is motivated primarily by his own ego, he can be jealous and spiteful, and has a pathological need for attention. The fact he is so upbeat, witty, charming, and possesses a childlike glee at the world is the only thing that keeps him from being completely insufferable.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on Phyrexians vs Eldrazi
    Eldrazi Sliver

    Sliver creatures you control have Annihilator 1.

    Compleated Sliver

    Sliver creatures you control have Infect.

    Tell me that either of those (regardless of P/T or mana cost) isn't bring-my-brown-pants terrifying.
    Posted in: Opinions & Polls
  • posted a message on Mardu WBR character
    Kenshiro, Fist of the North Star.

    He wanders the wasteland searching for Raoh, who is undoubtedly a monster that the world would be better without. When he sees people getting hurt (as happens all the freaking time in the wasteland) he shows great emotion, as he is the originator of the "Manly Tears" meme, and goes into a state of tranquil rage, utterly destroying those responsible. However, someone points out to him that his quest to find and defeat Raoh might be misguided. He does so much good fighting other threats and saving people in the wastes. He frees slaves and saves lives. Last time they fought, Raoh utterly destroyed him and left him for dead. So, if he goes to fight Raoh, there's the very real possibility he will die. When Kenshiro says that his own good is so limited, he points out that Raoh's evil is just as limited. If he dies, there won't be anyone doing as much good as Kenshiro, and all the good he's done will be for nothing. Kenshiro acknowledges he's right, and then says it doesn't matter. His personal goal is to defeat Raoh, and thus prove himself stronger (Black). All his altruism (White) and his passion and compassion (Red) is just what he does on his way to that goal.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on Phyrexians vs Eldrazi
    I think everyone is so focused on those two, they're missing the real threat to the multiverse: Slivers.

    Imagine what would happen if the Slivers managed to "learn" from either of those two.
    Posted in: Opinions & Polls
  • posted a message on Black aligned heroes
    YES! YES YOU DO!

    The first is one of my favorite games of all time. The second I have yet to play because I don't have a WiiU, but I've watched playthroughs and it's epic. Not putting a coin in the jar, epic is an apt word to describe it.

    And yes, I can definitely see her as a Black heroine. She is, technically, the good guy because she, like Liliana, is cancelling the apocalypse. The first game just turns the traditional apocalyptic narrative on its head by having the church essentially welcoming the apocalypse as a way to bring about a perfect harmonious paradise (a very White goal). Bayonetta gets involved purely for selfish reasons--finding a rare gem--but it discards that plotline in favor of another selfish plot of restoring her lost memories. Even her protection of the little Cereza (who mistakes Bayonetta for her mother) is ultimately self-serving, though for reasons that are complicated and unclear until pretty late in the game. Still, no reason why a Black character can't take a liking to someone, and Bayonetta is far from coddling ("If there's two things I can't stand it's crying children and cockroaches. Though crying baby cockroaches would just be dreadful...")

    The second game continues this trend. She gets involved out of an Orphic quest to save her lover, Jeanne (Oh, don't even pretend she isn't). Then when the apocalyptic plotline kicks in, we oddly see demons throwing in with the angels on this. Demons have also traditionally been Red as well as Black, so it's fitting that the villain's plot is rather Green. He once ruled the world, but not in a traditional sense: He saw through to the truth of the world, and made that truth reality. That is, he didn't rule by making decisions for the world and humanity, rather by simply removing other options with his gaze of simple truth. He wants to return to that: a world without the illusion of free will. It's odd because his appearance and powers are so Blue (time manipulation, mainly), but his goals are so Green.
    Posted in: Opinions & Polls
  • posted a message on Black aligned heroes
    I'm a big advocate for Black being misunderstood, but I don't think Star-Lord is Black. He's pretty Red. His actions show that he values freedom and his own emotions, not his own advancement. Things like double-crossing Yondu, stealing the Orb, etc, seem to me to be done less out of a motive for personal advancement than simply "because it's cool." Richard Castle (at least in the first couple seasons) is a better example of a Black protagonist. He does everything for himself and to get what he wants. At first, it's material for his book, but it quickly becomes "Lt. Beckett." In later seasons he changes, but still remains a very self-centered character (just see the scene where he has a broken leg and calls her at work).

    In fact, the two characters make a very excellent counterpoint to each other and the difference between Red and Black in essentially similar actions. Castle wants Beckett, and he recognizes that he needs her respect first. When he doesn't get the respect he feels he's owed, his response is to redouble his efforts, force systems to bend to him, and to simply refuse to go away. Star-Lord's response to disrespect is comedic indignation. Also, Castle is very goal-oriented, he wants to "have" Beckett and pursues her respect as a means to get her. Star-Lord wants people to be impressed with him right now, because of what he just did.

    Black protagonists are tricky, because you have to understand that the good they do is incidental to their goals. Look at Liliana in Innistrad. Her goal was to kill Griselbrand, that's it. She did some pretty horrific stuff to achieve her goal. Then, by achieving her goal, she wound up saving the world, something she didn't give a flying flip about. A good way to make a Black protagonist is to give them a goal, and then put something bad in their way. Not even necessarily worse, just bad. Tokyo cheers Godzilla when he defeats the other monster, even if he wrecks everything on the way out.

    Got a lot more to say on this subject, but my posts can easily turn into essays if I don't reign myself in.
    Posted in: Opinions & Polls
  • posted a message on [[DGM]] Artwork (pics from Uncharted Realms added)
    Is it bad form to say Exava is really hot? She looks like a seriously dangerous woman as well, but what jumps out at me is how built she is. Wide hips and large chest, but with a thick waist so it looks realistic. She looks both attractive and dangerous, like the Rakdos guild itself. I also love how she seems to have noticed the fourth wall mid-stride.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on New cards: Lasso, Apple Family Cider Press, Return to Sender, Dreamwalk
    Quote from ryzorz
    About the symbol; what do you think about a gold version of the colorless symbol (for generic colored mana)? The current symbol is very, very busy and shoves too many colors into its area.

    Actually, I do like that idea. The current symbol was the best that I could find in MSE extensions (the other one literally looking like a rainbow turd), but a gold symbol may work too. I'd have to do the edits manually though.
    Posted in: Custom Card Creation
  • posted a message on New cards: Lasso, Apple Family Cider Press, Return to Sender, Dreamwalk
    Dreamwalk: Yeah, I wasn't sure how to cost this, so I erred on the side of "too expensive." Especially when I had it at two cards. If other people agree, I'll drop the cost.

    Lasso: You're right, this is more of an uncommon effect. I'll adjust accordingly.

    Cider Press: You are right that the symbol, in this case, probably isn't strictly necessary. I could get the same thing across with just 1. However, I have cards in the works that rely on that symbol as their prime mana cost, and a lot of nonbasic lands that produce colorless unless you do something about it. I may need to make this concept its own thread and show one at each rarity and each supertype.

    As for its power level, you are right it does seem a bit more than the others, though it doesn't work as well for mana fixing if you aren't getting the mana you need. I think this one may depend heavily on the Limited environment, so I'll just err on bumping it up to Uncommon for now unless someone has an idea on how to drop the power level.
    Posted in: Custom Card Creation
  • posted a message on New cards: Lasso, Apple Family Cider Press, Return to Sender, Dreamwalk
    I'm still working on my own unique mechanics for this set. One of the cards (that I misposted as its own thread elsewhere) shows a little of this mechanic, though it's not a huge expression of it just yet.

    Return to Sender UU
    Instant {C}
    Return target creature to its owner's hand. If that creature was a token, return this card to its owner's hand.
    One down, 98 to go...

    Lasso 2
    Artifact - Equipment {C}
    Equip 1
    Equipped creature has “:symtap:: Tap target creature. It does not untap during its controller’s next untap step.”

    Both of these feel pretty straightforward to me, but you may see problems I don't.

    This one is a problem child. I'll tell you about my first version later which was Skullclamp-broken instead of Jace-broken.

    Dreamwalk 3UUU
    Enchantment {R}
    At the beginning of each player's upkeep, you may look at the top card of that player's library. You may put that card on the bottom of that player's library.
    Awakened from her nightmare, Luna once more guarded the dreams of others.

    First version had the top two cards. Yeesh...

    This one is special. It's showing my first "unique" mechanic. I honestly can't even format it properly for this forum, so I'm just gonna post the image:


    Prismatic mana. Right here it's just used as an activation cost, but in other cards it may be the main cost. I'm trying to get it to behave properly as a main cost, but I'm still working on that. What do you think? Is this something that should exist or not? Also, how are the card mechanics?

    Finally, here are the images for all, plus a reprint of Befoul, last seen in Kamigawa.





    Posted in: Custom Card Creation
  • posted a message on Apple Family Cider Press, and my new mechanic
    Yeah, I may not technically need it on this card, but there are other cards I'm working on where it may be necessary. I wanted to have it on this one since it's the first one I'm actually somewhat satisfied with using the "prism" mana.
    Posted in: Custom Set Creation and Discussion
  • posted a message on Apple Family Cider Press, and my new mechanic
    Okay, it's about time I showed one of the new mechanics I want to try out in my set. The forum will not allow me to display what I need to, so I will provide the card image in the text and use the incredibly awkward (WUBRG) instead.

    Apple Family Cider Press 2
    Artifact {C}
    (WUBRG), T: Add two mana of the color spent to pay for (WUBRG) to your mana pool.
    ((WUBRG) can be paid with any colored mana. It can not be paid with colorless mana.)


    This is a very loose idea of mine. I'm not in love with this particular card, but I have other ideas for cards using (WUBRB). So, tell me what you think about this card specifically and the concept in general.
    Posted in: Custom Set Creation and Discussion
  • posted a message on Card discussion: Group Hug, Forgiveness, Motivational Minotaur
    If no one's got anything more to say, then I'm gonna add these to my current project file. Thanks for the input, everyone.
    Posted in: Custom Card Creation
  • posted a message on Card discussion: Group Hug, Forgiveness, Motivational Minotaur
    Quote from ryzorz
    Teach "I hate ponies"

    I've got no good will towards bronies, but all you have to do is ignore the flavor and you can still be a productive member of the forums.

    I definitely prefer the card in green, but thinking about it, I'd like to see it at sorcery or at 3 cmc; Brand still seems like a rather large bonus on a common.

    "Ignore the flavor"?

    Hah! Yeah, that's kinda missing the point of this set. I have absolutely no problem with people not liking MLP, but saying it's okay if you ignore the flavor is like saying Twizzlers are okay if you ignore the flavor. Some people (me) love them, you're not wrong if you hate them, but honestly if you don't like Twizzlers you're better off getting popcorn at the movie theater.

    Ahem. Anyway. Looks like Group Hug is okay. Forgiveness may need colorshifting. Motivational Minotaur needs to have the ability made asymmetrical. First post updated with new versions, are these better?
    Posted in: Custom Card Creation
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.