A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
 
Exclusive: Sword of Truth and Justice
  • posted a message on Team Mafia Game 2 - Giant Robot Battle Royale II (Game Over)
    I didn't realize we had such little time left.


    vote : beeboy

    At this point I'd advocate for literally any lynch. We need to get it going.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Team Mafia Game 2 - Giant Robot Battle Royale II (Game Over)
    Well I read a few more pages and got bored so I skipped ahead.


    My strongest town read curreny is kanji, which feels horrible because I'm pretty sure long term interacting with him will drive me insane.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Team Mafia Game 2 - Giant Robot Battle Royale II (Game Over)
    It's been a while since I've played on MTGS and looks like I haven't played with anyone in this game.

    I'm on page 6 right now, I have some notes but I got bored so instead I'll probably just shoot from the hip until I'm in the thick of it.


    As far as players I like /don't like (Based on the content to page 6).


    I really don't trust anyone so far.

    I absolutely can't stand shin's response to cantrips mass claim proposal: "Regardless of my alignment which i am town, i wont partcipate in any mass claims." Combine that with the massive quote walls, it just feels like someone is trying to hard to come across as town.

    D_V seems like logical and aggressive town, except when he started talking about "every post is alignment telling". I don't believe that at all and this felt like he was trying to convince himself when he was trying to explain it, which reads kinda scummy.


    Anak feels a bit off. I don't really have much to talk about cause it's more of a gut feeling.

    I have no idea if Kanji is town or scum but the yolo dope swag persona is annoying.

    I kinda liked Nacho and wasn't really sure why he was getting crap early. I know at one point he said something that made him sound serious about winning as town. He also voted shin which would have been my choice early, but then there were other parts where he seemed kind of disinterested or scattered with answering.


    Tom seems kind of weird but I think he is having fun with a new play style.

    Mostly everyone else I have no read on yet. I'll get there.



    Anyways, back to catching up.




    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mono Green Control
    Has anyone been trying this recently? I picked it up and plan to try it at my lgs once I finish getting trinispheres.
    Posted in: Deck Creation (Modern)
  • posted a message on MTGS Mafia Votecounter v0.5 - New Year, New Update!
    I know I haven't been around these forums for a while but I am a dev primarily using C# and I'm familiar with github. If I get a chance I might try and play/work on it.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mind Screw Salvation Mafia - Endgame: When The Seagulls Cry, There Are No Survivors
    Slammed at work and going out of town this weekend.

    Bottom of page 12 but I should be able to post enough to avoid prod.

    I like necargs response to my question. TS was the aggressor and normally town is the proactive one. I asked him the question because I came to a different conclusion. I think since it's day 1, no one knows anything for sure so the town vs town dwindled out instead of ramping up (his conclusion).
    Im interested in your proof ghosting.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mind Screw Salvation Mafia - Endgame: When The Seagulls Cry, There Are No Survivors
    Hey necarg.

    Gut reaction without rereading TS and Tom yet, which one do you peg as scum?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mind Screw Salvation Mafia - Endgame: When The Seagulls Cry, There Are No Survivors
    Currently looking over the last couple pages.

    I'm thoroughly confused why I'd have a role that gives me rules in this game when it matched up to onr of the old rules of another mind screw mafia.

    Also I think if be fine with lynching Az. I'm curious what would happen.

    @hans
    You said you asked me something? Couldn't find it.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mind Screw Salvation Mafia - Endgame: When The Seagulls Cry, There Are No Survivors
    Hey nacho, where did you get that list of rules?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mind Screw Salvation Mafia - Endgame: When The Seagulls Cry, There Are No Survivors
    So I think Tom is pretty derpy and when he first town cleared hans I thought it was a blatant scum slip. If he feigned more and more ignorance, I would have fully pushed his lynch.

    He didn't. I disagree with some of his logic but he isn't "playing dumb" as what I would expect from scum tom.

    Also I think he is very prone to blatantly scumslipping so I'm not worried.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mind Screw Salvation Mafia - Endgame: When The Seagulls Cry, There Are No Survivors
    I'm not sure what's wrong with having doubts. I disagree with your main point on two fronts. One, I think it's ok being on the fence about someone and two, you are accusing me of leaving the possibility of future scummy play... that doesn't really make sense... It's like you think you are a precog from minority report, except you can't see the future.

    Also i don't think some of your assumptions apply to me as they would to other players but that's whatever.


    @everyone else
    Speaking of doubts.

    unvote Tom

    The tapping and tom is town vs town.

    I have a few meta reasons why I think Tom is town but blah blah on going game cant elaborate wit concrete examples. Let's just say he would make even less sense if he was scum... and if I am wrong and he is, he will still be caught pretty quickly.




    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mind Screw Salvation Mafia - Endgame: When The Seagulls Cry, There Are No Survivors
    So you don't like me taking no stance on someone after disliking a post they made?

    My initial scum read is now my biggest town read. It's page 6 on day 1 and most people are still null to me. I'm not sure if ghost is scum or just has a different view of the game than I do.

    Tom and anak both town cleared hans instantly without evidence. Can you please explain your thoughts on those players?

    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mind Screw Salvation Mafia - Endgame: When The Seagulls Cry, There Are No Survivors
    Quote from Ghosting »
    Now I see your questions, Hawk, and I think I may have kind of answered them in my last post? To expand:

    I simply wanted more time rather than no time to at least discuss the potential ramifications of the claim. There's been a lot of stuff going on, and with the Hans claim, governor claim, etc., I believed it would be best to at least have SOME semblance of discussion before another claim is thrown out there.


    You need to specifically answer why you think the rule I provided helps scum more than town, which is what you said
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mind Screw Salvation Mafia - Endgame: When The Seagulls Cry, There Are No Survivors
    Also one thing I should mention before I forget is the rule I listed earlier was given a number 2. Not sure how many rules there are but maybe I can get a random upper bound later to estimate.

    @rob

    Have we ever played together?

    Also I'd like you to answer the 2 questions I asked ghosting earlier, but I would like him to answer first.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Mind Screw Salvation Mafia - Endgame: When The Seagulls Cry, There Are No Survivors
    Quote from Ghosting »
    Quote from 7hawk77 »
    Hey ghosting.

    Please explain how "we didn't need the scum getting this much information so early" knowing that. A.) This rule might not even exist in this game, it's just a possibility and B.) Why do you think this is actually useful to the scum team more so than town?


    @Tom

    Hey tom. You enjoying your this game so far?

    @Everyone else
    I think hans is my biggest town read right now.


    Since I asked the question first, can you answer it? I'd prefer to have questions answered rather than deflected with a question on myself. I have no problem answering, but please give me the same honor. What benefit do you gain by not discussing?


    The problem is you are trying to control my play without the knowledge my role brings. I don't find discussion that useful about roles and game setup unless I'm very familiar with the player. For example rhand and myself come to different conclusions about game and roles pretty often. If proph asked to wait, I probably would have waited. I don't know you, I don't trust you and you saying blanket statements like that seems like you are trying to act towny but really not doing anything.


    Also its called OMGUS. And generally that happens when someone votes and then an immediate counter vote happens. Also im not completely sold you are scum so I'm not sure why you think that would apply.

    Now please answer my previous questions. Also how much experience do you have playing forum mafia?

    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.