Seems too powerful. Maybe make it when a creature deals combat damage return a creature you control to your hand? That way you only get 1 per creature. That is still very very powerful though.
I agree with y'all actually. I had thought the same thing after posting. Face up is definitely better for this type of card. Maybe it needs Splitsecond or something else of that nature to make it uncountable? I don't like the idea of telegraphing the cards more so than absolutely necessary.
Really like the idea. White one does seem like the least useful. I'd say they should be played and remain in exile facedown until all conditions are met. That way the opponent can't see what exactly is coming. If you have a few of them in each color then it could throw the opponent off and they may not guess correctly.
The heights version seem like it can easily be messed over though. A Ghost Quarter or Field of Ruin can mess up plans or just having enough removal to keep you down to 2 or less guys. Personally, and I haven't played it, but feel like your original take was better.
Seems like you are the mono white aggro master my good sir. Well done on those games. Yeah that game 3 looked pretty good. Which version are you liking better?
This is true but I feel like other than Emmy we can find another I win card. Ideas? These other cards are all fluff but there has to be something... Maybe the spell that lets you cast anything without it's casting cost? Nevermind it's already in there. Haha. I can't think of another card better than what's already in here. Got to be an improvement that can be made ...
T1 Mothdust Changeling
T2 Magda, Brazen Outlaw, tap both to Mothdust ability, get two treasures.
T3 Tap Magda & Mothdust to make two more treasures. 7 Mana on turn 3 sounds pretty nice.
Forgot to play any dwarf or changling to search your deck for a dragon. That's pretty fast and brutal.
I find it funny how the colors shifted from the very beginning. In the beginning returning to the battlefield without a drawback was exclusively a white ability. Black could but hurt you or the creature in some way. Now white is supposed the color that returns it to hand and red returns it to the battlefield. Although almost all the red cards that do it are phoenixes. I'm sure that was just a decision made because a phoenix is associated with fire. Red is fire. It's not really a red ability though.
The first card should tax you, not the opponent. I can see a game where both players get one out. If a player cracks a fetch or something of that nature then both players can empty their library of planes. If it's going to be a tax on the opponent then it should say when the second land is put into the battlefield.
I agree completely with the above poster. The effect does feel more white red than white blue but it's such a close margin that either would work. Could also make it an instant that bounces it and then that would feel more blue red.
I also enjoyed the read. But I think you did a few things wrong. #1 equip should be endurance A+. They will probably always have equips in every set or block and there is no way they will ever run out of ideas for the keyword. #2 Banding should have been #1. I mean come on man.
Forgot to play any dwarf or changling to search your deck for a dragon. That's pretty fast and brutal.
The first card should tax you, not the opponent. I can see a game where both players get one out. If a player cracks a fetch or something of that nature then both players can empty their library of planes. If it's going to be a tax on the opponent then it should say when the second land is put into the battlefield.