A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
 
Exclusive: Sword of Truth and Justice
  • posted a message on Hill House Mafia Day 2: Tom Does Dallas
    FYI, if I was scum with Lng (or in general) I’d tell my buddies not to do rule of three cause it’s a thing. Pretty sure I’ve actually mentioned it in scum chat in some of my previous games.

    Is no one going to like...look a Chris even?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Hill House Mafia Day 2: Tom Does Dallas
    Ftr silver, that’s not really softing in a way that I would consider indicative (IE, I have “softed” nearly identically as Vanilla before).
    As for why you and Chris different, because your game play overall was very different? Like, I had some niggling things on Chris anyway, and you’ve been high posting and generally not really given me much to side eye from you.

    (And seriously....why did you claim, and then buckle to pressure about claiming results immediately? Like really dude?)

    I actually think I want to see what happens here with
    Vote Chris

    (I kind of want Vaimes catch on rod to be real, but I also kind of think Rod might be the type to do that as either alignment)
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Hill House Mafia Day 2: Tom Does Dallas
    @Cantrip, I remember seeing you ask a question of me when skimming, but I don’t remember what it is.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Hill House Mafia Day 2: Tom Does Dallas
    I have returned. Pretty tired, but some quick thoughts:

    Last v rod is both irritating to read, and seems more likely tvt, not even taking claims into consideration.

    I’m kind of not sure why literally no one is talking about Chris today, his position on Lng and pseudo trying to push the lynch anywhere else while also not really defending him is eyebrow raising.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Hill House Mafia Day 2: Tom Does Dallas
    Sitting in an airport, not much time.

    @Silver: as far as I can tell you have given no read on me whatsoever, and just left it at “I can’t read shadow” which hasn’t ever stopped you from trying before. Why not even try?

    Also, can you go into more detail why you’re reading Lng and Grape as anti aligned? I’m not particularly low on Grape, but I certainly don’t think their interaction at eod is unfakeable, especially not if there is day chat and coaching took place.

    @last: why Tom?

    I’m out.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Hill House Mafia Day 2: Tom Does Dallas
    I have much less time this trip than I thought, I apologize. Just did a quick(ish) catchup, and seriously, first off, what even is wrong with the 3 or so people saying they’d vote me, literally nothing has changed since I went on V/LA you ninnies.

    I’m not moving my vote, rhand is townie, Grape is townie, Last is self resolving and I’m never lynching Chris or Tom day one with the effort they’ve each put in. Stop playing games and lynch Lng like we should have and not had an extension to piddle around with. If he’s not scum, it’s unlikely at this point he’ll clear himself, and another replacement is just not good.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Hill House Mafia Day 2: Tom Does Dallas
    I...don’t think I’ve seen silver get that mad before. Not that I remember anyway.
    Quote from Sir Chris »
    Silver if you had a vig shot that only worked on people with 50+ posts, who would you shoot and why?
    To be clear, the player pool is [Chris, tom, shadow, Grape].

    Probably shadow? I don't really want to kill any of them toDay but if Grape is a wolf I'll definitely be able to resolve him, and I feel slightly worse about shadow than I do tom on a gut check (I have a pretty bad track record reading both of them).

    Still think you're probably just a wrong villager, really.
    If Grape is a wolf why not resolve him and then go for his buddies off interaction though?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Hill House Mafia Day 2: Tom Does Dallas
    He has two wolf games and some other games where he’s replaced out. I would be pretty surprised if he got his pm here and said “yes, I’m going to top post as a wolf and really make this my breakout game”. If he’s got a cheerleader that would certainly help, but it would surprise me.

    I will slightly confess that I still have niggling doubts about you, so when you go after someone I like it has me worried. It took pressure on you to get you here, and while I’ve liked you since you’ve been here, as you say, you don’t have all those awards for nothing.

    So let’s dance on silver; show me the post in response to you that you think most showcases his scumminess. Show me the post before you engaged him that most raised your eyebrows.

    (I recognize you’re working on Grape as well, do what you need to do, I’ll be in and out at best through eod)
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Hill House Mafia Day 2: Tom Does Dallas
    Chris, I don’t want to lynch the top poster not because he’s the top poster, but because he looks like his town self and doesn’t look like his scum self. No, he’s not outside of his range, but he’s not really in it. If you’re going to stop the Lng wagon, fine, give me someone worth lynching today then.

    Using online status is actually not really okay, so let’s not talk about that.

    That being said, if the only argument for not lynching Lng is “he’s not here” I’m not whelmed.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Hill House Mafia Day 2: Tom Does Dallas
    Wolfy pop in.

    Silver isn’t strictly outside his scum meta, but he’s pretty clearly within his town meta, down to the awkward as crap self awareness. I’m not lynching him, especially when other people (Lng) are very clearly within their scum meta.

    Really I have yet to see any truly compelling argument to lynch outside of Lng. Like, if anyone actually has a compelling town case on him I’m all ears.

    (@Mafia)
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Hill House Mafia Day 2: Tom Does Dallas
    For anyone unfamiliar, Lng is somewhat of a low hanging fruit player in general, but as town he’s thoughtful, engaged, and can be incredulous. I don’t see any of that here, the most he’s really done is omgus and piddle around without digging into the thread. It’s not like, a rock solid case, but it’s day 1 and we need to not no lynch.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Hill House Mafia Day 2: Tom Does Dallas
    Quote from tomsloger »
    Quote from Killjoy »
    Mod note: Deadline will be set for July 7 around noon PST
    TY, somehow I missed that. I will not be around for deadline, so let’s try and get something rolling please.

    Can everyone post their preferred lynch targets? I prefer Lng, am generally against rhand, and my thoughts on Ruma have already been stated.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Hill House Mafia Day 2: Tom Does Dallas
    @Mod
    When is the deadline?
    Also, I will be V/LA from 7/6-7/13, will plan to check in at least every other day, but I’ll be on vacation.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Hill House Mafia Day 2: Tom Does Dallas
    @Lng: if you’re town, can you get in here and engage?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Hill House Mafia Day 2: Tom Does Dallas
    Quote from Sir Chris »
    ##unvote: Will

    I wake up to a good question from Will, glad to see it.

    I think this reflects very poorly on Lng, because in my experience scum will often times proceed through the game and not carry their vote with them. So Lng posting a decent amount but not really progressing his reads. It's a good catch.

    Any reason you didn’t accompany this post with a vote? Do you have a reads list/player breakdown?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.