- Registered User
Member for 12 years, 5 months, and 20 days
Last active Wed, Dec, 22 2021 17:14:17
- 3 Followers
- 2,686 Total Posts
- 115 Thanks
May 25, 2021I still don't understand why wizards is playing it so conservatively with the weird foil treatments on their cards. The Force of Will tcg had really neat, elaborate "etched" foils years before wizards started dipping their toes into alt foil styles. There are probably production considerations, and I guess I could understand wizards being phobic about producing a stinker foil cycle (not that they haven't released some questionable frame styles over the years). Just puzzles me why they're so late to the game on interesting, creative foil treatments.Posted in: The Rumor Mill
May 16, 2021Dolono posted a message on Good Morning Magic- Info on the upcoming preconstructed commander decks (NO SPOILERS)Arguments about 60 card casual vs commander precons aside, I'm pretty dismayed they're doing another round of 4 decks right after strixhaven's 5. Assuming they're $40 again, this will be a massive strain on the wallet trying to keeping up with 3 constructed sets (strix, MH2, ARF), plus an annual commander release (C21), plus another annual commander-sized release.Posted in: The Rumor Mill
I wish they'd stick a bit closer to the release + 2 $20 commander deck model. Those commander decks, IMO, have been exceptional products in terms of value and deck quality. Zendikar and Kaldheim's were really well designed.
Apr 3, 2021Dolono posted a message on Set (P)review - My top 20 Strixhaven (STX) cards for the cube!Thanks for the great write up! It's certainly an interesting, flavorful set but I'm frankly glad it doesn't have too much going on for it, cube-wise. I'm still trying to catch my breath from 2019-2020!Posted in: Articles, Podcasts, and Guides
Nov 2, 2020Dolono posted a message on [CMR] Araumi of the Dead Tide and self-mill cards— MTGGoldfish previewsPosted in: The Rumor MillQuote from ashrog »I have been working on a "board game/box set" of Pauper/Peasant Commander decks since Dominaria.
First Thalisse and now Araumi give great build-around commanders at uncommon for color pairs that only had weak options before. Love it!
I used to maintain a pauper edh cube years ago. I might have to dust off that idea again after this set drops. There are some fantastic new legends at uncommon, and the mono colored partner mechanic would really help smooth out some issues in the draft department.
Sep 10, 2020For EDH cube I'm thinking the following:Posted in: Cube Card and Archetype Discussion
Lithoform Engine - cut deathrender
Moraug, Fury of Akoum - cut savage beating
Bala Ged Recovery
Nullpriest of Oblivion
The black, red, and green mythic flip lands all appeal to me, but I don't think any of them are must includes. I may swap them in as I pick them up incidentally from pack cracking or trades.
Sep 4, 2020Thanks for the reply and interesting cube proposals. I agree completely on the opportunities for flavor and lore "wins" with this format. With some thought and care crafting packs, I'm sure some great stories could be built off the back of magic variants like planechase; really "boardgame-afying" magic. For instance, theme packs depicting the old walkers, weatherlight crew, phyrexians, and other side factions + planechase for a "weatherlight saga jumpstart cube" would be an amazing achievement in set building!Posted in: The Cube Forum
Based on the proposal you've written above, you'd be dispensing with all the rarity distributions in normal jumpstart packs, and going straight to high powered archetypes in each?
Jun 27, 2020I'd be interested personally, but I think the traffic on this site has died down to the point where there might not be enough interaction for the effort. I think you'd probably get a higher volume of feedback posting on one of the reddit cube forums.Posted in: Cube Card and Archetype Discussion
Jun 26, 2020Thanks for the response! I could definitely envision your two dual decks scaled down to this format and plenty of your other ideas fleshed out. I see from your inclusion of turbo fog and nic fit that you were also thinking about how to do legacy/modern archetype and combo package themes. These could actually lead to some very interesting decks, as plenty of competitive constructed decks over the years have just been grafting one successful archetype on top of another, leading to a new deck; thopter sword + dark depths is the one that first came to mind for me.Posted in: Cube Card and Archetype Discussion
I love that there's really no limit to the specificity of themes, including completely arbitrary artist packages or even people/objects featured in the artwork (I remember there was an old edh deck thread of "women looking to the left").
After working on a few samples, I think the main design constraint is really ramp and color fixing, and having to make sure that there aren't too many nonbos lurking in potential pairings. The windstorm I included in the Surrak deck would most likely be a dead card if the player also landed up with wizard's above the clouds or pegasus themes.
Jun 25, 2020A long time ago, when I was busy building up my collection of draft sims, I was extremely interested in the concept of set-specific, minor archetypes, such as Avacyn Restored's "loner." These were the kinds of archetypes that were way too insular or under-powered to ever make their way into a standard cube environment, but were still interesting and flavorful. With the advent of Jumpstart it seems like there are some great opportunities to craft unique and interesting "themes" for use in an ultra fast and casual cube variant.Posted in: Cube Card and Archetype Discussion
I'm creating the following thread as a space to post Jumpstart cubes, decklists (themes), and even just lists of theme ideas folks have thought up for this format.
Below are a few sample themes I cooked up in my spare time. Warning, they are DUMB, but the format has definitely got my juices flowing for concepts that would be difficult to pull off in cube, or even in EDH. So far, I've been conforming to most of WotC's design principles for the jumpstart product: low-ish power level (1-3 rares max), theme trumps optimal card choices (mix of commons and uncommons), 8/5/7 creature/spell/land split, budget friendly, and with some effort made to help themes "mix" together. Like regular cube, I'm sure sky's the limit on how crazy you could make themes, unshackled by cost, rarity, or card availability constraints ("Mox Theme").
Jun 23, 2020Now that the set's been spoiled, and we know the composition of packs, just curious if Jumpstart has gotten anyone thinking about variants or implications for the cube format? I can see a lot of ways for a casual or budget cube designer to run with this:Posted in: The Cube Forum
1. Remove duplicate themes from a box, keep the deck lists, sleeve up the remainder, and run this as a draft sim. Perhaps collecting additional themes that weren't present in the first box.
2. Refine, add to, and tune certain themes, so they're either more powerful or just function more smoothly.
3. Create entirely new themes.
4. Work on adding more "glue" cards to the packs, so there's more synergy between each random pack pairing.
5. Since most sets will have a featured tribe, character, and/or mechanic, add new packs to the "cube" with each release.
In the interest of not having to sleeve so many lands, I could see making packs of between 13 and 15 cards (depending on the # of non basics included), and allowing players to pick their basics out of the land station the cube owner provides.
I'd be interested in hearing what other folks have been thinking!
PS. Stupid proof of concept:
DeckMagic OnlineOCTGN2ApprenticeBuy These Cards Creatures
1 Hunted Nightmare
1 Faceless Butcher
1 Mesmeric Fiend
1 Plague Mare
1 Wormfang Drake
1 Paragon of Open Graves
1 Hideous End
1 Aspect of Lamprey
1 Breathstealer's Crypt
1 Drake-Skull Cameo
1 Salt Marsh
1 Thriving Isle
Jun 22, 2020Dolono posted a message on Set (P)review - My top 20 Magic 2021 (M21) cards for the cube!Thanks for the great read! I'm still formulating my edh cube changes but looking primarily at:Posted in: Articles, Podcasts, and Guides
Radha, Heart of Keld
Mangara, the Diplomat
Basri's Lieutenant (test)
See the Truth
Teferi's Ageless Insight (test)
Barrin, Tolarian Archmage
Liliana's Standard Bearer (test)
Gadrak, the Crown-Scourge (test)
Mazemind Tome (test)
Do you think that standard bearer could be a good replacement for disciple of bolas? Not sure if folks are even running that gal anymore...
- To post a comment, please login or register a new account.