1. Silvercrys3467 - about null. Might be scum just by PoE
2. Lastwhisper - pretty solidly town. I played two game with Wisp scum and his play here does not remind me of those games at all.
3. shadowlancerxJackritoProphylaxis - ??? If I had a gun to my head I'd say town, but the role is so weird and his actions even more so.
4. Vaimes - probably scum. The fact that he isn't posting a lot kinda cements that read for me.
5. KittyCupCake - play makes me think town. the way she reacted to nacho's CC is still town.
6. vezokpiraka - Obv town
7. Rhand - Probably scum. His reads and his play have been very cautious. To me he seemed like he built justification for reads after deciding on them
8. dkingsland967 - Probably town. Bodyguard seems reasonable in this setup.
9. M1ndreaverKeldeo - Keldeo has been pretty townie, but I still have doubts about M1ndreaver. I'll probably explore this closer to LyLo.
10. Axelrod - Meh. I'm pretty null on axel. He wasn't scummy per se, but I haven't seen the brilliance of town Axel yet.
11. Killjoy - All his posts screamed town. I won't be terribly surprised if he is actually great scum, but that's a low possibility.
13. SlothfulGrapefruit21 - mason buddy.
16. fulcrum - No idea to be honest. The way she claimed makes me think town, but behaviour makes me shrug.
17. Asta - Probably town double-voter.
So I'm at Rhand/Vaimes/{Keldeo/Axel/silver}. I'm probably wrong somewhere, but there's so many people I think are town.
I'm really out of the game and grape isn't much more into. I barely have coherent thoughts to post in thread, let alone stuff that we should discuss as masons. I'll try to re-read or something in weekend and talk a bit with grape, but I can't really promise anything.
I thought about something. If a wagon goes beyond 8 votes without me and grape on it, then it's probably a wagon on town. That means scum have to bus seriously or we can just exclude them in a pile of non-voters.
@proph: Do your orbs survive after your death?
I'm still debating if scum shadow would send me a protection orb just to mess with me or this is town shadow who simply read me correctly in a few posts.
So we still need to talk to decide on wagon, but if you are town, you're gonna have to vote on the biggest wagon regardless of your opinion of it. Otherwise we'll just lynch town.
Heyo, haven't thought about this game since before Christmas. Catching up now. Looking at Tom's role I want to go back an look at the RB claims from earlier. Because tom definitely seems like some light town disruption. But in a high powered game like this I'm not sure how much that creates exclusivity.
Mod confirmation of protection is utterly bizarre but I'm town reading Asta so happy enough to leave that be for now.
Going to try and look closely at Silver in a bit, Vez has been pushing that for a while and I don't trust myself enough to stick with my town read.
Are you two sure you're masons?
We don't really talk in Quicktopic. Last thing I said during the night was that I wanted to reread you because I think you're scummy. My opinion changed a bit since then.
Silver ia right. We started on quicktopic and moved to discord.
Sloth was absent everywhere. Gemma said that sloth is purposefully avoiding the thread and that made me scumread her a bit, because sloth was simply not posting anywhere and I thought she was just trying to push an easy lynch.
I will reread the thread tomorrow and see what I can dig up.
I have more to say about silver now that nacho is dead, but I'm away at family and can only phone post. I don't even like the way they commented on the nightkill. The only WIFOMy thing was that they killed tom instead of masons, but tom has been such a powerhouse all of yesterday, that I really didn't see any other believable way.
Everyone also seems to be ignoring that scum had the chance to shoot Vezok as a mason yesterday and instead shot Gemma. Do you think that scum shoots Gemma if she's completely wrong on me and her main couple of scumreads just because she "looks town"?
Idk? Kills are just wine anyways, for the most part at least
Yeah, this is bad wifom. I've done nothing of value since the beginning of the game. Even if gemma was wrong on a lot of reads (which she was, she had slothful as scum) she was townread by almost everyone and could turn around to see the error of her ways.
@Keldeo: Proph already clarified he meant Green orb.
1. Silvercrys3467 - about null. Might be scum just by PoE
2. Lastwhisper - pretty solidly town. I played two game with Wisp scum and his play here does not remind me of those games at all.
3. shadowlancerxJackritoProphylaxis - ??? If I had a gun to my head I'd say town, but the role is so weird and his actions even more so.
4. Vaimes - probably scum. The fact that he isn't posting a lot kinda cements that read for me.
5. KittyCupCake - play makes me think town. the way she reacted to nacho's CC is still town.
6. vezokpiraka - Obv town
7. Rhand - Probably scum. His reads and his play have been very cautious. To me he seemed like he built justification for reads after deciding on them
8. dkingsland967 - Probably town. Bodyguard seems reasonable in this setup.
9. M1ndreaverKeldeo - Keldeo has been pretty townie, but I still have doubts about M1ndreaver. I'll probably explore this closer to LyLo.
10. Axelrod - Meh. I'm pretty null on axel. He wasn't scummy per se, but I haven't seen the brilliance of town Axel yet.
11. Killjoy - All his posts screamed town. I won't be terribly surprised if he is actually great scum, but that's a low possibility.
13. SlothfulGrapefruit21 - mason buddy.
16. fulcrum - No idea to be honest. The way she claimed makes me think town, but behaviour makes me shrug.
17. Asta - Probably town double-voter.
So I'm at Rhand/Vaimes/{Keldeo/Axel/silver}. I'm probably wrong somewhere, but there's so many people I think are town.
@proph: Do your orbs survive after your death?
I'm still debating if scum shadow would send me a protection orb just to mess with me or this is town shadow who simply read me correctly in a few posts.
So we still need to talk to decide on wagon, but if you are town, you're gonna have to vote on the biggest wagon regardless of your opinion of it. Otherwise we'll just lynch town.
We don't really talk in Quicktopic. Last thing I said during the night was that I wanted to reread you because I think you're scummy. My opinion changed a bit since then.
Another readlist. I'm willing to pursue anyone after grape/killjoy except dk.
I isoed gemma and found this readlist. She's wrong on sloth. I kinda want to kill Rhand after reading gemma's iso.
vote Rhand
Sloth was absent everywhere. Gemma said that sloth is purposefully avoiding the thread and that made me scumread her a bit, because sloth was simply not posting anywhere and I thought she was just trying to push an easy lynch.
I will reread the thread tomorrow and see what I can dig up.
I have more to say about silver now that nacho is dead, but I'm away at family and can only phone post. I don't even like the way they commented on the nightkill. The only WIFOMy thing was that they killed tom instead of masons, but tom has been such a powerhouse all of yesterday, that I really didn't see any other believable way.
Yeah, this is bad wifom. I've done nothing of value since the beginning of the game. Even if gemma was wrong on a lot of reads (which she was, she had slothful as scum) she was townread by almost everyone and could turn around to see the error of her ways.
execute nacho
The fact that the day kill came right after nacho switched to summer is just too much for me.