IIRC you claimed proph's ability after he already claimed them, you put a safe bet on Keldeo not targetting Gemma, because how could he, and then you claimed Asta was targeted by this mysterious message on day 1.
All this could easily be solver if Asta didn't receive a message and you're just covering for them.
Muddled. When I said that I thought the teams were either exactly Asta/KCC or exactly Fulcrum/Killjoy but my earlier plan loses to fulcrum/KCC teams and that's kind of where I'm at right now. He was definitely targeted by "something" on N1 and I don't reaaaaally think he's faking emotion at being set up toDay but that's. Kinda thin.
Even if it isn't exactly fulcrum/KCC lunching them both in some order should hit a wolf. Asta first is... well, if he flips town, fulcrum should always be a wolf with either KCC or Killjoy, then F4 would be like, me/you/KCC/Killjoy or something and we have to pick between them?
If he's a wolf fulcrum can't be one so it's just KCC
But I think I'd rather lunch KCC -> fulcrum or vice-versa, that should always hit a wolf if not end the game, and if fulcrum is town we get town killjoy with a BPV into F4, if KCC is town we just lunch fulcrum -> Killjoy since he had to have done the N4 busdrive/redirect/whatever changed Vaimes' results
We are in no way going with a plan that does not involve killing Asta. This just feels like scum silver trying to tie up the game pretty badly.
If dk/asta are scum/scum then the message is a mistake from Asta and that would kinda make dking disprove it, but at the same time they should have discussed this in scum chat and not come out so badly.
If dk/Asta are scum/town then dking worked with the mafia to send the message so he shouldn't be confused by it. It was his way to rope another mislynch in case he dies. So that means the mafia couldn't have sent this message in this case. That means the message was either invented by asta or sent by a third party and dking was afraid that asta was running a gambit to make him claim something untrue about the way his role interacted. None of these situations make that much sense which means that Asta has to be scum for this whole ordeal to have sense, but if Asta is scum why claim the message at all?
Rhand is a big nerd who played 11 (out of 14) games.
Congratulations to Cantipmancer who has the best win rate at 66% in his 9 games.
Special commiserations to Rumanashi for playing the most games without a win (5).
I am missing from your speadsheet and this makes me sad.
There's 3 years in there. You're in 2018 and 2019.
I really want to know what the **** is happening. I have an exam today and need to finish another project before i'm done with this semester, but after that I want to dig up Axelrod's post with the claims and fill in the blanks.
Like Asta is outed scum. They said they received a confirmation message for dkings bodyguard which is obviously a lie. dkings also claimed they sent no message so it's not scum messing with actions at night.
Pretty sure silver is also just scum here. Anything else to say before we wrap it up?
Rhand is a big nerd who played 11 (out of 14) games.
Congratulations to Cantipmancer who has the best win rate at 66% in his 9 games.
Special commiserations to Rumanashi for playing the most games without a win (5).
I am missing from your speadsheet and this makes me sad.
are u insane... We absolutely do not flip this before fulcrum...
Sure, whichever
unvote vote Fulcrum
Can we not? Fulcrum is putting in work, has been pretty consistent on everything and has TWO abilities confirmed by Vaimes. I know it sucks we don't have a good investigative, but fulcrum is not a great lynch for today.
Flipping dkings today leaves us in a much better position for tomorrow with one less active player down and a bigger restriction on the POE. Killing fulcrum now makes scum shoot KJ and we miss whatever information he still holds.
Silver/dk/?asta maybe fits much better than fulcrum/kj/?silver or some other combination.
All this could easily be solver if Asta didn't receive a message and you're just covering for them.
Silver/Asta is still a possibility for the rest of us. Your abilities are not very confirmable.
We are in no way going with a plan that does not involve killing Asta. This just feels like scum silver trying to tie up the game pretty badly.
If dk/asta are scum/scum then the message is a mistake from Asta and that would kinda make dking disprove it, but at the same time they should have discussed this in scum chat and not come out so badly.
If dk/Asta are scum/town then dking worked with the mafia to send the message so he shouldn't be confused by it. It was his way to rope another mislynch in case he dies. So that means the mafia couldn't have sent this message in this case. That means the message was either invented by asta or sent by a third party and dking was afraid that asta was running a gambit to make him claim something untrue about the way his role interacted. None of these situations make that much sense which means that Asta has to be scum for this whole ordeal to have sense, but if Asta is scum why claim the message at all?
Whoa. Sorry then. I'm not good with spreadsheets.
I have no idea how to solve this right now. I need to go back and reread dkings. I'll do that tomorrow and come back
I really want to know what the **** is happening. I have an exam today and need to finish another project before i'm done with this semester, but after that I want to dig up Axelrod's post with the claims and fill in the blanks.
Pretty sure silver is also just scum here. Anything else to say before we wrap it up?
Made the dead person have a vote today probably.
Anyway vote asta
I am missing from your speadsheet and this makes me sad.
Can we not? Fulcrum is putting in work, has been pretty consistent on everything and has TWO abilities confirmed by Vaimes. I know it sucks we don't have a good investigative, but fulcrum is not a great lynch for today.
Flipping dkings today leaves us in a much better position for tomorrow with one less active player down and a bigger restriction on the POE. Killing fulcrum now makes scum shoot KJ and we miss whatever information he still holds.
Silver/dk/?asta maybe fits much better than fulcrum/kj/?silver or some other combination.
KCC seems to be town though.