I was really hoping we could get Necarg's scores as well, but it has been forever now, so lets go with the three judges scores. That makes bravelion83 the winner of the April round!!
Sorry for the long wait, as mentioned in the above posts, I should have just closed it and called it on the scores we had available, my apologizes for that. But now the round is officially closed and we have a winner!
(2/3) Quality: It should be "Return target creature card with power 2 or less from your graveyard to the battlefield."
Copy-pasting it here instead of quoting because with the latest changes to the forum layout, quoting a post automatically makes it all italics, and that's not good for custom cards. That is a problem I will have to face also as a judge in future months by the way. I think I will do the same: copy/paste instead of quoting. It seems easier than making screenshots and attaching them to the judging post.
Erebos’s DecreeBBB
Sorcery (R)
Choose two or more —
- Create a tapped 2/2 black Zombie creature token.
- Each player sacrifices a creature.
- Return a creature card with power 2 or less from your graveyard to the battlefield.
- Each player loses X life, where X is your devotion to black. Erebos doesn’t need to speak to let his will be known. A stroke of his whip is enough.
It doesn't matter for the scores, but I feel like I have to explain my thought process. The use of "a creature card" without the word "target" was completely intentional and a late change to the card. In fact, it has to be like this to achieve the functionality I intended, that is allowing you to reanimate with the third mode the same creature you just sacrificed with the second one, breaking the symmetry of the second effect with an in-card trick. If it said "target", you would have to choose targets as you cast this spell and the creature you will sacrifice is not in the graveyard yet so it can't be chosen. There is a functional difference: using "a" instead of "target" allows you to make the choice as the spell resolves, and when it does you follow the...
Sorry for the late reply, took the kids away for the weekend. I now see what you did there. I did chalk it of as a mistake, but reading the explanation and idea behind it, it makes sense the way you did it.
I am done with March's judgments. We still need two more Judges!! There will be cake!! (We have 2 backup judges, but I think they really want to play this month )
4
Sorry for the long wait, as mentioned in the above posts, I should have just closed it and called it on the scores we had available, my apologizes for that. But now the round is officially closed and we have a winner!
1
The_Hittite (20.5 + 23 + 21) = 64.5
bravelion83 (22 + 22.5 + 23) = 67.5
Vertain (17.5 + 20.5 + 22.5) = 60.5
Tesco(black)lotus (19.5 + 19.5 + 22) = 61
This makes bravelion83 the winner for April!!
1
1
Sorry for the late reply, took the kids away for the weekend. I now see what you did there. I did chalk it of as a mistake, but reading the explanation and idea behind it, it makes sense the way you did it.
1
Edit:
Round two is up, will add Necarg's top 4 as soon as he is done.
2
Freyleyes
Tilwin
Indighost
Necarg
1
1
1
1