All users will need to merge their MTGSalvation account with a new or existing Twitch account starting Sept 25th. You can merge your accounts by clicking here. Have questions? Learn more here.
Dismiss
 
The Role of Ecosystems in Fantasy Worldbuilding
 
Life's Legacy: Delving into Delver
 
All Sets Are Good: Prophecy
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Also if there's a neutral out there that isn't AZ you have a pretty dope bargaining chip to make us let you achieve a wincon because claiming it now outs one or both of az/rodemy.

    Technically the claim would put you in a trichotomy that always contains [1-2 neutral, 1-2 scum, 0-1 town] but pretty much a garauntee you outlive the other 2
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    The azrael-shaped iceberg still seems far enough away. We gonna crash into it on night 2? Seems unlikely to me.
    He's probably lying about the exact shape. It's pretty common knowledge that 90% of an iceberg is below the surface. God this metaphor is perfect...

    But with rodemy confirming multiple parts of his role, there is a neutral that's stealing souls. I doubt the neutral would ever be able to win faster than he could try to side with the scumteam at 3-1-4 on day 4 (or the scumteam could lynch him ftw).

    So it seems like that's the latest we could deal with it. I could see an argument for lynching him day 3 before he even gets a chance to choose a side.

    And if he's scum rather than neutral, rodemy is all but lock his partner. And we can chain that before lylo.

    And if there's town killpower out there somewhere, it's ~always used on him.

    Let's lynch scum (again?) today
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Hiding flips isn't pro-neutral. It's only pro-scum.

    And AZ at this point is probably just neutral (or scum with rodemy, who seems town to me)

    Idk if the kraken is related to the lack of flips. But it's the biggest worry for me rather than the kraken, and I'm hoping that there's someone to lynch to make it stop.

    And if az is scum he's probably not that person based on claim. I think?

    This post did nothing for me or anyone. Lynch scummy people. Technically that's not AZ.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    @shadow
    you are welcome to go back to where I talked about it yesterday. I have nothing new.

    @dota
    I appreciate a new wind blowing in. And he could totally be scum. But what do you think of anyone else?
    Did you read the whole game or just archmage iso?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Quote from Nancy Drew 39 »

    I confess; I have never ever liked D1 and can't wait for D2; when I actually feel I actually have some real knowledge to work with.

    What if the knowledge doesn't come? Do you just sail listlessly?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    I mean, putting rhand low when all signs point to him being the NK is a bit silly but we aren't getting alignment flips so you still have to put dead players on your readslist (like in a witchhunt)
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Kazin claim doesn't actually make sense to me but I also don't care at all.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Quote from shadowlancerx »
    So just so that I have it on record: Do you actively believe that Dawning and I are dichotomized? As in, do you actively believe we both can’t be town?

    Not sure where i would even get such information barring a CC. But I strongly believe dawning to have been scum, and in the offchance she wasn't your scum equity goes way up.

    Actually... sure. I think there's exactly one scum in you/dawn 95% of the time.
    But you make up ~rand of that percentage.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    I, too, have been scum with Joe. We won even.
    And yes I agree he's... solving... here.

    But the crux of it is not the meta, but the concern with appearing town rather than just doing what he does.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Clicking around and I think I like my vote.

    Joeterry is very appeasing on this journey. Which... may sound strange if you've not played with him before...
    He remains abrasive as ever. Just seeing and reacting. That's NAI.

    But going deeper. Where often he can abrade and get something out of it. The background thinking. Here, it's replaced with the wheedling, the smoothing over, the clarifications.
    "I was just joking"
    "That's not what I meant"

    This joe is more concerned that people townread him than with getting ***** done.

    Townjoe is a steamliner. This is a tugboat.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    I mean...

    Az can die he's almost never *town* here
    but it feels like the iceberg is still pretty far away
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Wait, did Rod just claim cephalopodomaniac that tries to hump squids!?

    This feels like Joe trying to replicate zero escape Joe and very lightly failing at it?

    Maybe?

    That might be stupid...

    Shrugs

    vote: stinkyjoeterry
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    On the other hand, i don't think he was conspiring with dawning. And making him walk the plank would all but garauntee we only get one the first two days.
    Which isn't terrible in no flip but not amazing.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Shadow, the gills
    Just, seems to know what's going on more than he should.
    Certainly more than I do.

    I think...
    Yeah

    vote: shadow
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    "Magical merchant" doesn't sound like a 1 shot doc, so im hopeful that lynch was good. But my role name doesn't particularly sound like what I am either...

    Still just think she was strongly scum by meta though.

    As the sun dawned on the second day of the journey the iceberg seemed a bit closer. The gills more pronounced. The gulls more fervent.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.