2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on Slivers soon?
    Quote from PorcelainGod
    We as humans are regarded as the most evolved form of life on Earth and there are hundreds if not over a thousand abilities in nature that we don't have.
    Here's a new sliver for you.
    Mean Sliver 2R
    All Slivers have Intimidate.
    2/2

    Now What happens if I play him with Ghostflame Sliver.

    If you give all slivers Annihilator 1 then there is no reason NOT to attack with them because you have just turned every one of them into repeatable Vindicates. The cheapest form on Annihilate in ROE is on Umalog's Crusher at 8 if you give that to slivers then you are getting Annihilators for 1.

    There are some abilities that should just never show up on slivers.


    Even if Slivers did eventually get intimidate, indestructible and annihilator 1, that still probably wouldn't be put them over the top as the best deck in extended. What happened to "dies from removal" argument here?
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on Slivers soon?
    Quote from PorcelainGod
    One BIG problem with your approach. Slivers are a theme, you can't have a set with 5 slivers without some time of other support.
    Time Spiral had 28 (2 purple rare), Planar Chaos 11, Future Site 6
    By the time we saw the 6 in Future Site there were 39 already in standard.

    The only way Core Set slivers are ever going to work is if they print around 20 of them in the Core Set. Or they print 5-10 in the Core Set and then give more in the following block.


    Well, I'm of the opinion 12-15 Slivers (which would include a brand new Sliver legend) would be sufficient size for a core set hive, which is almost the size of the Tempest hive, and that many new Slivers is possible with the examples I gave.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on No Eldrazi in white or blue?
    Thematically, those probably were the colors that rallied and organized the rest of the 5 colors to rise up and fight the Eldrazi, the last two colors that didn't fall under their influence.
    Posted in: New Card Discussion
  • posted a message on Slivers soon?
    Quote from Morphling
    I cannot believe that people seriously want to see more Slivers after Future Sight.

    They're just so obnoxious.

    No moar, pleez. Frown


    :thumbsdown::thumbsdown::thumbsdown::thumbsdown::thumbsdown:


    I've said it a couple times on here, I'll say it again, I'd be completely for seeing brand new Slivers in the basic core set with whatever evergreen keywords that we haven't seen yet. With abilities such as all 6 landwalk abilities, indestructible, lifelink, deathtouch and the 5-6 "Protection from..." possibilities. That should sate people's desire to see them for a bit.

    Beyond that, maybe it is a good idea that WoTC wait a bit longer after SoM to utilizing Slivers.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on Eldrazi after ROE
    My best guess is we'll eventually see a couple more Eldrazi in some distant future Time Spiral-esque block, or in a return to this plane, as both creatures and/or a planeswalker.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on Thoughts on ROE overall.
    Quote from onlainari
    I love you. I cry for the way life has treated you.

    Click for harmony


    This, cracked me up. Well played sir.
    Posted in: New Card Discussion
  • posted a message on The last Mythic?
    ^^
    We are getting a printed legendary token, I was assuming WoTC counted it as among the 7 listed from the Orb.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on The last Mythic?
    At this point, the only thing left to be spoiled that has me at the edge of my seat, waiting patiently for, is the last nonbasic land. Everything else is just gravy.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on The last Mythic?
    And all the legendary permanents.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on Time for a new Mox?
    I don't think a plain and simple Mox that read:

    0
    T: Add one colorless mana to your mana pool.

    would be outrageous. That would pretty much tie up the Moxes in my mind.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on [ROE] Lay Bare, Coralhelm Commander, U draw 3
    Quote from Shaharazad
    @Dude recall.

    This card is a contradiction.

    On the surface, it needs to be in a deck that cares about creatures and it happens to be in the color that cares the least about creatures.

    The fact that the card is a sorcery totally ruins any potential it may have. Since it needs to be in a deck that cares about creatures, it means that you want to be using those creatures. If it was an instant, theoretically you could cast it at the end of your opponents turn and tap your creatures then.

    I suppose this goes into the epic Savor the moment / vigilance deck that is tearing up tournies. Muh


    Or it'll be used in decks that care about having creatures on the board, with blue as a third support color, mono blue or split-blue be damned.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [ROE] Lay Bare, Coralhelm Commander, U draw 3
    I'm of the mind that the "Dude Recall" will see tons of play in an Eldrazi deck, if its mana base can be stretched just to add a few Deprives and the Recalls.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Will they make Slivers?
    Quote from Luminis

    Furthermore, in terms of design, there isn't much difference between a Sliver that grants protection from, say, black and a Sliver that grants protection from colorles stuff.

    Yeah there is, something like that would give slivers protection from lands, artifacts and colorless creatures and spells that WoTC is starting to push.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on Will they make Slivers?
    Quote from Nyx
    Toxin Sliver and Essence Sliver were deathtouch(sorta) and lifelink respectively before they reworked the how those abilities worked post-M10. You youngin's may not remember that.

    Check my thoughts after that.


    Ghostflame Sliver gives colorless.
    Ward Sliver gives protection.

    I meant "Protection from colorless sources [however WoTC wants to word it]..."
    Most casual players don't play with five Ward Slivers, and obviously you could've only given your guys protection from four colors, and colorless wasn't an option.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on Will they make Slivers?
    Quote from Luminis


    Actually, in such a case an errata and a reprint might be a better solution. While there's technically no Sliver that grants Lifelink or Deathtouch, from a design perspective, there'd be absolutely no difference.


    And they did, for a while. But for whatever reasons, WoTC made the decision to change from the errata given to these older cards back to how they were originally worded.

    The only card given these errata changes that still have them is Loxodon Warhammer.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.