2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on Cuisines of the Multiverse - An Official Magic: The Gathering Cookbook
    Quote from Simto »
    Quote from foam_dome »
    Quote from Simto »
    You have got to be ******* kidding me


    Lmfao why are you acting like this is disappointing or in any way surprising? They have cookbooks for IPs like Halo, Skyrim, and Minecraft, what's got your knickers in a bunch about an MTG cookbook?

    It's just as completely idiotic as the rest of them


    Aight, stay mad then
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Cuisines of the Multiverse - An Official Magic: The Gathering Cookbook
    Quote from Simto »
    You have got to be ******* kidding me


    Lmfao why are you acting like this is disappointing or in any way surprising? They have cookbooks for IPs like Halo, Skyrim, and Minecraft, what's got your knickers in a bunch about an MTG cookbook?
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [WHO] Martha Jones, Dinosaurs on a Spaceship, and more — Princess Weekes previews
    Ayo, Flesh Duplicate seems like a fun Rebel to tutor up!

    Quote from Ryperior74 »
    Wait… I’m so confused to why they created “Dinosaurs on a spaceship” as a forever staple in Gishath, Sun's Avatar


    What are you confused about?
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [SLD] Li’l’est Walkers
    Of all the 6 mana Chandras to go with, they picked this one? If that Chandra had been Chandra, Hope's Beacon, Chandra, Flamecaller, or even Chandra Ablaze, this drop would have been quite a bit more appealing. As is though, it's still not too bad.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [SLD] Nerf LMTD Lightning Lair
    This was shown off at Magic Con Vegas. I kinda expected it to be more than just $40 tbh
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [LCI] [SPG] [RVR] The Preview Panel at MagicCon: Las Vegas
    Quote from foam_dome »
    Nope, they said in the panel that the set isn't tribe-focused this time around, which means we can assume that the Limited archetypes aren't either.

    What confuses me is that they say they aren't focusing as much on tribes this time...and then debut four precons based around tribal archetypes. Oh, and 2 of the 5 new cards they previewed also support those archetypes.

    I know there's plenty more cards in the set, but this is some pretty mixed messaging.


    Iirc, they said that the EDH precons will have more tribal themes, but the main set itself will not.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [LCI] [SPG] [RVR] The Preview Panel at MagicCon: Las Vegas
    Quote from Flisch »
    I assume there will be four draft archetypes, one for each tribe and that's it.


    Nope, they said in the panel that the set isn't tribe-focused this time around, which means we can assume that the Limited archetypes aren't either.

    Quote from Ryperior74 »
    ghalta 2.0 (without the vampire): Ah man I would love to have this be I know dang well this will kidney priced because we know dang well it’s gonna be 100% (tested/be) in Through the Breach/Goryo's Vengeance decks in modern and sneak attack/show and tell/reanimate decks in legacy, the same decks with Griselbrand and Emrakul, the Aeons Torn


    You know, I said something similar to my friend when we were sitting in the audience at the preview panel... He replied "Why? You don't need Ghalta"

    And you know what? I think he's right. If you're cheating in a Griselbrand or Emrakul, you're already winning the game. Cheating in something that can put them into play is just win-more.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [SLD] Secret Lair Artist Series John Avon
    Quote from Ryperior74 »
    You know emrakul 2.0 absolutely warped modern and standard formats when she came out heck i definitely hear she’s defintely still being used in modern the 4-color elemental deck in modern for one example. and also got the ban hammer for standard. that’s why one reason still exsepneive (besides no reprints) the other of why she’s almost $100 price tag because they shockingly did not reprint emrakul 2.0 commander master nor the colorless precon while Ulamog and kozilek 2.0 were.

    ps progentius technically escaped the binder status for people who bought the painbow precon (like I said above) in dominaria United it’s defintely a upgrade for that deck.


    I mean, Emrakul hasn't ever seen ubiquitous play in Modern. I think it briefly saw play in Tron, until people realized that Ulamog, the Ceaseless Hunger was often just a better card to go for. It does see play as a 1-of in 4c Control sideboards, but there's no way anyone would consider that "absolutely warping Modern."
    It definitely tore up Standard, but that doesn't have anything to do with its price. It's only maintained a high price because 1. it hadn't been reprinted since 2016, and 2. other cards were printed to increase demand for it.
    I'm still excited for this reprinting, though, because Emrakul, the Promised End is one of my all time favorite cards and the price has needed to come down for a while.

    As for Progenitus, a few people who bought the Painbow precon and upgraded it with a copy of Progenitus haven't done anything to change its status as a binder filler. These things were handed out like candy at GPs, to the point where it was easy to find copies of them lying around at tournament tables because players who didn't want them had left them behind. Every single GP main event and side event entry in 2017 came with one of these, so it wasn't difficult to just incidentally have a playset of them by the end of a single GP weekend. I wasn't even much of a tournament grinder, and found myself with 10 of them. I haven't encountered a single person who's been looking to trade for a copy of Progenitus since 2009.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [WOE] Regal Bunnicorn — MTG Tiktok Preview
    MTGSal being almost a day behind as usual

    Seems kinda boring. Not sure how good it'll be, but I don't anticipate it seeing much serious play.

    It's gonna get real awkward when this thing gets blocked in combat alongside your other creatures, then dies to SBAs when the other creatures die, lol
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [WOE] Ashiok's Reaper — Kakitabletop preview
    Reminds me of my college days when my friend used Enchanted Evening and a Tranquility effect to blow up the entire board in a multiplayer game, not realizing that the multiple copies of Femeref Enchantress he had in play would force him to deck out KEKW
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [WOE] Agatha's Soul Cauldron — Gamerbraves preview
    Quote from 5ColorsEDH »
    Can't this turn all of your creatures with +1/+1 counters on them into Grists if so I think this card is bonkers.


    Can you even activate loyalty abilities if you are not a Planeswalker?


    If you couldn't, then the reminder text on Luxior, Giada's Gift sure would be awkward

    But yes, if a non-planeswalker permanent has a loyalty ability with a cost that it can pay, then it can indeed activate that ability.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [WOT] Intangible Virtue and Mana Flare — MtG Facebook Japan previews
    Will these be playable in Standard Constructed or not? I am thinking not.


    With the exception of timeshifted cards from Time Spiral, bonus sheet cards have never been Standard legal, no
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [WOE] Leakers have struck again… several cards leaked including two new mechanics
    That's irrelevant, you could run that card for over 50 years and would still be a metagame issue.


    Hey, I'm just giving you the summation of 13 years of anecdotal evidence. But I guess that's only worth anything when it's coming from you, huh?

    That's again, a metagame issues, in my metas people run Theros Gods, Avacyn, Eldrazis and Blightsteel Colossus so Oblation is a very relevant answers against those threats and giving 2 cards to an opponent it's much less impactful in a multiplayer game of 4 players compared to a 1vs1 game. Somebody playing EDH for over 13 years should realize that.


    You're right, I can only speak in the context of my metas, and in my metas the shuffle has almost never been relevant. I've just had access to better answers against indestructible threats. It's true that two random cards are less impactful than an Avacyn or Blightsteel, but if you're using Oblation against something that isn't a game-ending threat, giving an opponent more cards to work with is a much bigger downside than giving them a token and should (imo) be avoided accordingly. I've been an Oblation apologist for over a decade, but with all the good mono white removal they've been printing lately, I just don't think it's needed anymore.

    I also mentioned monowhite cards but seems you like to skip whatever thing ruin your fallacious narrative apparently. Actually I will add the the list Spirit of the Labyrinth, Mind's Eye, Omen Machine and Possessed Portal, all cards a monowhite deck can run for any type of stax strategies.


    My fallacious narrative of talking about mono white and you bringing nonwhite cards into the discussion? KEKW
    But okay sure, Oblation is better with anti-draw stax pieces (or Smothering Tithe) in play, thank you for your mind-blowing revelation

    Quote from Mystic_X »
    I personally wish they reversed that rule change. Why did they even switch that to begin with?...because a handful of players who pilot decks which depend on their commander as their only win condition complained loudly online? Perhaps I don't fully understand the logic of the decision or the philosophy of the format despite playing for so many years, but why should we always be guaranteed access to the commander which is essentially an extra card (or two in the case of partners) in hand to cast that can never be disrupted or removed for more than a turn by any means?

    I was a big fan of cards like oblation which felt balanced as is in a format with access to so many tutors banned in other formats (along with other tuck cards like chaos warp, spell crumple, hinder, etc). I feel like now the only white tuck card which might actually pressure an opponent to keep their commander in the deck as opposed to zoning might be unexpectedly absent if X is lower than the cost of the command tax. Alas, does anyone even still play that?


    I fully agree, I loved the old tuck rule. If someone is going to build a deck that fully relies on its commander to win games, then the trade-off should be that they get punished when an opponent finds a creative way to get rid of it.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [WOE] Leakers have struck again… several cards leaked including two new mechanics
    Ayoooo it's always nice to see more good removal for mono white in EDH! Oblation is so obsolete now that it hurts


    Oblation is still more than decent, get rid of indestructible and if you target a permanent they stealed you, you are the one drawing 2 cards and possibily even draw again the stealed permanent. Not to mention the sweet interaction with stuff like Smothering Tithe, Orcish Bowmasters, Consecrated Sphinx or Notion Thief. Oblation definitely still has his uses in the right build.


    You... you do realize you're preaching Oblation to a guy who's been running it in mono white EDH for the past 13 years, right?

    The fringe utility of Oblation's shuffle vs Stroke of Midnight's destroy generally isn't good enough to make up for the fact that giving someone two cards is way, WAY more impactful than giving them a 1/1 token. Oblation dropped off hard when the commander tuck rule was changed, and now we have even more options available (like Excise the Imperfect).

    Also, why are you even mentioning cards like Consecrated Sphinx or Notion Thief when the discussion is about Stroke of Midnight in the context of mono white? Lol
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [WOE] Leakers have struck again… several cards leaked including two new mechanics
    Ayoooo it's always nice to see more good removal for mono white in EDH! Oblation is so obsolete now that it hurts.

    Spellbook Vendor and Mosswood Dreadknight might do cute things in Standard and cubes with lower power levels, but that might be it.

    A lot of these rare adventure cards have pretty decent rates, but I still don't really foresee them doing a whole lot.

    These manlands do look heaps better than the BFZ ones, though!

    Quote from Ryperior74 »
    Gaping holy crap Imodane is gonna be nuts in commander

    infact why don’t I leave these here



    I think your evaluation skills need work. No one plays most of these spells in EDH in the first place because they're almost all terrible, and letting them dome your opponents still doesn't make them good enough to justify running imo.
    It's also worth noting that Imodane doesn't work with Volcanic Salvo or Meteor Swarm unless they only damage a single creature, in which case you're sacrificing their utility just to make them work with her.

    And I don't foresee Food Fight being "nuts in Commander" either, considering that 1. it costs 2 mana to sac each artifact, and 2. you're talking about jumping through tons of hoops just to make each artifact deal enough damage for Food Fight to be worth it in the first place.

    Step 1: Have Food Fight
    Step 2: Play multiple spells that can make copies of Food Fight
    Step 3: Make a ton of artifacts to sac to Food Fight
    Step 4: Find a way to generate tons of mana to sac your artifacts to Food Fight
    Step 5: ?????
    Step 6: Profit, I guess??

    Quote from Ryperior74 »
    And you know what bargain can do “Tokens” so Fable of the Mirror-Breaker might be in trouble in formats


    Buddy, if you think Fable might get banned in older formats because it makes tokens to be sacced to a kicker mechanic, then we might need to sit you down for a talk... KEKW
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.