2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on [MKM] Krenko's Buzzcrusher — Goblin Lore Podcast preview
    Quote from Ryperior74 »
    There’s actually the most important part you guys are missing.

    where’s the word “target”?… TAKE THAT! Lotus Field!!!


    The funny thing is that Mark Rosewater said that the reason why this doesn't target is specifically because of Lotus Field, lol
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [MKM] Frantic Scapegoat — StalwartUrsa preview
    Okay I was out of my gourd yesterday and for some reason thought that suspected also came with +1/+1 because I was thinking of unleash lmao

    Definitely not good enough for Pioneer or Modern, but still decent in Standard
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [MKM] Frantic Scapegoat — StalwartUrsa preview
    This thing seems pretty good for Standard mono red aggro, possibly good enough for Pioneer or Modern too?
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [MKM] Case of the Gateway Express — The Commander Tavern preview
    TIL that Ravnica has a subway system
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [MKM] Push // Pull and FesterLeech — Mostly Casual Commander preview
    I'm still waiting for the Lock // Load split card
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [MKM] Sample Collector — @defiantcathar preview
    Not to be confused with a Collector Sample, which is found in every EDH precon Teach
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [MKM] Three Disguise Commons — Card Kingdom previews
    Now that's what I call an investi-gator
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Heroes of the realm cards of 2022
    This is the problem I have with Heroes of the Realm cards because all it does is divide the Magic community further through class warfare not in terms of how it's defined in Dungeons & Dragons but through a real life economical class system between the poor, middle class, and rich in Commander. Oh you're a peasant that doesn't own a real copy of Elusen, the Giving? Go run Karona, False God or Phelddagrif. It's actually kind of insulting to those who want to play these Heroes of the Realm cards in Commander but can't due to circumstances beyond their control unless they decide to proxy them. It also doesn't help that the print run of these cards are extremely low.

    It's already scummy enough that they print and design mechanically unique Commanders as Secret Lair Drops but it's even worse when Wizards of the Coast / Hasbro prints and designs cards solely to keep for themselves instead of sharing them with the rest of the Magic community all while expecting us to pay double or triple the price on their Paper Magic products with lower quality and bad card design. No wonder why Reserve List prices are tanking right now because everyone is liquidating their collections just to get through this terrible economy right now. It's hard for me to be optimistic about Paper Magic when Wizards of the Coast / Hasbro continues to screw themselves over time and time again.


    Hahahaha good one!

    This IS a troll post, right?
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Heroes of the realm cards of 2022
    Me: *sees RGWU in Elusen's casting cost and expects Ryperior to throw a fit about it*
    Ryperior: *complains about it not being black for some reason*

    Lol welp glad to see I wasn't disappointed

    So you wanted the card that was designed around charitable contributions to include black? When RGWU is canonically confirmed to be the color combination of altruism??
    These cards weren't designed to be playable cards for the community. They're not just going to make it black for no reason.

    Heroes of Kamigawa is the second HTR card we've seen that refers to a booster pile. Seems like a neat design space, maybe we'll eventually see it in a future Conspiracy product?

    The thing I like about Elusen is that she turns donating permanents into a keyword, which is something that could feasibly happen in black border Magic.

    Svega is a perfect design for a convention-themed planeswalker, and I love how her -X reflects the five cosplay mainstays at the Magic Cons (Taalia Vess as Elspeth, TeferiMagic as Teferi, Olivia Gobert-Hicks as Liliana/Onyx, TappyToeClaws as Chandra, and TanakhT as Garruk).

    Wizard From Beyond is a super neat card, albeit kinda boring.

    I wonder what the first HTR card for this year is.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [RVR] Shuffle Up & Play: Ravnica Remastered Challenge — Tolarian Community College previews
    Quote from Flisch »
    We're getting anime cards again? What does Ravnica have to do with anime?


    What did Wilds of Eldraine have to do with anime?
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on 14th doctor + minor spoilers to the specials
    Quote from Melkor »
    As Ryperior pointed out, there are other 4 color combinations it could have been with a companion that gives the 5th. actually I think the case for Rose being Green is at least as strong as for her being Blue, so a WUBR Doctor, which by the end of 10's run, there was definitely Black in the character.


    The thing is that it logically makes very little sense to make The Fourteenth Doctor anything other than RGWU, since the first thirteen Doctors are all in those colors. Yeah sure, players could add a doctor's companion to fill in the missing color if he was different colors, but why should their companion options be restricted in order to incorporate all the Doctors into their deck? This color combination allows players to play The Fourteenth Doctor with basically any companion while still getting to play all the cards in the precons with Doctor synergies, and also retaining their ability to add black through Clara Oswald or Vislor Turlough if they wish.

    But instead, you want to sacrifice that convenience and accessibility and have him be different colors because... we don't have enough commanders in the other 4-color combinations? I guarantee you that players would have been way more upset if The Fourteenth Doctor couldn't naturally include all the other Doctors without being shoehorned into playing a companion to unlock a huge chunk of the WHO cards.
    "But Foam-Dome," you may be thinking, "aren't they shoehorning us into using one of only two companions in order to play 5 color?"
    Yes, they are. But playing black in a Fourteenth Doctor deck is an option that is entirely unnecessary. Many players who want to build Fourteenth Doctor are going to want to include the previous thirteen, and black is the only color that they don't NEED in order to do that. On the other hand, having black is a largely useless color for the purpose of playing all the Doctors, so I imagine it would mostly lead to player frustration.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on 14th doctor + minor spoilers to the specials
    Quote from Ryperior74 »
    STOP MAKING INK-TRENDER COMMANDERS! RGWU for definition. we already got omnath, locus of creation, Aragorn, the uniter, and Kynaios and Tiro of Meletis, now we do need 4 color legends made but we need love for the other 4-color combos besides RGWU, which is yore-tiller WUBR, glint-eye UBRG, dune-brood BRGW, and witch-maw GWUB (we do have 2 witch-maw legends but it’s the same character with different abilties)


    What, so because WotC has already made more RGWU legends, you think they shouldn't print a Doctor Who card that lets us play with all the Doctors in the same deck? That's a silly thing to say.
    "Hey Wizards, you shouldn't be doing more of X unless you've done more of Y!"
    They've made it quite well known that 4-color cards are very challenging to design from both a mechanical and flavor standpoint, so you should be grateful that you're getting more of them at all.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [PIP] The First Look at Universes Beyond: Fallout
    Quote from foam_dome »
    I guess Tetzin, Gnome Champion isn't proper enough?

    Tetzin wasn't spoiled when this came out, and i can't pull a Eren Yeager and tell my past self to just wait a couple of weeks for a "proper" jeskai commander.

    Btw Tetzin looked extremely underwhelming, but after some deckbuilding and tests, it's fun. The jeskai artifact package is really really powerful. I also think that the doctor will be very strong.


    I'm aware. My point was more that you risk looking kinda silly by complaining about the "first" proper Jeskai artifact commander in PIP when there were at least two unspoiled sets slated to come out before it.

    I do agree though, Tetzin has been pretty sweet so far.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [PIP] The First Look at Universes Beyond: Fallout
    Quote from Simto »
    Finally get an energy commander and it's in the ******* Fallout set... and not temur...


    Lol i thought the same.
    This is also the first proper jeskai artifact commander and it's a ******* UB


    I guess Tetzin, Gnome Champion isn't proper enough?
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [SLD] Secretversary 2023 Superdrop
    Yeah, I can't say I'm interested in any of these at all. The snow lands look nice, but they've come out with a lot of nice-looking basics, so they're nothing special anymore.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.