2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on [ALA] Cross-Referenced Orb Results 09/18 update READY (Logs in posts 45 and 80)
    Are basic lands counted in the orb? If so, these two cycles of lands are impossible. There are 25 instances of "Land" in the orb. 20 of them are used by the basics. The same is true for the word "Basic". That means we could only have 1 land cycle, and that assumes that there is no land fetch.

    Am I missing something?

    athelred
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [TS] auction containing several cards (New Scans post 578)
    Quote from Shaharazad
    Guys, I know we are all excited, and this is the first time we have had a stifled rumor season, but please listen to me.

    Take some time and look carefully at shadowmage infiltrator. It has a gold rarity symbol. It can't be in the set.

    I want it to be! I love the freaking card, but it really doesn't have a purple symbol. It should be in the orb of insight but it isn't


    It is hard to tell from the small image, but if you zoom in on the card in paint or another image util, the rarity symbol looks clearly different from the one on the magus. It looks very similar to the ones on the rest of the card. I think that it's goldish appearence is duie to the gold border of the card interfering.

    EDIT: 'nathed by charlequin
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Snow mana and triggered mana abilities
    Quote from MTGPhreak »

    1. I have Heartbeat of Spring in play and tap a Snow-Covered Forest, should I get two green snow mana?

    No, you end up with one green mana from a snow permanent and one green mana from the heartbeat, which is not a snow permanent;

    Quote from MTGPhreak »

    2. I have Heartbeat of Spring in play and make it a snow permanent. I tap a forest for mana. Do I get any snow mana?

    Yes, the mana from the heartbeat's triggered ability is from a snow permanent. It can therefore be used to pay a snow cost.

    Quote from MTGPhreak »

    3. I have a Snow-Covered Forest in play enchanted with Wild Growth. Should I get two green snow mana?

    No, you end up with one green mana from a snow permanent and one green mana from the wild growth, which is not a snow permanent;

    Quote from MTGPhreak »

    4. I have a Forest in play enchanted with a Wild Growth that has been turned into a snow permanent. Should I get any snow mana?

    Yes, the mana from the Wild Growth's triggered ability is from a snow permanent. It can therefore be used to pay a snow cost.


    I think our confusion here is about "snow mana". I hate to even use that term as there is no such thing. There are six types of mana in Magic: red, green, blue, black, white, and colorless. Any mana produced by a permanent with the snow supertype can be used to pay a cost of S. In the above cases there are two different permanents producing mana. The lands produce mana from their activated ability, while the enchantments (and they both basically work the same, only the scope of the effect differs) produce mana from a triggered ability. The mana produced from each will be able to be used to pay a "snow mana" cost if and only if that particular permanent is snow.

    Make sense?

    athelred
    Level 2 Judge
    Posted in: Magic Rulings Archives
  • posted a message on Rav Sealed — How many colors?
    I expect Rav sealed and draft will both tend towards 3 colors. In sealed expect at least 60% of the decks to feature black (as it is by far the strongest color at common), and 60% to feature green (there will be overlap there obviously).

    Try to break up your colors into pairs instead of sinlge colors. So you might have 4 base stacks of the color combinations GW, RW, GB, and UB, and in between them the mono color cards that two stacks of multi color cards share (so your black cards will be in between the GB and UB stacks for example). This will help you to spot which color combinations are best together.

    The common lands and signets will be critical in both sealed and draft. They will be excellent mana fixers. It may be worth playing off color signets just for the accel, especially if it shares at least one color with your deck, as I expect that sealed will be a bit slow.

    Dredge can be good, but watch out for it. Cards with a high dredge number will be difficult to dredge back often. Remember that we only play 40 ish cards, and this makes something with dredge 4+ hard to abuse. The Grave Shell Scarab on the other hand is just stupid in limited, and should be played if availiable, as it will win games almost solo.

    When you are drafting keep in mind the following ideas:

    1. Think in color pairs, not mono colors. So when you get signaled early think about what pairs of colors you are getting signaled. Also keep in mind what the cards you pass will signal to the people down stream.

    2. When choosing the color pairs to draft, try to choose two color pairs that share a color in common (like GW and RW). Do not bet on being able to play a deck based on two colors.

    3. Guild mana cards are effectively mono color. They just get better with two colors. If you are in GW/RW don't be affraid to take GB guild mana cards.

    4. Black is by far the deepest mono color, which is good, as I expect 4-5 people at each table will be drafting black (in other words expect black to be overdrafted)

    5. Blue is the red headed step child of this set. Something like half the cards are unplayable in limited. This means it may be severly underdrafted, and you may be able to get good picks late.

    6. Red May also be underdrafted as it is only in one guild, and willl only play nicely with on other guild (RW/GW). It has better cards than blue though.

    Hopefully this will help as you try to make sense of this new set. Drafting especially will be very different from previous sets, and will require some rearrangement of thought patterns.

    athelred

    P.S. I think most of the above is good advice. I might be blowing it out of my posterior however. Use at your own risk.
    Posted in: Limited Archives
  • posted a message on [RAV] the rest of it (update post 104)
    Everything that can be said about most of these cards has been said.

    Except this one:

    Life from the Loam - :1mana::symg:
    Sorcery (R)
    Return up to three target land cards from your graveyard to your hand.
    Dredge 4

    You do realize that this almost single handedly re-enables the urzatron right? I figure that in three or four turns of drawing all the lands in the top 4 cards* of your library that you will have pretty much completed the set. Not to mention putting many juicy targets for dredge or reanimation into your graveyard.

    athelred

    * If you wonder how this works then consider the following

    Turn 2 : Cast this with 0 targets.
    Turn 3 : Dredge it, and cast it targeting any lands that you just dredged.
    turns 4-whatever : Repeat turn three using the cards in your hand as control elements, or drawing other cards as needed. Combie with Top to carefully choose if you need any of the top three cards or not. Complete the urzatron and do something unfortunate to your opponent.

    I like this card
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [Rav] Compilation of Orb Results
    Remember that r/w is only going to show costs that are exactly r/w. It will not show r/wr/w for example. So I would not worry about it being too terribly underepresented.

    Which incidentally is 1.

    athelred

    edit: All of the double guild mana costs are below

    r/wr/w = 1
    b/gb/g = 1
    g/wg/w = 1
    u/bu/b = 2
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Saturday School Question: Spliced Targets
    Nope a spell or ability is only countered upon resolution if all its targets are illegal. Since a spliced spell adds the text to the text of the original spell, the spell as it exists on the stack actually has two targets. Effectively you make an amalgum spell that look like this

    Rend flesh

    Instant -- Arcane
    Destroy target non-spirit creature.

    Deal 2 damage to target creature or player.

    This spell will only be countered upon resolution if both targets are removed.

    athelred
    Level 1 Judge
    Posted in: Magic Rulings Archives
  • posted a message on Polymorph and Serra Avatar
    Quote from Verashiden »
    It'll work like this:

    Polymorph hits the stack targetting the Angel

    Players pass

    Serra Avatar is destroyed

    Serra's ability triggers and waits for the spell to finish resolving before it hits the stack

    You reveal your library and don't find any creatures

    After Polymorph resolves Serra's ability goes on the stack

    So no, you don't get a creature.

    EDIT Tons of Fun: The destroy effect is part of the spells resolution so it doesn't happen at the same time.


    Serra Avatar's ability is not triggered. It is a replacement effect. Thus it replaces the goto the graveyard part of the destroy effect, immediatly. This occurs even during the resolution of another spell or effect. So the original poster is correct in what happens.

    Polymorph resolves. Serra Avatar is destroyed, but instead of going to the graveyard it is immediatly shuffled into the library. You then reveal cards untill you get to the serra avatar that you just shuffled in as it is your only creature. The Serra Avatar is the put back into play.

    athelred
    Level 1 Judge
    Posted in: Magic Rulings Archives
  • posted a message on [RAV] a bunch of W/G guild information
    I have looked at other cost reducers. From what I have seen it looks like unless the ability specifically says that it does not reduce the colorless cost then it does. I base this on the FAQ for Edgewalker (note that edgewalker specifically says that it does not reduce colorless costs).


    From the Official Scourge FAQ:


    Edgewalker
    Edgewalker's ability reduces what you pay only if the total cost of the Cleric spell includes B and/or W. Unlike previous cost reducers, it doesn't affect the generic mana portion of costs, even if you choose to pay that portion with white and/or black mana.

    If the cost to play a Cleric spell includes either B or W, you don't pay that part. If a cost includes B and W, you don't pay either of them.

    Multiple Edgewalkers are cumulative. If you control two of them, they reduce the amount you pay for Cleric spells by BB and WW.


    This definately implies that colored cost reducers can reduce the colorless cost of spells.

    I cannot find anything in the comprehensive rules that specifically denotes this, nor cannot I find anything that says the opposite. However, the FAQ is reasonably clear on this. Thus assuming that there is not a clause in the spell that prevents it, you should be able to reduce the cost by however many creatures you control of that color.

    athelred
    Level 1 Judge

    VestDan : The difference is that Edgewalker *specifically* says that you cannot use it to reduce colorless costs. Unless this says otherwise you can.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [9th] FAQ
    The ninth edition faq has been posted to the judges list. There is not a huge amount of new info, although a few interesting things (most of which we already knew about) are presented. Enjoy.


    _Ninth Edition_ Frequently Asked Questions

    Compiled by John Carter

    Document last modified June 30, 2005

    _Ninth Edition_ official release date: July 29, 2005

    The _Ninth Edition_ core set becomes legal for sanctioned Constructed

    play August 20, 2005.

    Set size: 350 cards (110 common, 110 uncommon, 110 rare, 20 basic land)
    This FAQ has three sections, each of which serves a different purpose.
    The first section ("_Ninth Edition_ Rules Changes") explains the rules
    that have changed with this core set. The second section ("General
    Notes") explains new concepts in the set. The third section
    ("Card-Specific Notes") contains answers to the most important
    questions players might ask about a given card.

    Items in the "Card-Specific Notes" section include full rules text for
    your reference. Not all cards in the set are listed.

    ----------

    _NINTH EDITION_ RULES CHANGES

    There have been some minor rules changes to better support cards in the
    _Ninth Edition_ core set and future sets. The most important changes
    are listed here. The most recent version of the _Magic: The
    Gathering_(R) Comprehensive Rules (in English) can be downloaded at
    www.wizards.com/default.asp?x=magic/rules/tourneyplayer.

    Local Enchantments Are Now Auras

    The _Ninth Edition_ core set introduces Auras, a new name for a kind of
    card that's been around since the beginning of the _Magic_(R) game. An
    Aura is just a type of enchantment that's attached to another permanent
    in play. Most experienced players won't notice any difference in how
    these "local enchantment" cards work; "enchant creature," "enchant
    land," and the like just move off the type line and into the text box.

    Spirit Link
    {W}
    Enchantment -- Aura

    Enchant creature (Target a creature as you play this. This card comes
    into play attached to that creature.)
    Whenever enchanted creature deals damage, you gain that much life.

    Why the change? The old format of local enchantments had proven
    confusing for a couple of reasons. First, they had words like
    "creature" and "land" on their type lines, even though they didn't have
    those types. Second, they were the only kind of spell that targets
    something without ever using the word "target." The Ninth Edition rules
    change clears up all that. The type line now says "Enchantment --
    Aura," and a keyword (such as "enchant creature") in the text box says
    what the Aura can enchant. And the keyword has reminder text to show
    new players that Auras are targeted spells (don't worry -- you won't
    see that reminder text in expert-level sets).

    Local enchantment cards printed in previous sets will receive new
    wordings in the _Oracle_(TM) card reference. Check
    http://gatherer.wizards.com for the current Oracle wording of any card.
    The following is an excerpt from the revised Comprehensive Rules:

    212.4c Enchantment subtypes are always a single word and are listed
    after a long dash: "Enchantment -- Aura." Each word after the dash is a
    separate subtype. Enchantment subtypes are also called enchantment
    types. Enchantments may have multiple subtypes.

    212.4d Some enchantments have the subtype "Aura." An Aura comes into
    play attached to a permanent or player. What an Aura can be attached to
    is restricted by its enchant keyword ability (see rule 502.45,
    "Enchant").

    212.4e An Aura spell requires a target, which is restricted by its
    enchant ability. Other restrictions can limit what a permanent can be
    enchanted by. If an Aura is coming into play by any other means than
    being played and the effect putting it into play doesn't specify what
    it will enchant, the player putting it into play chooses a permanent
    for it to enchant as it comes into play. The player must choose a legal
    permanent according to the Aura's enchant ability. If no legal
    permanent is available, the Aura remains in the zone from which it
    attempted to move instead of coming into play. The same rule applies to
    moving an Aura from one permanent to another: The permanent to which
    the Aura is to be moved must be able to be enchanted by it. If it isn't
    legal, the Aura doesn’t move.

    ----------

    GENERAL NOTES

    Creature Types

    The creature types of many cards in the _Ninth Edition_ core set have
    been updated to sync them up with the conventions used in the
    _Kamigawa_(TM) block and the upcoming _Ravnica: City of Guilds_(TM)
    set. Most of the changes revolved around the "race-class" model,
    wherein most sentient creatures have both a species and a job. Samite
    Healer, for example, was changed from a Cleric to a Human Cleric, and
    Raging Goblin changed from Goblin to Goblin Berserker. Every artifact
    creature that didn't have a type before was given one; Dancing Scimitar
    is now a Spirit and Ornithopter is -- what else? -- a Thopter. A lot of
    cards with old obscure types have been updated to have ones that make a
    little more sense. Clone is now a Shapeshifter, for instance, and the
    Lords such as Elvish Champion were given types to match their art (see
    the "Card-Specific Notes" for Goblin King, Elvish Champion, and Lord of
    the Undead for more information).

    A complete list of cards with creature type changes appears in this
    section. In addition, the creature type of the token created by Rukh
    Egg's ability has changed from Rukh to Bird.

    In general, the creature types of older cards are updated only as
    they're reprinted.

    Note that the following creature types have been eliminated: Behemoth,
    Clone, Force, Hell's-Caretaker, Monkey, Nekrataal, Rukh, and
    Will-o'-the-Wisp.

    Card Name Creature Types

    Anaba Shaman Minotaur Shaman
    Anarchist Human Wizard
    Archivist Human Wizard
    Balduvian Barbarians Human Barbarian
    Ballista Squad Human Rebel
    Beast of Burden Golem
    Blessed Orator Human Cleric
    Clone Shapeshifter
    Crafty Pathmage Human Wizard
    Crossbow Infantry Human Soldier
    Dancing Scimitar Spirit
    Daring Apprentice Human Wizard
    Elvish Bard Elf Shaman
    Elvish Berserker Elf Berserker
    Elvish Champion Elf Lord
    Elvish Piper Elf Shaman
    Elvish Warrior Elf Warrior
    Foot Soldiers Human Soldier
    Force of Nature Elemental
    Fugitive Wizard Human Wizard
    Glory Seeker Human Soldier
    Goblin Balloon Brigade Goblin Warrior
    Goblin Brigand Goblin Warrior
    Goblin Chariot Goblin Warrior
    Goblin King Goblin Lord
    Goblin Mountaineer Goblin Scout
    Goblin Piker Goblin Warrior
    Goblin Sky Raider Goblin Warrior
    Groundskeeper Human Druid
    Hell's Caretaker Horror
    Highway Robber Human Mercenary
    Honor Guard Human Soldier
    Infantry Veteran Human Soldier
    King Cheetah Cat
    Ley Druid Human Druid
    Llanowar Behemoth Elemental
    Llanowar Elves Elf Druid
    Lord of the Undead Zombie Lord
    Master Decoy Human Soldier
    Master Healer Human Cleric
    Mogg Sentry Goblin Warrior
    Nekrataal Human Assassin
    Norwood Ranger Elf Scout
    Oracle's Attendants Human Soldier
    Orcish Artillery Orc Warrior
    Ornithopter Thopter
    Paladin en-Vec Human Knight
    Phyrexian Hulk Golem
    Puppeteer Human Wizard
    Raging Goblin Goblin Berserker
    Royal Assassin Human Assassin
    Samite Healer Human Cleric
    Sanctum Guardian Human Cleric
    Sandstone Warrior Human Soldier
    Savannah Lions Cat
    Seasoned Marshal Human Soldier
    Serpent Warrior Snake Warrior
    Soul Warden Human Cleric
    Spineless Thug Zombie Mercenary
    Temporal Adept Human Wizard
    Tidal Kraken Kraken
    Tree Monkey Ape
    Venerable Monk Human Monk Cleric
    Verduran Enchantress Human Druid
    Veteran Cavalier Human Knight
    Viashino Sandstalker Viashino Warrior
    Weathered Wayfarer Human Nomad Cleric
    Whip Sergeant Human Soldier
    Will-o'-the-Wisp Spirit
    Wood Elves Elf Scout
    Yavimaya Enchantress Human Druid
    Zealous Inquisitor Human Cleric
    Zodiac Monkey Ape

    -----

    S-Series Cards

    The English and Japanese core games (the two-player game box designed
    for new _Magic_ players) contain nine cards that don't appear in _Ninth
    Edition_ booster packs. These cards have collector numbers that start
    with S, and they use the _Ninth Edition_ expansion symbol. All of these
    cards are part of the _Ninth Edition_ core set and are legal for play
    in all tournaments in which the _Ninth Edition_ core set is legal.

    S1 Eager Cadet (with new creature types: Human Soldier)
    S2 Vengeance
    S3 Coral Eel
    S4 Giant Octopus
    S5 Index
    S7 Vizzerdrix
    S8 Goblin Raider (with new creature types: Goblin Warrior)
    S9 Enormous Baloth
    S10 Spined Wurm

    Note that there isn't a card numbered S6/10.

    Because other languages use a different version of the two-player game,
    Eager Cadet and Goblin Raider are the only S-series cards printed in a
    language other than English or Japanese. However, older versions of all
    nine cards are legal for tournament play in all tournaments in which
    the _Ninth Edition_ core set is legal.

    ----------

    CARD-SPECIFIC NOTES

    Biorhythm
    {6}{G}{G}
    Sorcery

    Each player's life total becomes the number of creatures he or she
    controls.

    * If a player controls no creatures when Biorhythm resolves, that
    player's life total becomes 0, and he or she will lose the game.

    * If a player's life total will go down, that player "loses" that much
    life. If a player's life total will go up, that player "gains" that
    much life.

    ----------

    Blinding Angel
    {3}{W}{W}
    Creature -- Angel
    2/4

    Flying (This creature can't be blocked except by creatures with
    flying.)

    Whenever Blinding Angel deals combat damage to a player, that player
    skips his or her next combat phase.

    * If two Blinding Angels deal combat damage to a player (or if one
    deals combat damage twice), that player skips his or her next two
    combat phases.

    ----------

    Blinking Spirit
    {3}{W}
    Creature -- Spirit
    2/2

    {0}: Return Blinking Spirit to its owner's hand.

    * You can play the ability repeatedly, even during the turn Blinking
    Spirit comes into play.

    * The owner of a card is the person who started the game with it in his
    or her deck.

    ----------

    Booby Trap
    {6}
    Artifact

    As Booby Trap comes into play, name a card other than a basic land card
    and choose an opponent.

    The chosen player reveals each card he or she draws.
    When the chosen player draws the named card, sacrifice Booby Trap. If
    you do, Booby Trap deals 10 damage to that player.

    *The choice of which card to name can't be countered.

    * The card isn't chosen until Booby Trap is coming into play, at which
    time Booby Trap is no longer a spell and can't be countered.

    * If an effect causes the player to draw multiple cards, each card is
    revealed as it's drawn. If Booby Trap's ability triggers, it will go on
    the stack once the card-drawing effect has concluded.

    * If a single Booby Trap's ability triggers multiple times, then only
    the first ability to resolve causes Booby Trap to be sacrificed and
    damage to be dealt.

    * If Booby Trap's last ability is countered, Booby Trap remains in play
    (and no damage is dealt).

    ----------

    Clone
    {3}{U}
    Creature -- Shapeshifter
    0/0

    As Clone comes into play, you may choose a creature in play. If you do,
    Clone comes into play as a copy of that creature.

    * Clone doesn't copy any effects on the creature -- you just get
    exactly what's printed on the card and nothing more. So if you copy an
    animated land, for example, you get a normal, nonanimated land.

    * Clone doesn't copy whether the original creature is tapped or
    untapped, or any Aura enchantments or counters on the creature.

    * Any comes-into-play abilities of the copied creature will trigger
    when Clone comes into play.

    * If a Clone copies another Clone, it copies whatever the first one
    copied. That is, you get what was printed on the card that the original
    Clone copied.

    * You can choose not to copy anything. In that case, Clone comes into
    play as a 0/0 creature, and is probably put into the graveyard
    immediately.

    ----------

    Coat of Arms
    {5}
    Artifact

    Each creature gets +1/+1 for each other creature in play that shares a
    creature type with it. (For example, if a Goblin Warrior, a Goblin
    Scout, and a Zombie Goblin are in play, each gets +2/+2.)

    * Sharing multiple creature types doesn’t give an additional bonus.
    Coat of Arms counts creatures, not creature types.

    ----------

    Elvish Champion
    {1}{G}{G}
    Creature -- Elf Lord
    2/2

    Other Elves get +1/+1 and have forestwalk. (They're unblockable as long
    as defending player controls a Forest.)

    * Note that Elvish Champion now has the Elf creature type and its
    ability has been reworded to affect *other* Elves. This means that if
    two Elvish Champions are in play, each gives the other a bonus.

    ----------

    Emperor Crocodile
    {3}{G}
    Creature -- Crocodile
    5/5

    When you control no other creatures, sacrifice Emperor Crocodile.

    * Once Emperor Crocodile's ability triggers, there's no way to save the
    Crocodile from being sacrificed. Gaining control of another creature
    before the ability resolves can't save the Crocodile.

    * The ability triggers if you don't control another creature, even if
    it's only for a brief moment during the resolution of another spell or
    ability.

    ----------

    Fellwar Stone
    {2}
    Artifact

    {T}: Add to your mana pool one mana of any color that a land an
    opponent controls could produce.

    * The opponent's land need not be able to produce a given color at that
    time. For example, Mirrodin's Core from the _Darksteel_(TM) set has the
    ability "{T}, Remove a charge counter from Mirrodin's Core: Add one
    mana of any color to your mana pool." If your opponent has a Mirrodin's
    Core in play, you can tap Fellwar Stone for any color of mana, even if
    Mirrodin's Core has no counters on it.

    * If your opponent's lands produce only colorless mana or produce no
    mana, you can tap Fellwar Stone, but it won't produce any mana. (This
    is a functional change from the previous Oracle wording, which allowed
    Fellwar Stone to be tapped for colorless mana.)

    ----------

    Flowstone Crusher
    {3}{R}{R}
    Creature -- Beast
    4/4

    {R}: Flowstone Crusher gets +1/-1 until end of turn.

    * Flowstone Crusher's ability can be played multiple times, but
    Flowstone Crusher is put into the graveyard after an effect resolves
    that makes its toughness 0.

    ----------

    Furnace of Rath
    {1}{R}{R}{R}
    Enchantment

    If a source would deal damage to a creature or player, it deals double
    that damage to that creature or player instead.

    * If a creature, spell, or ability will deal damage to multiple things,
    you divide up the damage before applying this effect. This means
    something can't normally end up being dealt an odd amount of damage.

    * If you have two Furnaces in play, the damage is multiplied by four.
    If you have three in play, it's multiplied by eight.

    * The original source deals all the damage. Furnace of Rath doesn't
    deal any damage.

    * If multiple effects modify how damage will be dealt, the player who
    would be dealt damage or the controller of the creature that would be
    dealt damage chooses the order to apply the effects. For example,
    Mending Hands says, "Prevent the next 4 damage that would be dealt to
    target creature or player this turn." Suppose a spell would deal 5
    damage to a player who has played Mending Hands targeting himself or
    herself. That player can either (a) prevent 4 damage first and then let
    Furnace of Rath double the remaining 1 damage, taking 2 damage, or (b)
    double the damage to 10 and then prevent 4 damage, taking 6 damage.

    ----------

    Giant Spider
    {3}{G}
    Creature -- Spider
    2/4
    Giant Spider can block as though it had flying.

    * A few standard Magic card wordings had used the word "may" in
    abilities that weren't intended to ask players to make decisions. Most
    of these abilities are attacking or blocking restrictions, such as
    Giant Spider's ability. These cards have been reworded in Oracle to use
    the word "can" instead.

    * In the case of Giant Spider, the new wording results in a slight
    functional change: If an Elvish Bard ("All creatures able to block
    Elvish Bard do so") with flying attacks, Giant Spider must block it.
    (With the previous wording, Giant Spider's controller could choose that
    Giant Spider wasn't blocking as though it had flying and therefore
    can't block a flying creature.)

    * To learn more about this template change and which older cards it
    affects, check out John Carter's "Saturday School" column on
    MagicTheGathering.com on Saturday, July 30, 2005.

    -----

    Gift of Estates
    {1}{W}
    Sorcery

    If an opponent has more lands than you, search your library for up to
    three Plains cards, reveal them, and put them into your hand. Then
    shuffle your library.

    * Gift of Estates does nothing if each of your opponents has the same
    number of lands as you or fewer.

    * You can find nonbasic lands if they have the Plains land type, such
    as the Alpha card Tundra.

    ----------

    Goblin King
    {1}{R}{R}
    Creature -- Goblin Lord
    2/2

    Other Goblins get +1/+1 and have mountainwalk. (They're unblockable as
    long as defending player controls a mountain.)

    * Note that Goblin King now has the Goblin creature type and its
    ability has been reworded to affect *other* Goblins. This means that if
    two Goblin Kings are in play, each gives the other a bonus.

    ----------

    Greater Good
    {2}{G}{G}
    Enchantment

    Sacrifice a creature: Draw cards equal to the sacrificed creature's
    power, then discard three cards.

    * You draw cards equal to the creature's power when you sacrificed it.
    This includes any bonuses from effects like Giant Growth.

    * You must discard three cards regardless of how many cards you drew.
    If you have less than three cards in hand, you discard your hand.

    ----------

    Hell's Caretaker
    {3}{B}
    Creature -- Horror
    1/1

    {T}, Sacrifice a creature: Return target creature card from your
    graveyard to play. Play this ability only during your upkeep.

    * You can sacrifice Hell's Caretaker to pay for its own ability.

    * You can play the ability any time during your upkeep.

    * Note that the ability doesn't give the returned creature haste.

    ----------

    Imaginary Pet
    {1}{U}
    Creature -- Illusion
    4/4

    At the beginning of your upkeep, if you have a card in hand, return
    Imaginary Pet to its owner's hand.

    * Imaginary Pet's ability triggers only if you have cards in your hand
    as your upkeep begins, and the ability checks again as it resolves. If
    your hand is empty at both those times, Imaginary Pet stays in play.

    ----------

    Jade Statue
    {4}
    Artifact

    {2}: Jade Statue becomes a 3/6 artifact creature until end of combat.
    Play this ability only during combat.

    * You can play the ability any time during the combat phase. If you
    want to attack with Jade Statue, you need to play the ability during
    your beginning of combat step. If you want to block with it, you can
    play the ability either during the beginning of combat step or the
    declare attackers step.

    * If Jade Statue's ability has been played, abilities that trigger "at
    end of combat" will see Jade Statue as an artifact creature.

    * A delayed triggered ability that refers to Jade Statue still affects
    it even if it's no longer a creature. For example, if Jade Statue
    blocks the _Champions of Kamigawa_(TM) creature Kashi-Tribe Warrors
    ("Whenever Kashi-Tribe Warriors deals combat damage to a creature, tap
    that creature and it doesn’t untap during its controller’s next untap
    step."), the Warriors' effect stops Jade Statue from untapping.

    ----------

    Karplusan Yeti
    {3}{R}{R}
    Creature -- Yeti
    3/3

    {T}: Karplusan Yeti deals damage equal to its power to target creature.
    That creature deals damage equal to its power to Karplusan Yeti.

    * If the target creature isn't a legal target (it's no longer in play
    or has protection from red, for example) when Karplusan Yeti's ability
    resolves, the ability is countered and does nothing.

    * If Karplusan Yeti left play while its ability was on the stack, the
    effect deals damage equal to the Yeti's last known power to the target
    creature.

    ----------

    King Cheetah
    {3}{G}
    Creature -- Cat
    3/2

    You may play King Cheetah any time you could play an instant.

    * King Cheetah is never an instant spell, no matter when you play it.

    ----------

    Lord of the Undead
    {1}{B}{B}
    Creature -- Zombie Lord
    2/2

    Other Zombies get +1/+1.

    {1}{B}, {T}: Return target Zombie card from your graveyard to your
    hand.

    * Note that Lord of the Undead now has the Zombie creature type and its
    first ability has been reworded to affect *other* Zombies. This means
    that if two Lord of the Undead are in play, each gives the other a
    bonus.

    ----------

    Polymorph
    {3}{U}
    Sorcery

    Destroy target creature. It can't be regenerated. Its controller
    reveals cards from the top of his or her library until he or she
    reveals a creature card. The player puts that card into play and
    shuffles all other cards revealed this way into his or her library.

    * If the creature is an illegal target as Polymorph resolves, Polymorph
    is countered and nothing happens.

    * You can play Polymorph targeting an indestructible creature. The
    indestructible creature stays in play because it can't be destroyed,
    but its controller still gets to put another creature card into play.
    (You won't see any indestructible cards in the _Ninth Edition_ core
    set, but you will in other sets.)

    * If there are no creatures left in your library, you reveal your
    library and then shuffle it.

    ----------

    Rootwalla
    {2}{G}
    Creature -- Lizard
    2/2

    {1}{G}: Rootwalla gets +2/+2 until end of turn. Play this ability only
    once each turn.

    * If Rootwalla changes controllers after its ability has been played,
    the new controller won't be able to play the ability again until the
    next turn.

    ----------

    Sanctum Guardian
    {1}{W}{W}
    Creature -- Human Cleric
    1/4

    Sacrifice Sanctum Guardian: The next time a source of your choice would
    deal damage to target creature or player this turn, prevent that
    damage.

    * The target is chosen when you play the ability. The source of the
    damage is chosen as the ability resolves.

    ----------

    Sengir Vampire
    {3}{B}{B}
    Creature -- Vampire
    4/4

    Flying (This creature can't be blocked except by creatures with
    flying.)

    Whenever a creature dealt damage by Sengir Vampire this turn is put
    into a graveyard, put a +1/+1 counter on Sengir Vampire.

    * If Sengir Vampire and another creature deal lethal damage to each
    other in combat, both are put into graveyards before Sengir Vampire's
    triggered ability can make the Vampire bigger.

    * Note that Sengir Vampire's ability isn't restricted to combat damage.

    ----------

    Shard Phoenix
    {4}{R}
    Creature -- Phoenix
    2/2

    Flying (This creature can't be blocked except by creatures with
    flying.)

    Sacrifice Shard Phoenix: Shard Phoenix deals 2 damage to each creature
    without flying.

    {R}{R}{R}: Return Shard Phoenix from your graveyard to your hand. Play
    this ability only during your upkeep.

    * You can return Shard Phoenix any time during your upkeep by paying
    {R}{R}{R}.

    * You can sacrifice Shard Phoenix and then return it to your hand all
    during the same upkeep.

    * If, for example, Shard Phoenix was blue when it was sacrificed, the
    damage will come from a blue source.

    ----------

    Soul Warden
    {W}
    Creature -- Human Cleric
    1/1

    Whenever another creature comes into play, you gain 1 life.

    * Two Soul Wardens coming into play at the same time will each cause
    the other's ability to trigger.

    * The life gain isn't optional.

    ----------

    Storage Matrix
    {3}
    Artifact

    As long as Storage Matrix is untapped, each player chooses artifact,
    creature, or land during his or her untap step. That player can untap
    only permanents of the chosen type this step.

    * Permanents with multiple types untap if any of their types is chosen.
    For example, an artifact creature untaps if either artifact or creature
    is chosen.

    * Storage Matrix doesn't allow players to untap permanents that don't
    normally untap, such as Phyrexian Colossus.

    * If another effect limits the number of permanents that untap, that
    number combines with Storage Matrix's effect. For example, the
    Champions of Kamigawa card Imi Statue says "Players can't untap more
    than one artifact during their untap steps." If both Imi Statue and an
    untapped Storage Matrix are in play, and you choose "artifact," only
    one artifact untaps.

    ---------

    Verdant Force
    {5}{G}{G}{G}
    Creature -- Elemental
    7/7

    At the beginning of each player's upkeep, put a 1/1 green Saproling
    creature token into play under your control.

    * A Saproling creature token is created at the beginning of each
    player's upkeep, not just yours.

    * Verdant Force's controller puts the Saproling into play. If another
    player gains control of Verdant Force, the existing Saprolings stay
    where they are.

    ----------

    Yawgmoth Demon
    {4}{B}{B}
    Creature -- Demon
    6/6

    Flying (This creature can't be blocked except by creatures with
    flying.)

    First strike (This creature deals combat damage before creatures
    without first strike.)

    At the beginning of your upkeep, you may sacrifice an artifact. If you
    don't, tap Yawgmoth Demon and it deals 2 damage to you.

    * You may choose not to sacrifice an artifact.

    ----------

    All trademarks, including character names, are property of Wizards of
    the Coast, Inc. in the U.S.A. and other countries. (Copr.) 2005
    Wizards.


    athelred
    Level 1 Judge
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [9th] a "spider" can block as though it had flying
    Not bad, although I expect that most players won't even notice the difference.

    This seems to be going along with their recent trend towards cleaning up the rules. First they fixed walls, and then enchantments. Now they are changing this. These are only minor changes that clean up edge cases and consitancy. I wonder how much of this is coming directly out of the level 5 discussions. I'll have to ask Sheldon the next time I see him.

    athelred
    Level 1 Judge
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Bizarro Storm question
    I'm not a level 2, but lets give this a try

    503.2. When copying an object, the copy acquires the copiable values of the original object’s characteristics (name, mana cost, color, type, supertype, subtype, expansion symbol, rules text, power, and toughness) and, for an object on the stack, choices made when playing it (mode, targets, the value of X, whether a kicker cost was paid, how it will affect multiple targets, and so on). The "copiable values" are the values that are printed on the object, as modified by other copy effects, plus any values set for face-down spells or permanents. Other effects (including type-changing effects) and counters are not copied.

    Since the color changing effect of a lace is not something modified on the printed object by another copy effect or a value set for face-down spells or permanents, it would not be copied. Thus once storm resolved you would end up with one copy that is the color appropriate for the lace, and the remainder of the copies as the original color.

    athelred
    Level 1 Judge

    Edit: I start writing this thing, and by the time it gets posted someone else has posted almost the exact same thing.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings Archives
  • posted a message on Cranial Insertion: Take Your Turn
    Oh wait. If any state-based effects are applied or triggers are triggered during that discard, damage removal, and effect ending, then you get to play the priorité game again. Blah. But after that… TURN’S OVER!


    This is not entirely accurate.

    314.3. If the conditions for any state-based effects exist or if any triggered abilities are waiting to be put onto the stack, the active player gets priority and players may play spells and abilities. Once the stack is empty and both players pass, another cleanup step begins. Otherwise, no player receives priority and the step ends.



    You will note that after someone recieves priority during the cleanup step (for whatever reason), you immediately proceed to another cleanup step, not to the end of the turn.

    athelred
    Level 1 Judge
    Posted in: Articles
  • posted a message on Jinxed Choker
    Quote from Vodka7up »
    Using the same reasoning, when i get a Jinxed Choker, can i remove counters before my upkeep to prevent some of the damage?


    You can remove counters after the exchange has taken place, but before phase ends. You can also remove counters during the upkeep with the dealing damage effect on the stack. It uses number of counters on the choker when the ability resolves to determine damage, so if in response you remove all the counters you will take no damage.

    athelred
    Level 1 Judge
    Posted in: Magic Rulings Archives
  • posted a message on sleeves with artwork
    Quote from Tootsie_Roll »
    Even the 100 packs are sometimes defferecnt I think that they are packaged in the same way in things of 50 because if you notice when you open them 50 of them are usually curved the opposite way at the othe 50, also in my experiance buying 100 sleeves I have had a few times that 50 werre slightly bigger than the other 50 and that is my biggest M:tG petpeeve.


    Buying quality sleeves will fix this mostly. You may occasionally have issues, but if you stick to the really high quality sleves (like dragonshields), they will be few and far between. They are more expensive, but worth the $1- $2 extra per hundred.

    But then I tend to only use my sleeves for a short period of time anyway, so...

    As to sleeves with artwork, I have not been to or judged at a tournament that allows them. They are easy to mark intentionally and easy to mark accidentally. I would not use them for any games other than causual games (heck I wouldn't use them there, but whatever floats your boat).

    athelred
    Level 1 Judge
    Posted in: Magic Rulings Archives
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.