Oh, really ? Well, thank you. I would never have thought of that.
In the same spirit of cooperation, I'd like you to make a PBPA on yourself, unless of course you want me to do it. Then you can proceed to lynch yourself.
By the way, Kenji votes That Which Squeaks. Bandwagon !!!
Nah, I'm too lazy. I just figured I'd show that I recognize I'm pretty scummy looking, at least based on my voting record.
Sorry for the double post.
@AH: I'm afraid I would want a bit more than that. I've gotten a pretty bad vibe from you, and after the whole Kenji/Elvis thing I'd want to make sure. Any way you can tell us what you know without revealing your role?
No, as the untap ability is a trigger, meaning it triggers once, at the beginning of your upkeep. If it was worded, during your upkeep Forsaken City gains "Discard a card: Untap Forsaken City", then your scenario would work.
@DYH: Also, by those standards, I was on the bandwagons for all of them, and I unvoted on Machin Shin's at some point, until Kenji's confused counterclaim. Dunno whether this'll be seen as being town or not (probably not), but I figure I'd put it out there to save someone the trouble.
Eh... an unvote. I just began reading through again, and what was my big thing against MS actually isn't as incriminating when I read it correctly. (71/76 for anyone whos wondering). Not quite sure what to think now.
@Puzzle: I've never actually done a mass claim, so I really can't say I'd give good advice. However, from what I've been seeing (and flavor-wise) it seems to me that its very unlikely for anyone to be a vanilla. So, if we do go for it, we will expose cops and docs and the like, but (assuming) everyone has an ability, then we'll lose an ability person whenever there is a kill anyway. So... I guess I'm slightly inclined to say that it might help more than hurt.
Nope, but I'm not trying to kill anyone at the moment.
What exactly about the case against Bluesoul stands out to you, in particular?
Touche... As for your question, it is the way he seemed to handle his role... his brilliant plan was a dud, and I believe he would have seen that. If you want more, look at my pbp.
@ Bluesoul: No, no, you claimed at the right time with pressure on you, thats perfectly fine. My question was whether or not you understand why, assuming you're townie, claiming your role at the end of day 1, as you said you would have, would be bad. As for your role, yes, that is a point in your favor. However, you are not cleared because of it, and you're behavior has been extremely scummy. I'm not accepting sharing roles as completely townie, because who knows what CP thought up.
@Az: Is there really an explanation needed? Just as a note, you're not explaining yourself either. *shrugs*
@Bluesoul: I think you're scum, but do you actually understand why claiming your role would've been bad, if you were town? And, if you are town, why what you did makes me think you're scum.
I am worried that half of the waggon on bluesoul have themselves been the target of pbpa's/thought to be scummy by a lot of people. Those people being Machin Shin, Diggy, Beaker and Holmes.
This is a very valid point, but I'm also not sure what to think of it with Holmes' unvote... other than and FOS: Holmes. My vote stands for now, but I'll consider this deeply.
If we accept Twomz's result, then Bluesoul has an ability that belongs purely on a townie, correct?
I agree with what comes from this line, but I'm just wondering about your logic behind this... I could see this on a mafioso as well. Maybe SK, but don't they just normally have the kill ability?
So we do know what bluesoul's role is. However, his role in no way makes me think he isn't scum.... I'd be alright with a Machin Shin lynch, though I'm still convinced bluesoul is the better target on ability/overall scumminess/refusal to play.
Alright, I'm willing to concede to a Machin Shin lynch, but I'm going to wait on my vote until we get clarification from Twomz what exactly we know about bluesoul.
Nah, I'm too lazy. I just figured I'd show that I recognize I'm pretty scummy looking, at least based on my voting record.
Sorry for the double post.
@AH: I'm afraid I would want a bit more than that. I've gotten a pretty bad vibe from you, and after the whole Kenji/Elvis thing I'd want to make sure. Any way you can tell us what you know without revealing your role?
Vote: Machin Shin
Touche... As for your question, it is the way he seemed to handle his role... his brilliant plan was a dud, and I believe he would have seen that. If you want more, look at my pbp.
@ Bluesoul: No, no, you claimed at the right time with pressure on you, thats perfectly fine. My question was whether or not you understand why, assuming you're townie, claiming your role at the end of day 1, as you said you would have, would be bad. As for your role, yes, that is a point in your favor. However, you are not cleared because of it, and you're behavior has been extremely scummy. I'm not accepting sharing roles as completely townie, because who knows what CP thought up.
@Bluesoul: I think you're scum, but do you actually understand why claiming your role would've been bad, if you were town? And, if you are town, why what you did makes me think you're scum.
This is a very valid point, but I'm also not sure what to think of it with Holmes' unvote... other than and FOS: Holmes. My vote stands for now, but I'll consider this deeply.
I agree with what comes from this line, but I'm just wondering about your logic behind this... I could see this on a mafioso as well. Maybe SK, but don't they just normally have the kill ability?
So we do know what bluesoul's role is. However, his role in no way makes me think he isn't scum.... I'd be alright with a Machin Shin lynch, though I'm still convinced bluesoul is the better target on ability/overall scumminess/refusal to play.