Mmm... Absolutionis says he isn't scum, and CP says he did make an error... though its not supposed to have effected this. Yet Twomz said something that is untrue...
@KCW: Two things, first Puzzle did claim a role name, Number 2, who is indeed a character. Secondly Twomz did lie. He said that CP sent him a pm saying that Bluesoul had discussed his role in more detail in the thread. Yet the PM that Twomz sent contained all the information on Bluesoul we had until about 300 posts later after it was sent, long after Twomz said that Bluesoul was confirmed.
The slip-up, could be ignorable, at least in my eyes. What I posted though is proof that Twomz lied about CP's pm saying that he let him though. Thus, my vote.
Mainly because I didn't trust you, as you were seeming more and more... desperate, I suppose. I needed more of a detail then something that might possibly be implied. This is a more definite lie, at least in my opinion.
Lol, i almost forgot about the goldfish bowl. But i remembered it at the last second!
I doubt any of this will matter, because the mafia won't risk targetting Bluesoul... but, whatever.
So, Twomz did mention the Goldfish bowl then, however there was no mention of the refill ability. I believe this could've been implied... However:
Quote from bluesoul, post 737 »
I will explain my role once again, completely. I'm Wonko the Sane. I have a fishbowl full of wheat germ, and when someone targets me, I can choose to throw my wheat germ at them, causing them to get disgusted and leave. When I use this (one-shot) ability, I'll simply have a fishbowl, which I'll pass on to someone when I die.
This is the first time that Bluesoul ever mentions that the bowl refills.
Quote from Twomz, post 1120 »
I can't quote what CP said back to me... but it was something along the lines of Bluesoul had discussed his ability in more depth in the thread, but that he was going to let it go through anyway. The reason i haven't tried again on anyone else is that i know i'll have to be way more specific to meet CP's standards next time... and no one has really full claimed besides Bluesoul.
Bolding mine. He had done no such thing, considering he only mentioned this extra bit a few hundred posts after you said it had gone through. And thus a Unvote, Vote: Twomz.
Oh, a few more notes. The red text there is part of the search, black bolding is mine.
On Puzzle: Believable role, seems likely,and his record is pretty good. No scum there, I believe.
Oh, theres no confidence, I think hes being an idiot, but I don't know if hes scum. I wouldn't be unhappy to see him go anyway if just to stop him leaking everywhere and holding back info, but my chance of living depends on lynching scum, which I don't believe he is.
1. Thats not established neccessarily. I can see where CP would allow his ability to go through, even without specifically saying that the giving of the fishbowl would give them the ability. After all, what would the point of it be if it didn't. Admittedly this is bad against him, but I believe him.
2/3. Yeah, hes acted pretty scummy, but in a sense he is a watcher and roleblocker (assuming his claims are true), and I don't believe hes scum, just as a matter of sense.
In short, I don't think hes scum, and based on my own survival I'm going to look elsewhere. But if the town think hes the best lynch, then go right ahead, I won't object.
*shrugs*
Anyone, yay to be alive, vote Abandon Hope for the time being, and I'll post more once I have free time.
Mmm... Absolutionis says he isn't scum, and CP says he did make an error... though its not supposed to have effected this. Yet Twomz said something that is untrue...
*is now waiting for the lynch scene*
Because its his ability, of course. I'd personally say KCW would be a fine choice here as well.
So, Twomz did mention the Goldfish bowl then, however there was no mention of the refill ability. I believe this could've been implied... However:
This is the first time that Bluesoul ever mentions that the bowl refills.
Bolding mine. He had done no such thing, considering he only mentioned this extra bit a few hundred posts after you said it had gone through. And thus a Unvote, Vote: Twomz.
Oh, a few more notes. The red text there is part of the search, black bolding is mine.
On Puzzle: Believable role, seems likely,and his record is pretty good. No scum there, I believe.
I'm highly, highly suspicous of AH, and I'm hoping to do an analysis today at some point, so that I can have some concrete examples to point to.
1. Thats not established neccessarily. I can see where CP would allow his ability to go through, even without specifically saying that the giving of the fishbowl would give them the ability. After all, what would the point of it be if it didn't. Admittedly this is bad against him, but I believe him.
2/3. Yeah, hes acted pretty scummy, but in a sense he is a watcher and roleblocker (assuming his claims are true), and I don't believe hes scum, just as a matter of sense.
In short, I don't think hes scum, and based on my own survival I'm going to look elsewhere. But if the town think hes the best lynch, then go right ahead, I won't object.