2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on The Brood Lineage
    If you rearrange the letters in Eldrazi you get Dlizera. Then it's a matter of replacing the D and A with S and the Z with a V and there you go! SLIVERS!
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on Zendikar as a card?
    Quote from Dave Rockstar
    why not this, I mean, the next set is called "worldwake" maybe the abuse of the Roil causes Zendikar's spark to ignite...:


    I'd play that in a heartbeat... on my first turn... through some ungodly means.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on Fun Mill Crab
    Oh, good deal! I see what you mean now, plus with the archive trap, as discussed on the Spec thread, it'd be super punishing

    'Nathed on the trap
    Posted in: Rumor Mill Archive
  • posted a message on Fun Mill Crab
    Quote from Telastyn
    And I like how it's a direct threat to make fetching not the no-brainer it was. And I like how stuff like the Pyromancy Ascension then can counter milling a bit. I hope to see a little more of that.


    Do you mean that if they fetch you mill? Because Landfall only works for your lands, so that still makes fetching a no-brainer. A land you need and six off the top? Why not?
    Posted in: Rumor Mill Archive
  • posted a message on Fun Mill Crab
    Quote from pandafarmer
    Considering the strategy is rarely viable in any tournament format (Owling Mine and High Tide are the only ones I can think of that aren't Fog based), I think it's nice to see them give it some solid love this time around.


    True dat! A strategy can only be viable if they offer the tools.

    You all sure would hate building a house with a screwdriver, but that changes when you have a hammer.
    Posted in: Rumor Mill Archive
  • posted a message on Ob Nixilis, Planeswalker?
    Quote from krishnath
    Anyway, We know for a fact that Elsphet is not native to Alara, and we know for a fact that she "comes from a plane of darkness and horror". Now, we don't know to many planes that are like that, and one of those we can discredit from the start because it is pretty much only populated by demons (The Abyss), Of the remaining we can also discard Shadowmoor as she is obviously human (or human looking), that pretty much leaves two possible home planes among the planes we know: Phyrexia and Ulgrotha, and the latter only holds true if the Baron finally managed to conquer the plane.


    That's not necessarily true. She may be native to ALARA, but we know she's not native to BANT. She could be from Grixis (though doubtful, since she would know all Grixis lore and wonder why Bantian lore matches so closely).
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on Viable Mill? [Archive Trap]
    Quote from TwOnEight_Magic
    I think you'll really miss the Path to Exile / Archive Trap synergy. But, best of luck in any case. Smile


    I agree. As mentioned earlier, either you get a drawback-less PtE (meaning they missed out on thinning their deck AND getting a land for ramping/landfall or that it's well past when they need a land, so whatever you PtEd was worth it) or you get to trap them, which comes with the fun of mimicing Admiral Ackbar.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on Could the next set be a LIFE THEMED set?
    Quote from The Pinsir
    Yeah...let's hope not. You don't win games by gaining life. That will be a sad day for Magic...


    Test of Endurance, Sanguine Bond and Felidar Sovereign would like to have a word with you.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on [Read This] Rumor Mill rules and regulations
    Before posting, take a quick second to review these rules.

    • As an entry point to the rest of MTGSalvation, we are more relaxed on spam. Most spam will merely be deleted, but if we find you going on a spamming spree, or it is a common theme, an infraction will be issued.
    • Related to that, these forums have a thanks system. If you see a post that has an opinion you agree with, we strongly urge you to thank it rather than parrot. This will cut down on the number of “This art is awesome!” and “This card sucks!” posts.
    • Similarly, please use the search function. This will allow you to see if anyone has already posted about your news.
    • Flaming will not be tolerated. There is no need to insult other people. You may attack ideas, but do so while being civil. Cite your sources if at all possible.
    • If you have a scan, card image or similar, we suggest using the ‘manage attachment’ option beneath the posting box to attach images. This serves two functions. It will keep your image from being removed or running out of bandwidth, and it will keep you from possibly receiving an image leech infraction.
    • If you have information from an EBAY auction or Craigslist sale (or similar sale site), do not link to it. This is not Market Street, and advertising isn’t allowed. Feel free to comment on the auction, but do not link it.
    • Do not complain about slow rumor seasons or individuals who post information. Both are spam, and in regards to spoilers, it’s punching a gift horse in the mouth. We appreciate any little information we get.
    • Please do not perform necromancy on threads. If you see a thread that has been dead for about a month, please leave it that way. The exception to this is new information on an upcoming product.
    • The Rumor Mill is not Custom Card Creation. Please do not post your designs in the Rumor Mill.
    • If you are merely guessing off of general themes and hints, that goes in Speculation. If you are wildly guessing with no basis in anything currently happening, that goes in Baseless Speculation. Threads not in their appropriate section will be moved.
    • We do not encourage, condone or support the breaking of NDAs or other legal contracts. Do not do it. It’s not worth the risk and consequences that it brings to you and us.
    • Compiled info threads and spoilers allow posting, but once your post’s information has been added to the initial post, your post will be deleted.
    • Box Mapping - Discussing the practice of tracking print runs is allowed, but creating Box Maps is not, nor is linking to one. People attempting to make these maps will be infracted and the posts deleted.

    -The Rumor Mill Staff
    Posted in: Rumor Mill Archive
  • posted a message on Rules for Rumored Card Rulings
    This subforum is to be used for rules questions concerning cards that are added to the MTGSalvation spoiler for the current product being spoiled.

    Some rules on new abilities and mechanics may not be easily outlined in reminder text, so please keep that in mind as some rulings may change after new information is released.

    No rulings made in this forum are to be considered 100% and final, but they will at least help to clear up confusion related to how certain cards 'work'.

    Ruling questions on cards in standard legal sets are not for discussion here.

    Otherwise, this subforum follows most of the same rules as the main Rulings forum. You can read the full set of Rulings Forum Guidelines, but the ones relevant to this subforum are quoted below:

    • Posts that just answer a question by saying "Yes" or "No", without any further explanation, are considered spam. Please explain why something works or why not. Exception: If the question is "Is [explanation stuff stuff] correct?", "Yes" is an acceptable answer. "No" is not - explain why it's wrong then.
    • You can save time by using the Search function to see if such a thread exists that already answers your question. You generally will not be penalized for not searching, though, unless the question you're asking is still on the first page in another thread.
    • Don't repeat the right answer over and over again. That can also be considered spam. If the question of a thread has been fully answered and this answer has been backed up by two other posters, then I think that the thread has served its purpose.
    • If you're not 100% sure if your answer is correct, please avoid posting. Check the Comprehensive Rules or other resources to make sure that you're right, or just wait until someone who is sure helps out. Guessing answers does not help! It is okay to be wrong, but do not say "I don't know, but I think..." unless there's a very good reason to guess.
    • Do use card-tags, especially when starting a thread or mentioning a card for the first time. You can find an explanation on how they work in THIS THREAD. There are only two exceptions to this rule: basic lands, and questions where the cards don't matter (eg, referring to "Dread Return" played for its flashback cost versus "a spell" played for its flashback cost to ask a question on flashback). Absolutely do not include in your post "Hey, use card tags!" This serves no purpose whatsoever; just report the post, and one of the mods can determine if card tags are needed and handle it appropriately. For cards that have not yet been released, please post the rules text, to the extent we currently know it.
    • Just because some people don't understand it: this is not the forum to discuss combos and/or strategies. This is a forum where you can ask and answer rules-questions, but that's it. If you want to know if and why a combo works, you're in the right place. If you want to know how to respond to anything or the like, go to the strategy-forums. Mentioning how to improve a combo in a rules answer is okay; posting just to provide combo tips is not.
    • Be polite. While the general forum rules already prohibit flaming, please remember that you're either here to give or receive assistance. The standards for politeness are therefore higher than other parts of the Salvation forums.
    • No nitpicking. If you want to post that an answer is wrong because of either a) an informal usage (summoning sickness, fizzle), or b) one or two cards in all of Magic can change the answer, DON'T. Yes, the answer is different if Chains of Mephistopheles is in play. No, no one cares. Nitpicking serves to discourage users from posting answers, which does a disservice to everyone.
    Posted in: Rumored Card Rulings
  • posted a message on Rules and suggestions for New Card Discussion
    What belongs here:
    -SCD threads for cards from the current product being spoiled.
    -Discussion of groups of new cards/cycles from the current product being spoiled.
    -General strategies from the current product being spoiled.
    -New decks involving rumored cards from the current product being spoiled. Keep in mind that the standard boards do not permit decklists involving cards that are not yet legal in the format.

    Threads concerning rumored cards are not allowed on many other boards.

    If you see a post that violates the Forum Rules, please use the report post button.

    Please label your thread/topic carefully when starting a new thread. Repeats of other threads covering the same cards/subject matter as an existing thread will be deleted.

    Please don't make a new thread to discuss your favorites/top10/worst10 from a particular set. If everybody did that, there would be thousands of new threads here. Instead, post on a currently ongoing discussion about favorites/top10s/worst10s.
    Posted in: New Card Discussion
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.