Here's the scenario: my friend and I are playing a game with the planeshift cards. The plane we are on is Immersturm and he rolls a chaos and triggers the effect on his own creature: a forest that was made into a 4/4 creature by a spell. My question is, when the forest leaves play, does that cancel the effect that made it a creature? If so, does it come back into play at all? Thanks.
My friend and i have just finished playing a match hinging on a controversial play.
The major details are as follows: he is using a mono green elf deck, while I'm using a white deck with artifacts. He attacks with a 31/31 Heedless One (unbuffed, just had an a$$load of elf tokens on the field). I play Boros Fury-Shield and use Spectral Searchlight to gain the one red mana for BFS's added effect. He has a Shell of the Last Kappa in play and claims that he can use that to counter the spell. I argue that the spell itself doesn't target him, just the secondary effect. We debate for a bit, then attempt to google the ruling of such a play. Our serach is fruitless, and we finally agree that BFS doesn't target him, just his creature, and he loses as a result. Were we correct?
"Ass" isn't even censored, but don't try to evade the censor. That just defeats the purpose of having one. -Woap
The major details are as follows: he is using a mono green elf deck, while I'm using a white deck with artifacts. He attacks with a 31/31 Heedless One (unbuffed, just had an a$$load of elf tokens on the field). I play Boros Fury-Shield and use Spectral Searchlight to gain the one red mana for BFS's added effect. He has a Shell of the Last Kappa in play and claims that he can use that to counter the spell. I argue that the spell itself doesn't target him, just the secondary effect. We debate for a bit, then attempt to google the ruling of such a play. Our serach is fruitless, and we finally agree that BFS doesn't target him, just his creature, and he loses as a result. Were we correct?
"Ass" isn't even censored, but don't try to evade the censor. That just defeats the purpose of having one. -Woap