I'm not opposed to letting toastboy off the hook for the moment.
Vote Xyre.
I understand your reasons for voting for Xyre, but I am curious as to your insight on the Kraj case. I recall earlier that you opted to add him to your town list, and as I recall Kraj voted for Kpaca in the post after Kpaca said he was unsure of Kraj being added to the town list (telling? Maybe).
When I asked earlier if Kraj's vote was simple bandwagoning he said it was, and from his post on the last page he doesn't seem to think that's scummy, but I believe kpaca's post on this page is the best response to that. I think you'll find the reason for kraj's vote switch was as he said in the post he made it- he wants a lightning fast day one.
Can Chris and Phantom explain in detail why they think that Kraj switching votes is scummy? I would prefer that Chris answer first.
I had said in my earlier post that I intended on reserving judgment on toast. It was more that the vote was switched to a bandwagon vote on what I deemed a weak wagon than the mere act of switching it.
All you were doing with that post was acknowledging the existence of cases, not whether or not you agreed with them? Huh.
Perhaps you should check back on that post. The most relevant part was that I didn't even see the case against Chris.
I think that toastboy is getting rather frustrated, but in my experience that can mean caught scum or overwhelmed town. I'm reserving judgment on him.
One thing that strikes me as majorly suspicious is Kraj's last post. He starts by saying he's happy with his kpaca vote, and finishes by voting for toastboy... Is this a joke? I think we're far enough out of random to deem it not to be, and I think toastboy has enough votes on him for this to be simple bandwagoning.
I think R&D just wanted to see what would happen in a wrathless format. Hopefully some manner of control remains viable without it. Honestly, wrath balances formats, so I really do hope we get it back soon.
Hello all. I know some peeps on here from MTGDarkness and thought I'd come see what Sally is about. I loves me some magics and am trying to learn how to not such at mafia.
I understand your reasons for voting for Xyre, but I am curious as to your insight on the Kraj case. I recall earlier that you opted to add him to your town list, and as I recall Kraj voted for Kpaca in the post after Kpaca said he was unsure of Kraj being added to the town list (telling? Maybe).
When I asked earlier if Kraj's vote was simple bandwagoning he said it was, and from his post on the last page he doesn't seem to think that's scummy, but I believe kpaca's post on this page is the best response to that. I think you'll find the reason for kraj's vote switch was as he said in the post he made it- he wants a lightning fast day one.
I had said in my earlier post that I intended on reserving judgment on toast. It was more that the vote was switched to a bandwagon vote on what I deemed a weak wagon than the mere act of switching it.
Convenient that you didn't mention these things. Would you kindly address them now?
Perhaps you should check back on that post. The most relevant part was that I didn't even see the case against Chris.
I think that toastboy is getting rather frustrated, but in my experience that can mean caught scum or overwhelmed town. I'm reserving judgment on him.
One thing that strikes me as majorly suspicious is Kraj's last post. He starts by saying he's happy with his kpaca vote, and finishes by voting for toastboy... Is this a joke? I think we're far enough out of random to deem it not to be, and I think toastboy has enough votes on him for this to be simple bandwagoning.
vote: kraj
As in, you need to wait for Az to post before you decided what to say?
As I recall, I said I saw the case, not that I agreed with it.
Well, I don't know Az, and I will easily concede that he is a better player than I, but here is my read on Az's vote on Xyre:
Az votes for the mod on page one
Xyre barns the mod vote
The novelty of the mod vote was lost after the first time it was done. Xyre's post was therefor neither funny nor conducive to scum hunting.
I think I just lost 500 Az points.
I see the case on Netfinity and Xyre, but I'm still missing the one on Chris.
If the contention is that she's good in every matchup then why isn't she maindeck?
I got Kown'd.
Discuss.