Blinking seeing the kill attempt on Puzzle clears Puzzle IMO outside of a rediculous gambit.
Armlx you are currently voting for the right person, but you appear to be confused about what happened last night. There was no attempt on Puzzle last night. There was an attempt on Blinking last night, which was prevented by Pibbly.
Concerning claims, I'd suggest that everyone who has two unclaimed cards state the following total :
Power Day 1 + Toughness Day 1 + Power Day 2 + Toughness Day 2. Only the total, not the individual values and only people who haven't claimed day 1 or day 2 cards.
Hey, five days, not bad. Back to lurking...
Good grief. If that isn't the most confusing and pointless suggestion yet. Are you just pulling our legs now?
Can we get a few more votes over here? (Sorry, Puzzle, I seem to have it in for you both games at the moment.)
Remember, though, I don't want a lynch yet. Just 10 votes. (Alpha, you never voted).
Well that's...interesting. And completely unnecessary, I think, for you to have said. I rather suspect the mafia didn't know where it was. But I'll trust that you know what you are doing and are in no danger tonight (or tomorrow?)
Forget the FOS stuff, though (that was Puzzle's idea). Just vote.
Puzzle, we are lynching Silicon right now, so it isn't even worth responding to your hot air at this point (though I'm sure Armlx and Blinking are getting a big chuckle out of the idea that we are all in cahoots together).
I will not be baited by you today (then again, if people want to change their minds and lynch Puzzle today, I'd happily re-engage on the subject).
@Armlx + other PKs: I wouldn't protect swinkee, guys. (after all, we still have Puzzle!) Frankly, if the mafia goes after him tonight--and gets him--we would learn just about everything we need to break the game. Assuming Puzzle still claims to be protecting him.
I would recommed putting out two names (but not Puzzle, swinkee, or me) and each of the three of you privately picking one of them. That way one of those people will definately be protected, and as a practical matter, the mafia would probably avoid both. I might go with Pibbly (not that he's totally clear to me yet, but he claimed that Talisman protecting function) and maybe Blinking Spirit (assuming Silicon is scum, he's pretty much cleared).
Ok a few things. Am I the only one who noticed that communication bewteen Axel and Iammars? Axel suggested that in order to trap mafia he should claim rare but to give them more wiggle room he should claim common. Iammars claimed common. I am almost sure that Axel is town however and therefore make little of this.
???
I was trying to see if we could use Iammars' second day card to help trap a mafia in blue. If his day 2 card wasn't rare, however, it wouldn't help us. So I asked him. He said it wasn't rare. This doesn't tell us anything. I certainly wasn't instructing him to say his card wasn't rare.
Okay, if that's a gambit Blinking, it's a good one.
Unvote Puzzle
Vote Silicon
Tonight I don't really want the Peacekeepers to protect Puzzle anymore (sorry Puzzle, apparantly you can protect yourself--quite a nice job you got there, HA!) Puzzle should still protect Swinkee (of course!) to prove what a good Doctor he really is. Swinkee, I almost don't care what you do. You ought to investigate Titus, but I'm not sure I'd trust you if you said you did.
If the owner of the Talisman feels in need of protection, he might want to say so. If not, Peacekeepers need to agree on someone (or at least one of you needs to come out and say who, for sure, you are protecting. Don't protect me, though ).
There are several possibilities to consider. If we were following my original idea then the people we would be looking at today would be:
Carrion Pigeons
Urban Druid
Titus
Blinking Spirit
Silicon
We would lynch one of these, Swinkee would investigate another and tomorrow we would know the score. If we missed the lynch, and Swinkee said his investigation was True, then the last three would by default all be Mafia (unless Swinkee himself was mafia). We would lynch all of them in turn and then, if that was not game, look for the last one, probably in the Peacekeepers.
But since I now suspect Puzzle (4 Docs guys-FOUR. Don't forget this.) The math may be off. And if Puzzle is False, it casts doubt on all Swinkee's inspections. Pibbly could then be False (or me).
I'm willing to change my vote, however, because from where we stand right now, we can only miss one more lynch--assuming a 5 man Red mafia. We really need to get their numbers down to give us breathing room.
Druid is almost certainly clear. The "fog" role-block effect makes little sense for mafia. Likewise, Carrion Pigeons is virtually clear to me. His role-claim was extremely solid. I don't believe a mafia could have invented it.
That leaves:
Silicon
Titus
Blinking Spirit
Of these, Silicon has always been my top target. I think he is most likely mafia, regardless of some kind of Swinkee/Puzzle gambit. Such a gambit could have been used to "clear" Pibbly (along with Puzzle) and there might be another one in the Peacekeepers, but that's the absolutely worst case, we ain't gonna win scenario, and even then, Silicon looks like he's probably still mafia.
Deadly Budah - 1 (Pibbly)
God Child - 1 (swinkee)
Swinkee - 1 (God Child)
Enigma91 - 4 (LJustus, Armlx, Fayul, Deadly Budah)
With 17 alive it takes 9 to lynch.
Armlx you are currently voting for the right person, but you appear to be confused about what happened last night. There was no attempt on Puzzle last night. There was an attempt on Blinking last night, which was prevented by Pibbly.
Luke! It's a trap!
Still open to the suggestion we lynch Puzzle first, in light of the fact he just confessed an all.
Good grief. If that isn't the most confusing and pointless suggestion yet. Are you just pulling our legs now?
Can we get a few more votes over here? (Sorry, Puzzle, I seem to have it in for you both games at the moment.)
Remember, though, I don't want a lynch yet. Just 10 votes. (Alpha, you never voted).
Forget the FOS stuff, though (that was Puzzle's idea). Just vote.
I will not be baited by you today
I would recommed putting out two names (but not Puzzle, swinkee, or me) and each of the three of you privately picking one of them. That way one of those people will definately be protected, and as a practical matter, the mafia would probably avoid both. I might go with Pibbly (not that he's totally clear to me yet, but he claimed that Talisman protecting function) and maybe Blinking Spirit (assuming Silicon is scum, he's pretty much cleared).
Deadly Budah - 1 (Pibbly)
God Child - 1 (swinkee)
Swinkee - 1 (God Child)
With 17 alive it takes 9 to lynch.
???
I was trying to see if we could use Iammars' second day card to help trap a mafia in blue. If his day 2 card wasn't rare, however, it wouldn't help us. So I asked him. He said it wasn't rare. This doesn't tell us anything. I certainly wasn't instructing him to say his card wasn't rare.
Vote: Puzzle
I would like to get him up to, oh say, 10 votes, but not lynch him. Just want to see if anything happens. Yes, I've got my reasons.
Unvote Puzzle
Vote Silicon
Tonight I don't really want the Peacekeepers to protect Puzzle anymore (sorry Puzzle, apparantly you can protect yourself--quite a nice job you got there, HA!) Puzzle should still protect Swinkee (of course!) to prove what a good Doctor he really is. Swinkee, I almost don't care what you do. You ought to investigate Titus, but I'm not sure I'd trust you if you said you did.
If the owner of the Talisman feels in need of protection, he might want to say so. If not, Peacekeepers need to agree on someone (or at least one of you needs to come out and say who, for sure, you are protecting. Don't protect me, though
Carrion Pigeons
Urban Druid
Titus
Blinking Spirit
Silicon
We would lynch one of these, Swinkee would investigate another and tomorrow we would know the score. If we missed the lynch, and Swinkee said his investigation was True, then the last three would by default all be Mafia (unless Swinkee himself was mafia). We would lynch all of them in turn and then, if that was not game, look for the last one, probably in the Peacekeepers.
But since I now suspect Puzzle (4 Docs guys-FOUR. Don't forget this.) The math may be off. And if Puzzle is False, it casts doubt on all Swinkee's inspections. Pibbly could then be False (or me).
I'm willing to change my vote, however, because from where we stand right now, we can only miss one more lynch--assuming a 5 man Red mafia. We really need to get their numbers down to give us breathing room.
Druid is almost certainly clear. The "fog" role-block effect makes little sense for mafia. Likewise, Carrion Pigeons is virtually clear to me. His role-claim was extremely solid. I don't believe a mafia could have invented it.
That leaves:
Silicon
Titus
Blinking Spirit
Of these, Silicon has always been my top target. I think he is most likely mafia, regardless of some kind of Swinkee/Puzzle gambit. Such a gambit could have been used to "clear" Pibbly (along with Puzzle) and there might be another one in the Peacekeepers, but that's the absolutely worst case, we ain't gonna win scenario, and even then, Silicon looks like he's probably still mafia.
And Puzzle's deliberate lurking is beginning to annoy me. Any lurking is bad, but to announce it?
Deadly Budah - 1 (Pibbly)
With 17 alive it takes 9 to lynch.
*kpaca is being prodded*