2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • 2

    posted a message on [PODCAST] Re-Making Magic Episode 37 - Why Magic Sucks
    I really enjoyed the part where you critiqued my entire ideology and belief system but I was let down that the rest of the podcast wasn't also about me Frown

    to the point that I'm an "armchair designer" that hasn't made games: I'm a writer. What I do is write. My subject is games, and specifically Magic. I'm not pretending to be a designer

    re: Rosewater: you say yourselves that you have to ignore and filter out his hype about new sets. Doesn't that kind of prove my arguments that he's not relevant, if some percentage of his articles you just accept as "oh yeah this one is just ad copy"? But more fundamentally, you misunderstand what I mean about him. He is a marketing agent of the game, so even when he's speaking honestly about Tempest or whatever (and to be clear, I think he is by far at his most interesting when he's talking about the past, because he doesn't need to filter) he is still coming from the perspective of the Wizards employee. "A History of Video Games Presented by the Nintendo WiiU" is going to have certain biases that color the material, so the same applies to Rosewater

    also he's not funny

    on to the "why magic sucks" portion: I was disappointed you only touch on 1/4 of the points I made, but sure, price is a big one. The snowboarding analogy is well taken, but the difference I see is that there are physical objects required to be a Serious Snowboarder: you will physically go down a hill in a different way with different gear. Magic, though, only has some cards as more expensive than other cards due to their economic model of Magic as a TCG and not a living card game. With a different economic model, there could be the same games at a fraction of the cost

    it's also telling that whenever people try to make comparisons about Magic's costs w/r/t the cost of other hobbies, they always compare it to physical hobbies for outdoorsy white people: snowboarding, fishing, hunting, that sort of thing. Doesn't it say a lot about this CARD GAME that the closest things in terms of cost are things that require so much equipment? Compared to other non-active games, anything that can be played at a kitchen table or on a couch, Magic is super expensive

    yes, you don't have to spend as much if you don't want to be competitive. But the decision to make Magic more expensive when played competitively is a decision; it is not integral to the cards themselves.

    I've taught Magic to a bunch of people too and one of the reasons many of them stop is, "it's so expensive"

    sure, YOU know how to have fun with 10 thrown-together decks for $10, but the newer player just sees booster packs and goes "oh wow that is expensive"
    Posted in: Custom Card Creation
  • 4

    posted a message on
    Comment Hidden
    Link Removed
  • 7

    posted a message on
    Comment Hidden
    Link Removed
  • 1

    posted a message on
    Comment Hidden
    Link Removed
  • 2

    posted a message on
    Comment Hidden
    Link Removed
  • 1

    posted a message on Killing a Goldfish
    *throws voice* yeah that guy is great
    Posted in: Magic General
  • 1

    posted a message on Boston "false flag"
    Conspiracy theories in the wake of horrifying tragedies are a fairly well-studied phenomenon. Even rational people try to make sense of senseless, catastrophic acts. It helps shield us from facing our own powerlessness; the world seems like a more sensible, logical place, where our actions have real meaning, if the most important acts in history have meaning.

    If I ask you, in the dark, is it more likely that the destruction of buildings that cost (in 2013 dollars) $2.3 billion, took thousands of lives, and irrevocably shaped our culture and policies are the work of someone's well-budgeted plan, or some randoms with virtually no resources? The idea that people half a world away can cause that much damage is, frankly, harrowing.

    Similarly, would we rather our most-beloved president in modern memory to die as a result of his policies and actions from a conspiracy, or some lone nutjob?

    The development of conspiracies is, in many ways, a coping mechanism.

    Alex Jones is another case, though. This is a guy with a pretty clear messiah complex and a large following that is so far deep down the rabbit hole that they assume anything that contradicts their beliefs is a plant by The Enemy. There is literally no evidence that could persuade them, because they will interpret it as something planned by enemies of Jones. (Not to mention that vast conspiracies such as this inherently appeal to the mentally ill, which, as someone with a lot of mental illness in my family as well as dealing with forms of it myself, is very saddening.)
    Posted in: Debate
  • 3

    posted a message on
    Comment Hidden
    Link Removed
  • 1

    posted a message on ND bans most abortions
    Quote from Killer Of Giants

    Firstly, I am glad you believe the propaganda propagated by Planned Parenthood. I am assuming you are on their monthly mailing list.


    This is extremely offensive. Their mailing list is bi-weekly.
    Posted in: Debate
  • 1

    posted a message on Should the number of posts matter when issuing suspensions?
    Someone's cumulative post quality should be considered, not number of posts. Someone with a high posts per day is probably just posting absolute garbage. But someone who is one of the best members of the forum calls someone a ****ing idiot? Some leniency should exist. On the other hand, though, if someone is a nonstop terrible poster, they should get the book thrown at them for a missed piece of punctuation
    Posted in: Community Discussion
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.