Is this the right thread to discuss BR Reanimator? If not please link me to the right thread. Anyway...
What do you think is better in BR Reanimator Bayou or Scrubland?
Scrubland offers less sideboard slots, an advantage, to play Wear//Tear
Bayou uses more sideboard slots for Reverent Silence and Abrupt Decay.
The advantage with Bayou is that Abrupt Decay is uncounterable and can also hit Deathrite Shaman. Nevertheless, both versions play Collective Brutality in side and will side it in anyway. I read after googling around for a while that Bayou used to be favoured before Top was banned but now Scrubland is better.
What do you think?
For now I've invested in the Scrubland mainly for budget reasons
I'm new to Modern and I will be probably building this list. Feel free to give me feedback.
I'm working from this deck tech video
I'm unsure about playing the Mind Stone with Chalice in the same deck.
I no longer see this deck getting good results at major tournaments. It seems to have fallen off the face of the earth. I see Eldrazi doing well, I have this complete deck, but I dislike playing it.
Allowing proxies would drive collector demand and make the format way more popular and i think anyone syaing otherwise is crazy . when people pay to proxy in events, they win cards at the store. duh. probably to get the cards they're proxying.
I meant cards like Brainstorm . You'd have all your staple valued cards, but the kind of cards that make the metagame swing more tempo to the other more mid range would fluctuate. A format where you need to spend 2-3 mana to efficiently card draw would be fun to play in occasionally.
You should be able to pay to proxy your deck , have the coin enter a prize pool, so that anyone who wants to drop $20 occasionally to play MTG and proxy much of their deck or change and play different decks occasionally can, and then everyone benefits from people doing this. I could proxy for instance a Mana Crypt to play Vintage, and it'd make sense to do this financially since I'd have to play over 100 times to make up the difference in cost, but I would also buy Mana Crypt just because I like collecting cards, and if I won a prize pool of proxy money from other people, yes I would use the store credit to do guess what? buy magic cards. so I don't see what the problem of proxies is. it drives collector demand. it makes the format more enticing for new people to play. it benefits everyone.
The way the banned list is right now is that particular strategies are really good for years on end.
I'd prefer to have a banned list which is seasonal or every two or three months, this wouldn't madly fluctuate the value of staple cards like Dark Confidant that are rares, or like Tarmogoyf, and if cards like that were ever banned (just making examples) they'd be on and off the list for a short duration, but the cards I think need regular bannings and non-bannings like in and out of rotation are cards like these,
Allowing proxies in Legacy would benefit collectors a lot and drive collector demand for harder to get cards. If more people played Legacy there would be more cards made for the format. Allowing proxies would increase the cost of a lot of the cards, just as Modern and Commander made cards more expensive..
I've considered playing this in Legacy MUD .
Though I think I might start playing Legacy LOL and play Vintage instead.
I wanted to start attending Vintage tournaments and playing without Tangle Wire and Smokestack so that I don't have to do stack nonsense, for now .
Some people prefer it because the Wurm isn't Legendary so it can't be bounced by Karakas
What do you think is better in BR Reanimator Bayou or Scrubland?
Scrubland offers less sideboard slots, an advantage, to play Wear//Tear
Bayou uses more sideboard slots for Reverent Silence and Abrupt Decay.
The advantage with Bayou is that Abrupt Decay is uncounterable and can also hit Deathrite Shaman. Nevertheless, both versions play Collective Brutality in side and will side it in anyway. I read after googling around for a while that Bayou used to be favoured before Top was banned but now Scrubland is better.
What do you think?
For now I've invested in the Scrubland mainly for budget reasons
I'm working from this deck tech video
I'm unsure about playing the Mind Stone with Chalice in the same deck.
I'd prefer to have a banned list which is seasonal or every two or three months, this wouldn't madly fluctuate the value of staple cards like Dark Confidant that are rares, or like Tarmogoyf, and if cards like that were ever banned (just making examples) they'd be on and off the list for a short duration, but the cards I think need regular bannings and non-bannings like in and out of rotation are cards like these,
Dark Ritual
Stoneforge Mystic
Lightning Bolt
Brainstorm
Swords to Plowshares
Wasteland
I find the removal in Legacy to be too good, all at once at one time, there aren't enough blind spots in the format.
the policy on formats seems to be "as much as possible at once" when it should be "certain cards in and out now and then"
the problem with Daretti is that your opponent can attack into him. his loyalty is not high enough
I've considered playing this in Legacy MUD .
Though I think I might start playing Legacy LOL and play Vintage instead.
I wanted to start attending Vintage tournaments and playing without Tangle Wire and Smokestack so that I don't have to do stack nonsense, for now .
Insert a picture of a goblin burning his face off.
Artifact
Sacrifice this to add RRR and draw a card.
Be careful with that.
//
Molten Scrap
Land
T: Add 1 to your mana pool and this deals 1 damage to you.
2, T: Add RRR to your mana pool. Use this ability only if you control a Desert.
Welder with Cloudposts with enough red mana for Daretti and a couple welders is possible.
I find Wasteland to be relatively useless and would prefer boarding it out, as odd as it sounds.
Daretti gives really good card draw..