With one more kill things may get clearer. I'm afraid we will eventually need to decide on one of you guys, but not now, maybe one of you even die toNight. Notice that I'm not saying that's likely, it's not but stranger things have happened.
I'm having second doubts, not because of my reread, but because that's way too convenient and it DOESN'T make a lick of sense for a CC from Iso at that point, it would be such a terrible play I cannot see Iso doing it.
Because if swish was gambitting scum, he was hunting for the real SCC owner, and what if no one had CCed him? He would just be lynched as part of the plan himself was now pushing for, and worse still he would NOT have the SSC so he would die alone. This does not make a lick of sense, and Iso made the worst possible play available by CC him. On the other hand, if Iso was scum CC him is just a brilliant game winning gambit.
In the end the whole situation is so complex I have no confidence to lynch either one, I say we no lynch and pray that our NK shed a little light into this mess. Hopefully the jailer and the redirector can make something good.
vote no lynch
EWP: btw if you have a redirect, try to redirect the kill to me for obvious reasons.
@Karn I'm not rereading the full game unless I'm alive in lylo, considering I'm the best player available and have already caught the scumteam, I find this unlikely Swish is probably going to toast me after we lynch him.
Also WG vote probably means he's swish buddy for three reasons.
a)WG is not a noob, he knows very well townies should not be voting in lylo.
b)Swish position is much weaker than Iso's, he knows it, everyone knows it. When scum see the painting on the wall they are usually quick to bus to earn some town credit.
c)he instantly determined Iso was the town of them both because of a convoluted reason. Looks like inside info to me.
I'm rereading and it's not even close. Swish is so obvscum it hurts.Also Iso actually reacted to my first question about the SCC swish did no comment but mudslinged everyone and their mother (as already commented).
Another point in Iso's favor (though minor) is that we know Iso could not have done the NK because of the jail. Probably unimportant but Karn also could not be the target of the NK because of the redirect. DK and Gman read town to me.
Can you guys unvote untill we hear from everyone? Casting votes at mylo until we finish discussion is anti-town and very easy to make us lose on the spot.
@mod when it's the deadline and can you increase it? The forums went away for a day and this weekend is the prerelease weekend so most of the playerbase will be away.
No. I'm disagreeing with you thinking that Proph wouldn't put Daytalk in a game where the scum are severely crippled by not being able to coordinate things the way they normally would.
How do you know the scum are severely crippled this game? This is a pretty major slip you know?
That being said I'm not getting scum vibes from you anymore, and swish is far scummier.
Again I think we should no lynch. One of those guys is lying and it's very hard to determine whom. Maybe the best option probably is to no-lynch and pray tomorrow someone more townie get the SCC or FW, need to think more on this.
1 Deathgaze Cockatrice
1 Quag Sickness
1 Altar's Reap
1 Nightwing Shade
1 Dark Favor
1 Diabolic Tutor
1 Mark of the Vampire
1 Child of Night
1 Gnawing Zombie
1 Sanguine Bond
1 Festering Newt
1 Tenacious Dead
1 Corrupt
1 Deadly Recluse
1 Giant Spider
1 Voracious Wurm
2 Brindle Boar
1 Plummet
Artifact
1 Haunted Plate Mail
1 Elixir of Immortality
1 Staff of the Death Magus
1 Mutavault
11 Swamp
6 Forest
Because if swish was gambitting scum, he was hunting for the real SCC owner, and what if no one had CCed him? He would just be lynched as part of the plan himself was now pushing for, and worse still he would NOT have the SSC so he would die alone. This does not make a lick of sense, and Iso made the worst possible play available by CC him. On the other hand, if Iso was scum CC him is just a brilliant game winning gambit.
In the end the whole situation is so complex I have no confidence to lynch either one, I say we no lynch and pray that our NK shed a little light into this mess. Hopefully the jailer and the redirector can make something good.
vote no lynch
EWP: btw if you have a redirect, try to redirect the kill to me for obvious reasons.
@Karn I'm not rereading the full game unless I'm alive in lylo, considering I'm the best player available and have already caught the scumteam, I find this unlikely Swish is probably going to toast me after we lynch him.
GG
Scumteam is Cythare, WH and Swish.
a)WG is not a noob, he knows very well townies should not be voting in lylo.
b)Swish position is much weaker than Iso's, he knows it, everyone knows it. When scum see the painting on the wall they are usually quick to bus to earn some town credit.
c)he instantly determined Iso was the town of them both because of a convoluted reason. Looks like inside info to me.
Another point in Iso's favor (though minor) is that we know Iso could not have done the NK because of the jail. Probably unimportant but Karn also could not be the target of the NK because of the redirect. DK and Gman read town to me.
That being said I'm not getting scum vibes from you anymore, and swish is far scummier.
Again I think we should no lynch. One of those guys is lying and it's very hard to determine whom. Maybe the best option probably is to no-lynch and pray tomorrow someone more townie get the SCC or FW, need to think more on this.
No. Also we are screwed, this is a nightmare scenario, I have no idea who's lying but certainly one and just one of Iso/Swish is scum.