hi, wtwlf123, our playgroup is following your decklist and here is one of my member of the playgroup thoughts.
'''
I wonder what you guys think of dice-rolling effects, specifically Comet, Stellar Pup, in the vintage cube. Last week I managed to tinker blight steel colossus on the battlefield. Then I got insta killed simply because my opponent casted Comet and rolled 6 and two 4. The dice rolling effect is not about deck building or any magic skills. This is no skill just luck. This is not MAGIC. I wonder if you have the same feeling and therefore, considering removing Comet from the vintage cube.
'''
thanks a lot for your cube list which brings us a lot of fun. Looking forward to your reply.
Hi, wtwlf123. My playgroup recently have played a lot with your CUBE, and a problem troubles one of my friends a lot.
He's very into Reanimator deck / Sneak Attack deck, these kind of unfair deck. But he find it very hard to play against blue deck which has a lot of counterspell. So he is wondering, whether some card that protect the spell will do in CUBE or not, such as "Mana Short", "Veil of Summer", "Slience" or even "Boseiju, Who Shelters All".
Personly I think that may be ""Mana Short"Veil of Summer", "Slience" or even "Boseiju, Who Shelters All" is not good enough for that they are not very wildly useful, but "Mana Short" is a good card, it can be use in unfair deck to protect the key spell and also can be used in midrange deck as a half-time-walk.
So I'm wandering what do you think of thest cards? Can they work in your cube list?
In the end, thanks a lot for your CUBE list, it brings us a lot of fun.
Hi, wtwlf123. My friends and I are beginners of vintage cube, we follow this cube list and having a lot of fun drafting. Thanks al lot for your cube list. However since we have drafted several times, some confusion came to us.
1. Is mono red aggro playable in this cube? It feels like no one wants these 1drop 21 red cards except monkey, or other mono red cards like Kari Zev. We just feel that they were so weak comparing to other cards and the whole mono red aggro is weaker than other archetypes. Or maybe these cards can be played in other archetypes like wr aggro or rg midrange? Do you think these archetypes are as powerful as other archetypes such as sneak attack deck or mono w aggro?
2. Whats these 1 drop zombies for? And many of them are crawler and cannot block. Black aggro or maybe sacrifice deck? But we think that some cards like Knight of the Ebon Legion (M20) is much better aggro card. As for sacrifice deck, it seems that there are not so much sacrifice payoff in this cube list. So we do not know what are these 1 drop zombies for.
It would be great help if anyone can share draft deck that use these cards like 1 drop 21 red cards or 1 drop black zombies. We are really confisued about what decks can these cards fit in.
In the end I want to express the gratitude of my friends and I for your contribution and hard work in this cube list. We do have a lot of fun. Thanks a lot for your time if you can solve our confusion.
'''
I wonder what you guys think of dice-rolling effects, specifically Comet, Stellar Pup, in the vintage cube. Last week I managed to tinker blight steel colossus on the battlefield. Then I got insta killed simply because my opponent casted Comet and rolled 6 and two 4. The dice rolling effect is not about deck building or any magic skills. This is no skill just luck. This is not MAGIC. I wonder if you have the same feeling and therefore, considering removing Comet from the vintage cube.
'''
thanks a lot for your cube list which brings us a lot of fun. Looking forward to your reply.
He's very into Reanimator deck / Sneak Attack deck, these kind of unfair deck. But he find it very hard to play against blue deck which has a lot of counterspell. So he is wondering, whether some card that protect the spell will do in CUBE or not, such as "Mana Short", "Veil of Summer", "Slience" or even "Boseiju, Who Shelters All".
Personly I think that may be ""Mana Short"Veil of Summer", "Slience" or even "Boseiju, Who Shelters All" is not good enough for that they are not very wildly useful, but "Mana Short" is a good card, it can be use in unfair deck to protect the key spell and also can be used in midrange deck as a half-time-walk.
So I'm wandering what do you think of thest cards? Can they work in your cube list?
In the end, thanks a lot for your CUBE list, it brings us a lot of fun.
1. Is mono red aggro playable in this cube? It feels like no one wants these 1drop 21 red cards except monkey, or other mono red cards like Kari Zev. We just feel that they were so weak comparing to other cards and the whole mono red aggro is weaker than other archetypes. Or maybe these cards can be played in other archetypes like wr aggro or rg midrange? Do you think these archetypes are as powerful as other archetypes such as sneak attack deck or mono w aggro?
2. Whats these 1 drop zombies for? And many of them are crawler and cannot block. Black aggro or maybe sacrifice deck? But we think that some cards like Knight of the Ebon Legion (M20) is much better aggro card. As for sacrifice deck, it seems that there are not so much sacrifice payoff in this cube list. So we do not know what are these 1 drop zombies for.
It would be great help if anyone can share draft deck that use these cards like 1 drop 21 red cards or 1 drop black zombies. We are really confisued about what decks can these cards fit in.
In the end I want to express the gratitude of my friends and I for your contribution and hard work in this cube list. We do have a lot of fun. Thanks a lot for your time if you can solve our confusion.