2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on The Tiniest Hunt - game over - witches win
    Quote from fulcrum »
    Quote from Umami »
    Quote from fulcrum »
    Quote from Umami »
    Quote from fulcrum »

    If you were already between me and Az as scum, why was your bait designed to tell you the exact thing you were already thinking. Also, weren't you literally just saying you thought Tubba might be scum. Is that a new read you just got Today or overNight?

    Also, if you're certain Ter was scum, why exactly do you think I hammered her when I could have hammered Az?


    I kind of mapped out the Tubba read in the context of what happened last night already

    I'm obviously not 100% certain or I wouldn't ask GD to claim. I can see a really random scenario where town Ter didn't realize the danger of doing a random assassin shot that launched scum hunter and decided to angel protect someone other than Osi b/c salt, which then knocked out Osi and attempted to knock outTubba. But again, why would Tubba be the target? It's just the most logical answer that Ter is scum in the context of what happneed last night. I 100% think you would hammer your partner and make a big production out of it to get future mislynch targets if you were scum

    Hummm.

    Fair enough, to the first point. I don't get /why/ you think Tubba being shot by hunter!Osie would make him scum, but whatever.

    If you're not 100% certain, then why did you vote?


    I mean, it's day 2, I'm used to voting and moving my vote around

    No, I think the best reason for assassin scum Terr to waste her shot on Azrael is that she wasn't actually the assassing, she was actually the BOD and scum felt forced to paint her as assassin so they could get the extra life when she died and later claim survivalist if they needed to. His hesitation to claim made me worried it's that scenario in which case why isn't town survivalist just claiming

    How would they ever fake claim survivalist down the line without being contested by the real survivalist?


    role kill survivalist. Terr said she was looking for GD with Azrael, but if she was really scum and scum didn't have survivalist, that's the role they would be hunting for
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Tiniest Hunt - game over - witches win
    Quote from Slothful »
    Quote from Umami »
    Quote from Slothful »
    @font Why is Az not GD?
    Ter's conf-role ticks Umami's softing downwards.

    @Ter exactly what role did you guess for Az? I'm weighting the pros and cons of you revealing this, and it's honestly not a huge risk right now. Go.


    What does that mean? Softing downwards?
    During the mechanics discussion with Font yesterDay you were overtly discussing and hinting (imo) that you were the assassin. As of eoD1, the Assassin is Ter, or Ter's partner.
    The fact that you were big on it makes it look worse on you due to the possible connection.


    How was I suggesting I was the Assassin?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Tiniest Hunt - game over - witches win
    Quote from Umami »
    Quote from fulcrum »
    Quote from Umami »
    Quote from fulcrum »
    Quote from Umami »


    No, I was between Azrael and you as scum. I don't think Sloth is scum...

    If you were already between me and Az as scum, why was your bait designed to tell you the exact thing you were already thinking. Also, weren't you literally just saying you thought Tubba might be scum. Is that a new read you just got Today or overNight?

    Also, if you're certain Ter was scum, why exactly do you think I hammered her when I could have hammered Az?


    I kind of mapped out the Tubba read in the context of what happened last night already

    I'm obviously not 100% certain or I wouldn't ask GD to claim. I can see a really random scenario where town Ter didn't realize the danger of doing a random assassin shot that launched scum hunter and decided to angel protect someone other than Osi b/c salt, which then knocked out Osi and attempted to knock outTubba. But again, why would Tubba be the target? It's just the most logical answer that Ter is scum in the context of what happneed last night. I 100% think you would hammer your partner and make a big production out of it to get future mislynch targets if you were scum

    Hummm.

    Fair enough, to the first point. I don't get /why/ you think Tubba being shot by hunter!Osie would make him scum, but whatever.

    If you're not 100% certain, then why did you vote?


    I mean, it's day 2, I'm used to voting and moving my vote around

    No, I think the best reason for assassin scum Terr to waste her shot on Azrael is that she wasn't actually the assassing, she was actually the BOD and scum felt forced to paint her as assassin so they could get the extra life when she died and later claim survivalist if they needed to. His hesitation to claim made me worried it's that scenario in which case why isn't town survivalist just claiming


    Other reason is already discussed: wanting to either get the extra kill with assassin or trigger the hunter role to pretty much guarantee an extra kill
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Tiniest Hunt - game over - witches win
    *assassin
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Tiniest Hunt - game over - witches win
    Quote from fulcrum »
    Quote from Umami »
    Quote from fulcrum »
    Quote from Umami »
    Quote from fulcrum »

    I don't get how your argument isn't that you were trying to bait scum!me (or sloth, I suppose) into voting town!Azrael to save Ter. Like, that would at least make some sense.


    No, I was between Azrael and you as scum. I don't think Sloth is scum...

    If you were already between me and Az as scum, why was your bait designed to tell you the exact thing you were already thinking. Also, weren't you literally just saying you thought Tubba might be scum. Is that a new read you just got Today or overNight?

    Also, if you're certain Ter was scum, why exactly do you think I hammered her when I could have hammered Az?


    I kind of mapped out the Tubba read in the context of what happened last night already

    I'm obviously not 100% certain or I wouldn't ask GD to claim. I can see a really random scenario where town Ter didn't realize the danger of doing a random assassin shot that launched scum hunter and decided to angel protect someone other than Osi b/c salt, which then knocked out Osi and attempted to knock outTubba. But again, why would Tubba be the target? It's just the most logical answer that Ter is scum in the context of what happneed last night. I 100% think you would hammer your partner and make a big production out of it to get future mislynch targets if you were scum

    Hummm.

    Fair enough, to the first point. I don't get /why/ you think Tubba being shot by hunter!Osie would make him scum, but whatever.

    If you're not 100% certain, then why did you vote?


    I mean, it's day 2, I'm used to voting and moving my vote around

    No, I think the best reason for assassin scum Terr to waste her shot on Azrael is that she wasn't actually the assassing, she was actually the BOD and scum felt forced to paint her as assassin so they could get the extra life when she died and later claim survivalist if they needed to. His hesitation to claim made me worried it's that scenario in which case why isn't town survivalist just claiming
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Tiniest Hunt - game over - witches win
    Quote from Slothful »
    Quote from TerRaine »
    I'm punching you in the throat when distancing is lifted cause you can't possibly think I'm this bad at being scum
    This post haunts me. It feels like Ter was legitimately annoyed at my stupidity.
    But she would also say that to leave her partner in a good spot and have be doubt her...
    Quote from TerRaine »
    Early on ( I’m mobile and going looking for it is a pain In this ass) he said something about scum NKing him so he could play in another game I think it was. Either way asked for the first NK...Struck me as weird and trying to hard so I looked at the roles.

    Gravedigger has action odd nights so n1 he’d have an ability. If I was shooting blind I thought eh maybe this was him trying to like he didn’t care if he died n1 cause it doesn’t effect his role.
    ...I mean, all aside, this is still pretty much a scum claim right? She has to be scum here. She was pretty much wearing a shirt that read "YES I AM SCUM" with this argument?

    Swear to god, Ter, you're infuriating sometimes.


    I'm still kind of hoping that she's town. I feel like we would get along
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Tiniest Hunt - game over - witches win
    Quote from Umami »
    Quote from fulcrum »
    Quote from Umami »
    Quote from fulcrum »
    Quote from Umami »


    Meh, I mean that everyone largely did nothing and kept pushing Ter wasn't exactly reassuring. Either my thing was too obvious and Ter's partner decided there was too much momentum to reverse it or Tubba hopped on board as a last ditch effort. Tubba is objectively the better lynch today, but you're definitely my vote for bussing partner

    I don't get how your argument isn't that you were trying to bait scum!me (or sloth, I suppose) into voting town!Azrael to save Ter. Like, that would at least make some sense.


    No, I was between Azrael and you as scum. I don't think Sloth is scum...

    If you were already between me and Az as scum, why was your bait designed to tell you the exact thing you were already thinking. Also, weren't you literally just saying you thought Tubba might be scum. Is that a new read you just got Today or overNight?

    Also, if you're certain Ter was scum, why exactly do you think I hammered her when I could have hammered Az?


    I kind of mapped out the Tubba read in the context of what happened last night already

    I'm obviously not 100% certain or I wouldn't ask GD to claim. I can see a really random scenario where town Ter didn't realize the danger of doing a random assassin shot that launched scum hunter and decided to angel protect someone other than Osi b/c salt, which then knocked out Osi and attempted to knock outTubba. But again, why would Tubba be the target? It's just the most logical answer that Ter is scum in the context of what happneed last night. I 100% think you would hammer your partner and make a big production out of it to get future mislynch targets if you were scum


    actually hunter doesn't even have to be scum in that scenario, it would make more sense if they weren't. But again, it's random and seems unlikely
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Tiniest Hunt - game over - witches win
    Quote from fulcrum »
    Quote from Umami »
    Quote from fulcrum »
    Quote from Umami »
    Quote from fulcrum »

    Osie is a he.

    Forgive me if I don't believe you trying to get Az lynched and save scum was "bait."


    Meh, I mean that everyone largely did nothing and kept pushing Ter wasn't exactly reassuring. Either my thing was too obvious and Ter's partner decided there was too much momentum to reverse it or Tubba hopped on board as a last ditch effort. Tubba is objectively the better lynch today, but you're definitely my vote for bussing partner

    I don't get how your argument isn't that you were trying to bait scum!me (or sloth, I suppose) into voting town!Azrael to save Ter. Like, that would at least make some sense.


    No, I was between Azrael and you as scum. I don't think Sloth is scum...

    If you were already between me and Az as scum, why was your bait designed to tell you the exact thing you were already thinking. Also, weren't you literally just saying you thought Tubba might be scum. Is that a new read you just got Today or overNight?

    Also, if you're certain Ter was scum, why exactly do you think I hammered her when I could have hammered Az?


    I kind of mapped out the Tubba read in the context of what happened last night already

    I'm obviously not 100% certain or I wouldn't ask GD to claim. I can see a really random scenario where town Ter didn't realize the danger of doing a random assassin shot that launched scum hunter and decided to angel protect someone other than Osi b/c salt, which then knocked out Osi and attempted to knock outTubba. But again, why would Tubba be the target? It's just the most logical answer that Ter is scum in the context of what happneed last night. I 100% think you would hammer your partner and make a big production out of it to get future mislynch targets if you were scum
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Tiniest Hunt - game over - witches win
    Quote from Umami »
    lol, so angry


    not me, in reference to your post about baiting
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Tiniest Hunt - game over - witches win
    lol, so angry
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Tiniest Hunt - game over - witches win
    What do you think of Terr hard core calling out Az for saying he was going to be the NK night 1 or whatever and saying that he must be GD and that's why she targeted him? She could have said the exact same thing about you but she was pretty selective about targeting Az
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Tiniest Hunt - game over - witches win
    Admittedly was not a great test, I didn't get the result I wanted to definitively find a partner, but that doesn't mean I'm going to stop looking...
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Tiniest Hunt - game over - witches win
    Quote from fulcrum »
    Quote from Umami »
    Quote from fulcrum »
    Actually, walk me through this post-justifcation.

    You, a town, decided to defend someone you thought was scum and further scum's wincon in order to see if any scum would jump on you for helping them. Someone you thought was town jumped on you during this, and you decided to keep going, gotta defend that scum until scum decide to push you. Did I get that right? Did you actually believe Azrael was scum during this or was that a read you bull*****ted as part of your bait?


    Oh font, you're getting so fiery, I really don't think I'm going to convince you if you're town and I think you just want to yell at me a bit, but if you're scum kudos on the good push. Much more believable than your "someone's going to NK me night 1" thing

    Condescension will not help you.


    Not condescension, exasperation
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Tiniest Hunt - game over - witches win
    Quote from fulcrum »
    Quote from Umami »
    Quote from fulcrum »
    Quote from Umami »
    For instance, I laid quite a bit of bait standing up for Ter, seeing if anyone would take it and try to flip the vote to me. Osi started to but she was my hardcore townread so that wasn't really helpful. You taking it later and setting up a future push against both Osi and me was interesting though

    Osie is a he.

    Forgive me if I don't believe you trying to get Az lynched and save scum was "bait."


    Meh, I mean that everyone largely did nothing and kept pushing Ter wasn't exactly reassuring. Either my thing was too obvious and Ter's partner decided there was too much momentum to reverse it or Tubba hopped on board as a last ditch effort. Tubba is objectively the better lynch today, but you're definitely my vote for bussing partner

    I don't get how your argument isn't that you were trying to bait scum!me (or sloth, I suppose) into voting town!Azrael to save Ter. Like, that would at least make some sense.


    No, I was between Azrael and you as scum. I don't think Sloth is scum...
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on The Tiniest Hunt - game over - witches win
    Yeah, I believed that Azrael was lurker scum, but feeling less like this today. Believed in Osi's Az/Ter team which is part of why I didn't think I was getting momentum and, yeah, if choosing between a scum pair, always believe in lynching someone giving zero info
    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.