2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Town win - Happily Ever After
    I have the most reasons to vote here all 3 of the top wagons are good atm though based off current content. DK and JT are too low content to be valid trains just yet imo.

    vote : CropCircles42
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Town win - Happily Ever After
    If I was going to vote someone atm it would be CC because his posts and stance on ZDS and how it changed are just not making sense to me. His responses to ZDS after his weird as hell vote also match more with the over defensiveness that I was referring to eariler unlike Highroller who looks like he is really scum hunting in his responses. CC looks scared and lost and just doing simple replies like a deer in the headlights. ZDS comes out way ahead in their exchange and considering how much I push ZDS early most games that takes some doing.

    Prop is also a concern to me for the reasons just given so want others thoughts on him.

    I would also not hate a vote on JT his posts are adding nothing to this game, but this also means I have nothing really to scum read him on either.

    I'm good with Grape his posts are helpful at least and showing his thoughts.

    ZDS is in my town pile because of how much better he came off compared to CC if CC flips town I review him. possible they is bussing happening though because both are in bad spots now I think about it their engangement with each other just feels off to a degree.

    Axel can be town because being proactive and I like his posts.

    I like how Silver is sharing my paranoia in Prop and is pushing it still and has good engagnments in thread I think he would be in my top 3 town with Vaimes and Highroller.

    Rod is still town to me, even for the dumb reason I don't think he plays this way as scum, but like always I just keep Rod to the side and see what happens since I have not seen him as scum yet and this feels like normal him.

    Vaimes and Highroller are both town for me for reasons given.

    So much for not deep diving till tomorrow.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Town win - Happily Ever After
    Quote from Axelrod »
    Because, in that instance, they were not actually lurkers. It was a silly thing for him to have said at all. If you were scum, and if your plan was to try and shift attention to lurkers, that is not exactly how/when you would do it.


    Why do it as town though is my issue, I would expect from some people this early, but not him. It just felt like a way to try and engage thread because unsure what to do imo. I think his recent stuff has being a bit better but still feels a bit lacking from what I expect. What is your view?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Town win - Happily Ever After
    Quote from Vaimes »
    Quote from Grapefruit21 »
    I've never been talked about more. I should interpret other people's posts more often. It's good for the ego.

    Anyway the Terry pressure is meh. The Highroller pressure is worse. Silver feels vaguely town. Proph can die, DK can die, Zds can do something else because this current back and forth is going nowhere.
    Sorry to break it to you, but the scumteam is JT/Axel/Jack.


    Expand on this team and also when do you not think I'm scum lol. In general on this site I'm either largely town read or scum read with no middle ground. On that actually the fact ZDS has not took any stance on me based off how recent games together is weird to me, but that is perhaps due to my lack of content and also his war with Highroller.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Town win - Happily Ever After
    I'm changing my view on Highroller after reread he has got better . Partly due to me being a sucker for effort and he is clearly putting in effort atm. I also take back my comment on him being overly defensive after reading his other stuff. If he was doing that his posts would have more panic to them and be less well constructed. This to me feels like a town trying to catch scum who are pushing him with good logic rather then a caught scum that is mad and crushing under pressure. His posts to Grape and just the whole going on with ZDS is proof of this. Its hard for most scum to push back in such a strong way espically with contredictions and the use of perspectives it just has a whole lot of town scum hunting to it which is hard to fake.

    unvote
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Town win - Happily Ever After
    Quote from Prophylaxis »
    Quote from Jackrito »
    Vote Highroller

    I agree with Vaimes points on him in regards to how he is treating Cross just feels so off to me. Rod's gimmick thing he has going on here is weird and a tad annoying, but I don't think he would be this gutsy as people call it if scum. Vaimes is my top town atm.
    Hi Jack.

    1) Expand more on why you think that Vaimes is town? I feel pretty comfortable with him myself but I want to hear exactly why you think he's town.

    2) What do you think of *me* so far? I understand that my early game entrance has been pretty divisive/polarized, but you basically said "you normally play differently than this".

    3) Do you have.... uhh, more substantive thoughts on the game at present? There's a fair amount of content coming in and I find it a little odd you just zero'd in on being a Vaimes stan?

    Quote from Silvercrys »
    vote: Prophylaxis

    This is not related to the "poppin bottles" theory

    Hey Silver, want to talk about this? Is this solely related to the fact that I told Highroller to vote me while having an RVS vote on Vaimes, or is there more?


    My read on Vaimes as town comes from a tone read and also him being pro active my last exp with him as scum he was less proactive then this and a bit on the lazy side in the mountainous game in MC. I'm a sucker for people that put effort in early and he seems to be showing decent eveluaion and willing to listen to others and not just death tunnel. What makes you think he is town?

    You seem a little bit stiff is how I see it, you lack the flair and shining light of townness that I normally see you. Normally you are lock town for me early and then I get paranoid of a deep wolf version of you later. I'm putting this maybe a bit down to rust from not playing for a while so waiting to see if you can play back into that. I know you can also play a scary wolf game as well which is why I'm not committing either way yet to the stiffness.

    I zeroed on that because it appealed to me the most I don't think we have a great lot of content I refuse to get pulled into trying to mod game again got burned too much from doing that lately so not going to comment on the claim nonsense. I have also being crazy busy so not deep dived this game to the extend I like to that will come tomorrow when free. I just have light views on people atm and semi doing Wisp's thing of joining wagons to see what happenes if the case appeals to me.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Town win - Happily Ever After
    Quote from Grapefruit21 »
    Quote from Vaimes »
    Two new posts since I left? Hello, snoozeville.

    @Grape do you expect Highroll to be doing something else as scum rather than try to mimic is townplay?

    Well no but if he's in his town!range I'm going to need something convincing to start suspecting him. As for the points I'm about to quote back to HR, he's not someone where word confetti is a worry for me. Now if we get continued wishy-washy-ness then I might start to worry but ehhhhhh. He's okay-ish. Really everyone is just okay-ish right now. The only thing that is sticking out at all is people jumping on wagons but like trying to break RVS is definitely a thing.

    @Highroller I know you are often a very literal person but in your quote claiming Vaimes didn't mention inconsistency of mindset he said: "Then he changed his mind, which would've been perfectly fine and natural on its own" and "But it wasn't just that. We also got a lot of blah blah blah".

    How confident would you say that you are in this read of them, I want to respect your views if it is a high percentage because last time you did this about someone I disagreed, and tunneled them the entire game so want to listen to you more this time. I should perhaps see this as a mini red flag because you were also scum in that game, so had tmi to support your read on Umani that game, and could be doing it again. That is just being paranoid for the sake of being paranoid though and far too early for that nonsense.

    His point isn't the word confetti alone or the change of mind alone. It's the combination of the two together.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Town win - Happily Ever After
    Quote from Highroller »
    Quote from ZeDorkSlipeur »

    11. Highroller: Too many inconsistencies in his mindset, like Vaimes pointed out.
    Except that isn't what Vaimes pointed out.

    Quote from Vaimes »
    This is what Highroller said, relevant to Proph:
    Quote from Highroller »
    2. Well that merits a finger of suspicion.

    3. Dude, it's not even been 24 hours since the game started. Are you freaking joking?

    The only thing keeping me from voting you right now is that there's a voice in my head telling me, "Hang on, no mafia would be this obvious."

    Then he changed his mind, which would've been perfectly fine and natural on its own:
    Quote from Highroller »
    Yeah, nevermind, I'm going to vote Prophylaxis .

    But it wasn't just that. We also got a lot of blah blah blah:
    Quote from Highroller »
    Yeah, nevermind, I'm going to vote Prophylaxis . I told myself before the game started that I would vote for the first blatantly tryhard post trying to get a town lynched based on logic that made no sense whatsoever, and Prophylaxis' post was one of the biggest examples of this I've ever seen. Gonna stick with my guns.
    None of this was needed. It's just scum tossing out word confetti.

    Side note: Highroller's formatting works for me but no thim because I'm a villager. QED.
    Nowhere does he mention inconsistency of mindset. His vote for me was for alleged "word confetti" when I voted Prophylaxis.

    Vote ZDS

    Quote from Jackrito »
    Vote Highroller

    I agree with Vaimes points on him in regards to how he is treating Cross just feels so off to me. Rod's gimmick thing he has going on here is weird and a tad annoying, but I don't think he would be this gutsy as people call it if scum. Vaimes is my top town atm.

    Quote from Jackrito »
    My reason is same as Vaimes if you scumread me for it push me by all means. Dont do light shade with no intent.
    And then there's Jackrito who is clearly winning the "piggybacking off Vaimes" arms race by making two whole posts that are nothing but that.

    Like, there's bandwagoning, and then there's openly admitting that you're not going to do anything but that.

    Quote from Jackrito »
    I normally trust you early because you have a good early game as either side, its your midgame where you tend to get a bit lazy is where I start to have issues.
    My dude, the thread is less than three pages long. You can read it on your own and post your own thoughts.


    If I agree with someone reasons for scum reading someone of course I'm going to join that wagon if their thoughts also match my own to a small degree and make sense to me. It would be insane not to, we are also only 3 pages in like you say so they is not a major lot of content to work off, and the best way to create more is to create wagons and see how people react to them. You are way over the top defensive for a early wagon, that will likely go nowhere and break up during the day, it is rare for the early wagons to carry though the whole day unless everyone is being lazy.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Town win - Happily Ever After
    Quote from Axelrod »
    Here's a bold stance. Neither Rod's nor Highroller's "claims" are suspicious, nor are they clearing in any way. I still kind of like them.

    Yes, I am that good.

    Proph even mentioning "lurkers" before we're barely a day in is probably not something scum does.


    Just catching so going to reply to anything that catchs my attention, starting with this. Why do you feel that scum would not bring attention to lurkers early is that not just a easy way to scum read someone for no reason and that can lead to a easy mislynch.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Town win - Happily Ever After
    Quote from Rodemy »
    Quote from Jackrito »
    Vote Highroller

    I agree with Vaimes points on him in regards to how he is treating Cross just feels so off to me. Rod's gimmick thing he has going on here is weird and a tad annoying, but I don't think he would be this gutsy as people call it if scum. Vaimes is my top town atm.



    YOUR CALLING OF NAMES HAS ME MIFFED
    AT LEAST I’M NOT POSTING ONLY GIFS

    I’LL SEE YOU AT DAWN, I CHALLENGE YOUR NAME

    what... no death battles? THATS LAME

    IM UNSURE ON YOUR VOTE AND REASON
    IS THIS A VOTE FROM SCUM THIS SEASON?






    My reason is same as Vaimes if you scumread me for it push me by all means. Dont do light shade with no intent.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Town win - Happily Ever After
    Quote from Vaimes »
    Quote from Jackrito »
    Vaimes is my top town atm.
    Since when do you trust me from the getgo? Who are you?


    I normally trust you early because you have a good early game as either side, its your midgame where you tend to get a bit lazy is where I start to have issues.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Town win - Happily Ever After
    Quote from Prophylaxis »
    I agree it's too early - my post was blind conjecture. Again, just something for me to look back on post-game and laugh at, rather than anything substantial.

    I do have some more informed thoughts on the gamestate but I'll give this thread some time to breathe.


    This is something I expect from Wisp in the eod1 not from you at the very start. I agree that low posters tend to be scum in most cases, but I did not think of you the type to scum hunt that way normally you towncore up and work backwards.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia - Town win - Happily Ever After
    Vote Highroller

    I agree with Vaimes points on him in regards to how he is treating Cross just feels so off to me. Rod's gimmick thing he has going on here is weird and a tad annoying, but I don't think he would be this gutsy as people call it if scum. Vaimes is my top town atm.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Snow White Mafia Signups
    /in
    Posted in: Old Sign-ups
  • posted a message on Voldemort's Throne Room Mafia | Game Over - Town Win
    Quote from Trisscar »
    Quote from Jackrito »
    If i could shoot tonight it would be Triss tbh.

    Details as to why would be nice.


    same reasons others have said and why I voted you earlier.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.