2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on I feel like a noob....
    Yes, if he casts the Incinerate during the Declare Blockers step after Snapcaster Mage has been declared as a blocker, the Wurmcoil Engine will stay blocked but deal no damage, so you will gain no life. This has nothing to do with the rules change about combat damage.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings Archives
  • posted a message on Simple Fling Question.
    Yes, actually you can respond by casting Fling and sacrificing the creature as part of the cost. This will cause the Go for the Throat to fizzle.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings Archives
  • posted a message on Timing.
    If you want to keep the card exiled with Mesmeric Fiend, you have to sacrifice it while its exile trigger is on the stack.

    So you cast Mesmeric Fiend, it enters the battlefield and its exile ability triggers. In response to the trigger (while it is still on the stack), you sacrifice it. Now its leaves play ability triggers. The stack looks like this:

    Top
    Leaves play ability
    Exile ability
    Bottom

    The leaves play ability resolves, doing nothing, and then the exile ability resolves, exiling the creature you wanted to exile.

    The same is true for Oblivion Ring: you have to bounce it in response to its ETB ability.

    If you want to use Sundial of the Infinite, you have to wait until the Mesmeric Fiend or the Oblivion Ring leaves play, and then respond to the leaves play ability by ending the turn.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings Archives
  • posted a message on What is the point of card drawing spells?
    I just have one thing to say: Ancestral Recall is the best Magic card ever printed.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on Combat Damage Step and Priority/Stack
    Hopefully this will clear things up for you:

    Any time something is on the stack, both players must pass priority in succession in order for it to resolve. So you can respond to Bitterheart Witch's trigger by removing your opponent's only curse from his library. The triggered ability will still resolve, however, allowing him to search his library (finding nothing) and shuffle it.

    Combat damage does not go on the stack, so you cannot respond to damage being dealt. But abilities that trigger after damage is dealt can be responded to, because they do use the stack.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings Archives
  • posted a message on Refusal to play powerful cards?
    As long as you can agree on which cards are allowed to play with, there's nothing wrong with restricting the list of allowed cards for casual play. Wizards is going to make mistakes from time to time and that's just the nature of the business, and I can certainly understand why you would want to "ban" a card. But as has been pointed out, you don't have to buy their cards or play with them if you don't like what they're doing with the game.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on Does anyone else hate self mill in ISD?
    Self mill is very good if you're playing a deck that uses a lot of the creatures that require you to exile creature cards from the graveyard in order to play them. Armored Skaab is fine because it's a decent creature without the milling ability but it's really good when you're trying to fill up the graveyard with dudes. I wouldn't play a card if all it did was mill because there are better choices, but see Deranged Assistant for a good self-milling card. It's good even if you're not trying to mill yourself because it gives you the ability to ramp in blue.
    Posted in: Limited Archives
  • posted a message on Mimic Vat question
    Assuming you both want to imprint it, it depends on whose turn it is. The Mimic Vat triggers will be placed on the stack in APNAP order (active player/non-active player). So if it is your opponent's turn, his trigger will go on first and then yours. Yours will resolve first, as it is on top of the stack. So if it is his turn, you will imprint the creature and his trigger will do nothing. If it is your turn, then he will imprint the creature and your trigger will do nothing. Note that imprinting a creature on Mimic Vat is a "may" ability, so if the player with the first trigger passes on the opportunity, the second player will have a chance.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings Archives
  • posted a message on What's your "infinite" card (get as many as you can)?
    I have almost 100 copies of Artisan of Kozilek.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on Past In Flames + Fireblast
    Quote from landmage
    Past in FlamesFireblast

    Can I flashback fireblast after casting past in flames by sacrificing mountains?


    No, you can't. The Flashback cost of Fireblast will be equal to its mana cost, which is 4RR. This means you can cast the spell from your graveyard by paying 4RR. You can't do it any other way because Flashback gives the card an alternate casting cost and you must pay that cost in order to cast the spell from your graveyard.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings Archives
  • posted a message on Which Cards are Following You?
    I've only played in 5 Innistrad Limited events and I already have a playset of Gavony Township (I only get cards from playing FNM).
    Posted in: Limited Archives
  • posted a message on Logical inconsistency between the Judeo-Christian God, and the existence of evil?
    We (Christians) implicitly accept that God is good. Others argue that we can't prove it, but we don't have to prove it. In mathematics, certain truths are accepted as axiomatic and therefore fundamental. In mathematics, you must begin with something which is understood implicitly before you attempt to prove anything. It is the same with all logical arguments. How is it that we can determine whether an argument is logically sound? If we didn't understand logic implicitly, we wouldn't be able to make such a determination. Implicit in all the atheist arguments is the fundamental belief that God does not exist so all of their arguments are predicated on that. However, who is right?
    Posted in: Religion
  • posted a message on Censorship (not MTGS)
    Censorship and free speech are antithetical. One is part of our constitution, the other is not, and that's the way it should be. I saw Terminator 2 for the first time when I was 9 years old and it didn't traumatize me. I was reading adult literature when I was in middle school and I wish I hadn't been exposed to it at that point because I wasn't mature enough to understand it but I don't necessarily think that I should be prevented from reading it by anyone except my parents. It is the parents' responsibility to ensure the development of their children and I am tired of other people trying to step in and treat us like we're all children and tell us what we can and cannot say.
    Posted in: Debate
  • posted a message on Interesting Limited Combos: Innistrad Edition
    Quote from Profani
    Yesterday, a friend of mine pulled the following combo;

    Angel of Flight Alabaster + Geist of Saint Traft.

    And proceeded to attack for 8 - 4 - 8 for the win over all of the opposing blockers.


    These two cards interact well together. It's unfortunate that you can't attack with the Geist on the turn the Angel brings it back from the graveyard. I actually had this combo and my opponent killed my Angel after a sacrifice attack from the Geist, keeping both in the graveyard permanently as I had no way of retrieving them.
    Posted in: Limited Archives
  • posted a message on Illusions + Angelic Destiny / Oblivion Ring
    Quote from apocalypse31
    My question is similar, what if you bounced Angelic Destiny with Venser, the Sojourner or Glimmerpoint Stag. When it reenters the battlefield, it doesn't target, so could it successfully be placed on the dragon?


    Yes, when Angelic Destiny enters the battlefield in either of those cases you may attach it to the Dragon for the reason you stated. You could also move it from some other creature to the Dragon with Glamer Spinners, because that ability doesn't target the Dragon either.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings Archives
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.