I attacked DV because I think he's scum, acting scummy, and even fitting his scum meta with the 'offense is defense' mentality.
You obv. don't know my scum meta. Since Seppel brought it up IN THIS THREAD. Why don't you go back and read? And if I am sooo scummy, why have you not voted me yet? Why are you so happy with a WoD lynch?
Quote from DC »
First paragraph: Classic fence-sitting. Actually, fence-straddling.
Second paragraph: Arguably one of the more ridiculously non-existent defenses I've seen in a long while, and a blatant Seppel barn following on Seppel's equally blatantly wrong accusation of me attacking 'everyone', to boot. No actual defence, merely an unconvincing follow-on.
Can we please lynch this scum already?
Go back and read your post. All you say is that I am acting like scum. Saying so doesn't make it so. Otherwise the world is flat. Your argument here is poor and you have not attacked me for anything other than "acting" scummy. You have yet to vote. And you have lurked all game(I know you have been sick but you lurked before that). I see you trying to attack a lot of players that I have very good reads on and I see you not being protown at all. And on top of all that you pick two players that are on my watch list and call them town. With no motivation to do so at all and no reasoning behind it at all either. I have also never seen you get so defensive over a couple of little posts, and you are literally on a Blitzkrieg style attack, which is really bad because well it doesn't have much merit. So, DC build a case on me, build a case on someone else, vote sometime, but please don't just attack me and think that this is protown.
Just some comments. WoD has completely dropped off the map with half of our player list. Yeah go us! I think we need to lynch WoD his complete inattentiveness to know whether or not someone he RB'd was alive or dead during the next day makes me wonder if he really has a roleblock. It just doesn't seem townie. Unvote Unvote Vote WoD Vote WoD
Umm... see below. I explain what I meant by that statement. I use gut as a suppliment alongside actual scum tells. All of my votes contain a certain amount of gut. I just don't usually go around saying that it is a part of my vote.
Also I fail to see how I barned kpaca's post there considering the only thing that we say the same in them is that it is a bad post and we both mention he calls out lurkers. Could you please expand on why you think this is barning.
See this is my point. You have a "gut" read on Az, but you didn't bring it up. Then you say that it is in addition to Az being scummy, yet fail to explain how he is acting scummy. Since the only thing I have seen is that he is swapped his view on things. And then to top it all off you vote jordman who is admittedly scummy, yet if your gut is so strong on AZ why do you change your vote?
Quote from Technolink »
@lurkers POST! I'm still waiting for your answers. Especially MMOD.
Maybe you could give us your opinion on jordman or Az.... Or someone other than a chronic lurker.
@Jordman, you see the problem I have with you saying that you change your mind a lot which you said multiple times in your last post is that the case against Az was based on him changing his mind.
Player Awards
Best Town Performance (Individual)
Best Mafia Performance (Individual)
Best SK Performance (Individual)
Best Non-SK Neutral Performance (Individual) DC, VR Salvation.
Best Town Performance (Group)
Best Mafia Performance (Group)
Worst Town Performance (Group) Amistarian Mafia, we lost pretty badly here, never got a single lynch right and AE's excessive vigging cost us.
Worst Mafia Performance (Group)
Best (False?) Role Claim (Individual)
Funniest (False?) Role Claim (Individual)
Best Town Player
Best Mafia Player
Best Overall Player
Most Entertaining Player
Best Newcomer, CED
Mod Awards
Best Game Design
Most Creative
Best Flavor
Most Interesting Role
Best Host
1. You basically fold under pressure from kpaca and others on the basis that Az makes too much sense after you voted him and barning my reasoning that Az doesn't make sense...
2. You call out all lurkers. Deflecting much?
3. Um... yeah this seems like another over reaction. You only have two votes... well soon to be three votes.
Unvote Azreal
Vote jordman
This is an awful post. You just repeated what kpaca said.
He had a fairly strong view against claiming and in a few posts he's suddenly for it. Maybe he's realised that claiming does indeed benefit scum? Which if he is scum explains the why of him changing his mind.
See, that's my point. This isn't a scum tell it is a maybe tell or a null tell. I can give you countless scenarios in which Az is town in this situation too. Does that mean he is town? No. Does that mean he is scum? No. This is a very poor point against him and does not show any indication too alignment.
@ Guardman That's funny that you say that you are voting on gut. Because when you vote Az you say this,
Quote from Guardman »
Really Az seems to be trying to plainsight lurk by not really addressing issues at hand and giving a lot of contentless posts, and I don't like the way he just votes Dancing Mad without even mentioning him previously.
Vote Azrael
MMM, anything about gut here? No, I think not. Unvote Vote Guardman
is using evidence from other game non permissable? And if people are saying that newbness is not an adequate shield why is proness anybetter?
Using evidence from other games is permissible, but ongoing games is discouraged. Because we can't analyze all that is going on in the game since we don't know all the roles.
Also, Johm I Demand(not ask demand) that you explain how changing your mind is a scum tell since you have not defended this awful attack.
Wait desCoures not attacking everybody isn't normal?
Also @ EVERYONE: What are your thoughts on WoD, especially in light of his inconsistent explanation on his role block.
Finally Mod can we get a vote count?
This is either a bus of a scum buddy, a scum looking for a wagon or a townie asking about someone who they think is scummy. I am inclined to believe one of the first two, but I need to think about whether I believe WOD first.
@ DC Ok, go after me then, and everyone else you just attacked because it is so obvious that if you attack everyone in the game then you must be right some of the time. Ok, let me do this Everyone in this game is anti town. There I am now right about 20-30% of the time.
Someone vig kpaca. Zionite is very obv. town to me. Kay Thx Bye.
I mean this doesn't even address the point where he is not paying attention to the thread.
You obv. don't know my scum meta. Since Seppel brought it up IN THIS THREAD. Why don't you go back and read? And if I am sooo scummy, why have you not voted me yet? Why are you so happy with a WoD lynch?
Go back and read your post. All you say is that I am acting like scum. Saying so doesn't make it so. Otherwise the world is flat. Your argument here is poor and you have not attacked me for anything other than "acting" scummy. You have yet to vote. And you have lurked all game(I know you have been sick but you lurked before that). I see you trying to attack a lot of players that I have very good reads on and I see you not being protown at all. And on top of all that you pick two players that are on my watch list and call them town. With no motivation to do so at all and no reasoning behind it at all either. I have also never seen you get so defensive over a couple of little posts, and you are literally on a Blitzkrieg style attack, which is really bad because well it doesn't have much merit. So, DC build a case on me, build a case on someone else, vote sometime, but please don't just attack me and think that this is protown.
His name and flavor?
Can we please lynch him?
See this is my point. You have a "gut" read on Az, but you didn't bring it up. Then you say that it is in addition to Az being scummy, yet fail to explain how he is acting scummy. Since the only thing I have seen is that he is swapped his view on things. And then to top it all off you vote jordman who is admittedly scummy, yet if your gut is so strong on AZ why do you change your vote?
Maybe you could give us your opinion on jordman or Az.... Or someone other than a chronic lurker.
@Jordman, you see the problem I have with you saying that you change your mind a lot which you said multiple times in your last post is that the case against Az was based on him changing his mind.
Yeah sorry, I was thinking of Tales fixed to represent that AE was vig.
Best Town Performance (Individual)
Best Mafia Performance (Individual)
Best SK Performance (Individual)
Best Non-SK Neutral Performance (Individual) DC, VR Salvation.
Best Town Performance (Group)
Best Mafia Performance (Group)
Worst Town Performance (Group) Amistarian Mafia, we lost pretty badly here, never got a single lynch right and AE's excessive vigging cost us.
Worst Mafia Performance (Group)
Best (False?) Role Claim (Individual)
Funniest (False?) Role Claim (Individual)
Best Town Player
Best Mafia Player
Best Overall Player
Most Entertaining Player
Best Newcomer, CED
Mod Awards
Best Game Design
Most Creative
Best Flavor
Most Interesting Role
Best Host
This is an awful post. You just repeated what kpaca said.
@ Guardman That's funny that you say that you are voting on gut. Because when you vote Az you say this,
MMM, anything about gut here? No, I think not. Unvote Vote Guardman
Also, Johm I Demand(not ask demand) that you explain how changing your mind is a scum tell since you have not defended this awful attack.
This is either a bus of a scum buddy, a scum looking for a wagon or a townie asking about someone who they think is scummy. I am inclined to believe one of the first two, but I need to think about whether I believe WOD first.
@ DC Ok, go after me then, and everyone else you just attacked because it is so obvious that if you attack everyone in the game then you must be right some of the time. Ok, let me do this Everyone in this game is anti town. There I am now right about 20-30% of the time.