MTG Salvation

Why are cards like Hullbreacher and Opposition Agent legal in commander?

What about Fallen Empires and Homelands cards with different art?

They aren't alternate to one main card, just a series of four different arts at the same rarity.

Card is called Guildless Commons.

Card is Uncommon.

I'm glad people are wisening up to this hugely overrated dud quite quickly.

So you get to recast it with Lurrus or Muldrotha. So what? You're commander is already in play and the lotus doesn't do anything.

Decks that it's good in like Urza or Jhoira already have a ton of artifacts to work with and this doesn't enable anything that they can't already do.

I don't think its that good and is just a hype card that will be forgotten a week or so after the set comes out. Everything it does can already be achieved with better existing cards.

If it doesn't have Phil Foglio art and has more than a single keyword for game text then it just isn't Ramirez DiPietro.

Why is everybody upset now, The Walking Dead has been in Magic since the early nineties.

Because banned as companion was 'too complex' which is a complete underestimation of the intelligence of the average player.

The actually offensive thing about Secret Lairs is that they never turn up.

Apparently it's licensed cards in black border, judging by the reaction.

I kinda hope Zilortha is Godzilla. Like he went there and that's what the Ikorians call him. It's implied Vivien does call on him to fight Obosh in the trailer.

Quote from soramaro »

Not sure if you're being obtuse on purpose.

These cards are mechanically unique and come in a black border, which makes them perfectly legal in EDH (this is especially relevant because they're all legendary creatures). How would you like your opponent playing with a My Little Pony card as their legal, completely legitimate commander?

That would be fine to me.

In fact I don't see how that is a problem for a casual format.

I know the cEDH hijack is real but jeez. Just let someone use a card if they want to.

I do have a Rodan led commander deck.

I don't understand why people are so angry about some cards for a non-essential luxury product.

If you want them just buy them.

Kulrath Knight

Woodfall Primus

People don't want narrative in games, they just want power.

I agree cEDH ruins everything.

To the surprise of no one one new guy who turned up for a week or two who had the cEDH mindset ended up getting himself banned after arguing with the store manager. Not a related matter but it's reflective of the overall personality.

I know what the c really stands for and it's not something pleasant I can say on the forums.