2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on What's Up Doc? - Game Over: It Was Apparently Town Season
    I think you guys are better than that. I don't know Tom's alignment. You asked specifically WHY I didn't vote him. Which is, that the risk isn't worth the reward. And the risk is, he's town.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on What's Up Doc? - Game Over: It Was Apparently Town Season
    Quote from shadowlancerx »
    You should go peruse some micros in the past couple years, fast hammers are somewhat more common and come from both alignments accidentally (or on purpose).
    that's probably good advice. This is my first micro.
    Quote from shadowlancerx »

    You’re more worried about first experiences than a quick lynch?
    I'll clarify, because I'm not sure that statement reflects what I was saying. I was more concerned that a newish town played would see 3 votes, and not think through hammering Tom (which would lead to scum killing a town player overnight, and then we'd lynch the hammering vote, and then scum kills another town, and then they control the vote and we lose). Either not realizing it was a hammer, or thinking that Rod's/Your vote was a serious/genuine attempt at finding and killing scum. So that's was my biggest reason for not specifically voting Tom then, "10 posts in" as you put it.

    I'm less concerned with quick lynches. My personality is usually more shoot from the hip, trust my instincts, than it is to over-analyze. So I don't usually mind if a lynch comes about quickly, so long as all the votes are real, and all the people are reasonably satisfied with that vote.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on What's Up Doc? - Game Over: It Was Apparently Town Season
    Well, I figured he's got a 33% chance of being scum, just randomly. And then if he IS town, who would hammer except scum? right? So we're doing a 1 for 1.

    My only hesitation was, that I don't know roughly 3/4ths of the game, and I didn't want somebody's first mafia experience ever to be like "oh, I'll do what everyone else is doing, and accidentally cause town to lose day 2.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on What's Up Doc? - Game Over: It Was Apparently Town Season
    Quote from shadowlancerx »
    Sadly in a micro that’s all too possible. Less so with you pointing it out, but I’ve seen weirder. Also less possible if you’re scum.
    I saw this last night. What's are your thoughts about Tom pointing it out? I don't see any opinions here, just information (and information we kinda already knew).

    @Tom I seriously considered putting you at L-1 just for being so aware of votes this early. Eventually I decided not to. Why should/shouldn't I?

    @Mifare Is a short/small game a good thing or a bad thing?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on What's Up Doc? - Game Over: It Was Apparently Town Season
    Oooo so many new faces for me, exciting times.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Cantripmancer's Micro-a-Thon 2: Electric Microbrew [6/7]
    Cantrip, did you see that Grape did an /out? I think you're counting him in the 7
    Posted in: Old Sign-ups
  • posted a message on Cantripmancer's Micro-a-Thon 2: Electric Microbrew [6/7]
    /in for whichever, would prefer "What's Up, Doc?".
    Posted in: Old Sign-ups
  • posted a message on One Last Job | And the Law Won
    Awesome game to watch. I nailed Shadow and cantrip, but thought last was their partner instead of rhand :). Mostly because last was pushing to keep both him and rhand on missions, and dummy rhand. I'm not sure what you expected to glean from that. Especially later when you got the single fail, and it's like "*****, nothing here really settled that dichotomy".

    Ironically, Cantrip's mission 4 was what won the game. Great job pushing that one through. Although saying he dummied shadow, I was like huh? I'd have loved to see you be like, "not telling muahahahaha",

    I was cheering for you lggnr. Don't give up next time. I think your instincts to be reasonable did you a disservice. But well played for sure.

    Shadow was great, Couple comments were a little greedy. Casting shade on lggnr at the end *probably* wasn't needed and I thought might tip someone off that you needed lggnr dummied to win.




    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Death in the Family - Game Over - A Family in Ruins
    Quote from D_V »
    Quote from M1ndreaver »
    Quote from D_V »

    But the fact remains that I answered MY opinion on this well before you posted your attack on me. Didn't attack you actually. Just put my observations on a reads list. You're the one who went bat*****.
    Additionally, I bring up the balancing issues which NOBODY else does. Most of my thought are independent and I challenge you to show otherwise. You claim I'm repeating others. I'm not. I didn't say ALL your thoughts are repeating others. I said you quoted others, and other experiences to sell your POV instead of before you gave yours. Can you at least agree there?

    Finally, you ignore the fact that ALL of the posts were withing hours of each other I was moving in real time though my thought process. I didn't say I ignored that. Cool story though.

    You did cherry pick and you did lie about the posts. Agree to Disagree I know you cherry picked (NO COLLUSION), because when you made your attack on me (Didn't attack you, you sensitive flower) for being playing remember when I had given a lot of thoughts on my feelings on the whole situation (talk some more about your feelings). So you're just lying. I"m not, but that's okay if you think so. Bye dearie. muah.
    </blockquote>

    I didn't go bat***** on you dude. I said come on my I talked about a lot of other things between then.

    You responded back "No you didn't" and I've shown that I did. You are now claiming that you were just focusing on those posts.

    But you used the hyperbole that HALF my posts were about that, they were not. You attacked me for using these comments in three of my posts. While claiming that it was a majority of my posts, when I said this wasn't true you said and I quote
    Quote from M1ndreaver »
    it's every post from your entrance until my comment. Which ones did I miss?

    That's a ******* LIE.

    It WASN'T every post since until your entrance. In fact I've quoted half a dozen posts that I didn't do that in.
    Yeah this is done. I hope you're happy with yourself. I'm not speaking to you for the rest of this game. You managed to language lawyer me to death. Managed to twist every word into a "he's lying!".

    Maybe I messed up the quotes. My question to you, that you ******* ignored, is because it doesn't MATTER when you said any of those quotes. and I'm sure that's just another "He lied!" quote, so don't even bother. My point was that you were relying on those quotes, and I wasn't showing progression in my thoughts. I was showing why I thought as I did about you.

    Mistakes aren't lies BTW. Not everything is some malicious attack. So you can **** off with that. Hope you win lots of games with that logic.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Death in the Family - Game Over - A Family in Ruins
    Quote from tomsloger »

    I believe (and your posts show) that you didnt care about grape at all you just joined a popular wagon.
    just shortening the post. not CHERRY PICKING. I wanted pressure on Grape at that time, and yeah, I thought he could be scum based on that language tell. If you thought I was scum, why would I do that?

    It's not as if Grape was sitting on 7 votes and I was #8. I was #3 after Rhand's post. But sure, a vote is a vote. You got me. I voted for the Grape. Now what?

    Gonna answer my other question?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Death in the Family - Game Over - A Family in Ruins
    Quote from D_V »

    But the fact remains that I answered MY opinion on this well before you posted your attack on me. Didn't attack you actually. Just put my observations on a reads list. You're the one who went bat*****.
    Additionally, I bring up the balancing issues which NOBODY else does. Most of my thought are independent and I challenge you to show otherwise. You claim I'm repeating others. I'm not. I didn't say ALL your thoughts are repeating others. I said you quoted others, and other experiences to sell your POV instead of before you gave yours. Can you at least agree there?

    Finally, you ignore the fact that ALL of the posts were withing hours of each other I was moving in real time though my thought process. I didn't say I ignored that. Cool story though.

    You did cherry pick and you did lie about the posts. Agree to Disagree I know you cherry picked (NO COLLUSION), because when you made your attack on me (Didn't attack you, you sensitive flower) for being playing remember when I had given a lot of thoughts on my feelings on the whole situation (talk some more about your feelings). So you're just lying. I"m not, but that's okay if you think so. Bye dearie. muah.
    </blockquote>
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Death in the Family - Game Over - A Family in Ruins
    Quote from D_V »
    I have no idea what happened to that post it worked fine in preview.

    If you go to that post you'll see at the end of it
    The very next post you declare that ETR/Tau is low percent, so shouldn't be figured out. And you move onto Rhand. Without every giving a solid read on Tau or ETR or sharing what YOU think about THIS game.

    This quote. Mindreaver is quoting a post that I made before the other post and claiming that it is the very next post.
    How important is the timing to my argument or yours?

    CHERRY PICKING!
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Death in the Family - Game Over - A Family in Ruins
    Quote from D_V »
    Quote from M1ndreaver »
    Quote from D_V »
    [spoiler][quote from="D_V »" url="/forums/community-forums/mafia/805970-death-in-the-family-day-1-just-the-beginning?comment=534"]At the end of the day its going to come down to you saying "Its the correct to reveal" and I'm going to counter well maybe its the higher percent play, but
    his play isn't anti-town. So, unless you think that the whole scum team has been caught, then he isn't scum. Because for you to think this play has revealed the whole scum team is just a joke to me. And frankly if you think that, I don't respect a word that comes out of your mouth.
    Don't put words in my mouth. I never said I thought he responded with the real scum team. NEVER. I've explicitly said the opposite.

    YOu know what D_V, I'm done with you for a little bit, I'm so frustrated with this whole exchange. I demand you admit that you spent a LOT OF TIME talking abou tthose other games, and that tell me that it's not legit to read you that was is ******* garbage.

    and I thin you should look into your own reading comprehension.
    </blockquote>
    I spent very little time talking about it so I'm not sure what you're own about. I've proven this pretty heavily. You cherry picked the three posts I spent talking about it and ignored a good majority of the rest of the posts. Additionally, the posts that I did also talked about other things as well.

    Furthermore, I didn't claim that you thought that. I'm stating that the only way you can think he is out scum based on this whole debacle is to think that he did out his whole team.

    I don't understand how you think you can misquote me out of context AND out of order in order to paint a narrative to fit your statements and expect me to be anything other than hostile.
    </blockquote>If I'm Mitch McConnell, you're Trump dude. NO COLLUSION. HE'S CHERRY PICKING.

    I didn't pick posts out of order. I showed EXACTLY what my point was. You spend a lot of time discussion those other games, and other peoples opinions on ETR/TAU and not your own. Yeah, I might not have caught all the posts, and I didn't realize that near the end of 574 you actually HAD an original opinion that ETR is town. That wasn't malicious, it was an obvious oversight because you spent most of that post rehashing the same stuff we've seen from everyone else. Oh, what is ETR thinking, what is Tau doing, is it scum or town, blah blah.

    And you know what, if you disagree with somebody, you don't immediately have to be an aggressive dick about it. That might be your default, but it's garbage dude.

    I mean straight up, are you really THIS tilted because I told you that "remember when" was scummy? cause I it was. and you did it in multiple posts.

    CHERRY PICKING
    NO COLLUSION
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Death in the Family - Game Over - A Family in Ruins
    Quote from you »
    Like, I get that we're all on a mission to show our thoughts, but it's just gonna go on and on and on. If GJ doesn't come in with the same block of text, I'll eat my hat.


    ^
    OHH. Sorry. I specifically figured that you'd weigh in on the ETR/Tau thing the exact why D_V has: W/W is *this likely*, W/V is slightly more likely, V/V is x% less likely. Etc etc. I was being more hyperbolic than referring to anything about you personally.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Death in the Family - Game Over - A Family in Ruins
    Quote from D_V »
    [spoiler][quote from="D_V »" url="/forums/community-forums/mafia/805970-death-in-the-family-day-1-just-the-beginning?comment=534"]At the end of the day its going to come down to you saying "Its the correct to reveal" and I'm going to counter well maybe its the higher percent play, but
    his play isn't anti-town. So, unless you think that the whole scum team has been caught, then he isn't scum. Because for you to think this play has revealed the whole scum team is just a joke to me. And frankly if you think that, I don't respect a word that comes out of your mouth.
    Don't put words in my mouth. I never said I thought he responded with the real scum team. NEVER. I've explicitly said the opposite.

    YOu know what D_V, I'm done with you for a little bit, I'm so frustrated with this whole exchange. I demand you admit that you spent a LOT OF TIME talking abou tthose other games, and that tell me that it's not legit to read you that was is ******* garbage.

    and I thin you should look into your own reading comprehension.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.