Its also the option that provides the least power to wishes if given a purpose, its also the option that requires no card banned, its also an option that requires no wishboard, its also an option that is the least likely to cause a big price spike, its already had a precedent which means using those rules is not that out there really. Its literally the safest option if change were to occur.
It can be argued the logistics of it, like what caused the social contract mess of an argument in the first place, but it still remains the better method purposed. Also that the only counter arguments to it are literally: Citing rules 0 and 13.
Also Blue are you really going down this route? Because Karn, the Great Creator is a modern day wish spell, just like Coax from the Blind Eternities. They are wish spells that also retrieve from exile. That what they are doing is the modern equivalent of the very same function prior to magic 2010 like if a spell was RFG with swords to plowshares. Fancy that. Its almost like your argument about me not knowing how wishes worked was a hugely false statement in a poor man's attempt to discredit me.
Also on the Shahrazad thing, don't talk about unrelated stuff that no bearing on the discussion, simple as that. Keep it on subject Blue or don't post it at all. If Blue wants to defend his unrelated topic to make it have relevance, they are contributing less than I was.
In fact both MHRBlue and Kamino_Taka have contributed very little in this revived discussion aside from thanking each other as if that gives them credibility. The only ones who seem to be actually doing the legwork for this discussion are Ava, ForgottenOne, and CrimsonWings_3689. Which is two in favor of wishes, one against wishes. I don't include myself as I will admit that I mostly just been the peanut gallery for this discussion.
1
A person who searches their library slowly for a card is not much better than person who slowly decides what card outside the game they want to put into their hand. A person who slowly calculates and recalculates the size of their board of their creatures and who they can go after isn't much better either. A person who goes through an infinite or near-infinite combo but takes a long time isn't much better either. A person who slowly decides if they let a spell resolve even if they couldn't actually respond to it anyway isn't much better either.
3
Draw spell? I assume your not referring to the land or just its activated ability in general.
T1: Forest
T2: Forest, Magus
T3: Draw, tap Magus to draw, play up to 2 cards from hand.
T4: Draw, tap magus to draw, play up to 2 cards from hand.
You can still play your hand, you just have to pace yourself.
A toughness of 1 would have been a better argument than being a creature.
Llanowar is fairly mediocre if you aren't capitalizing on the elf or druid tribal if that is what you meant by a "good deck". At best case scenario, when outside of those themes, its a 1/1 that might get a boost from an overrun-based effect.
Which is a different style of card draw and is more comparable to a brainstorm that lets you pay life to not put cards back on top of the library. Unless you have the lifegain to back it up for a +2, your effectively getting a +0 in net value most of the time; +1 if you actually need to hold onto something in hand but not likely to happen every turn.
From this thread, quite the contrary if its been brought up.
This seems quite random for a statement like you ran out of ammunition.
False statement.
Mystic Snake sees plenty of play, I don't know why you would think the opposite.
1
Rofellos, Llanowar Emissary: Simply too easy to abuse since Rofellos's strength is based on mana ramping and tossing down creatures sooner than others. Rofellos has been unbanned before but has proven to be still problematic even when allowed to be just in the ninety-nine.
Braids, Cabal Minion: Just because its a lesser evil in stax doesn't mean its safe. Also being mono color is not really that much of a weakness if its within the three horsemen that is BUG. As mono being a weakness only applies to R and W as they aren't very suited to this format and only recent years have gained some power thanks to more recent sets.
Erayo, Soratami Ascendant: See Braids.
Coalition Victory: One of the easiest to fulfill win conditions. Your commander fulfills 25% of the win condition. The other 25% requirement is having each basic land type which can be performed in a number of ways like a scapeshift or a prismatic omen. Next 25% is just get 8 mana (3 colorless, 1 of each color). Final 25% is nobody has an instant speed answer.
1
As what WotC is basically doing is: Instead of trying to climb a mountain, climb a wall first.
1
Legendary Creature - Elf Mystic Nomad (R)
Auras that target a Nomad or Mystic creature you control cost 2 less to cast.
Auras enchanting creatures you control have totem armor.
Whenever an Aura would enter your graveyard from anywhere, you may draw a card. If you do, discard a card.
1/1
Artwork: https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/gwent/images/8/82/Elven_Scout.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20171209011353
1
1) Include all rules associated with commander normally.
2) No deck, commander included, may have any enchantments, artifacts, planeswalkers or nonbasic lands.
3) Activated abilities can only be activated before attackers are declared.
4) Instants are always played at sorcery speed except for counterspells and "only during the declare attackers step and only if you've been attacked this step."
I just personally felt like sharing is all.
1
1
2
2