Player A's turn.
Player A activates Triskelion's ability to deal damage (1 damage at a time before resolve)
Player B casts Path to exile after first 1 damage of Triskelion, then Player B's response was Cloudshift.
As a result, Cloudshift resolved, Triskelion returns battlefield with 3 +1/+1 counters on it, Path is countered, and triskelion deals 3 damage to creature or player. Can you explain it with rulings?
Player A have Faerie Miscreant, Mistbind Clique on his battlefield. Mistbind already championed Spellstutter Sprite.
Here is the scenario:
1) Player B casts a spell with 2 CMC.
2) Player A responses by casting cloudshift that targets Mistbind.
Here is the result:
Mistbind leaves the battlefield, Spellstutter returns, B's spell is countered. Then Mistbind returns, cahmpions the Spellsttuter or Miscreant and B's all lands tapped.
What if the other way around?
Player A casts Path, PLayer B attempt to respons with sacrficing Hauler to deal 2 damages.
Hauler's activated ability resolves first, then exile is countered, am I right?
- Player A's turn, Player A activates ability of Ember Hauler to deal 2 damage.
- Player B tries to respond it by casting Path to exile to Hauler.
Can Hauler deal 2 damage even after Path to Exile resolves?
- Player A casts Stonehorn Dignitary
- After triggered ability went onto stack, Player B casts Path to exile to Dignitary.
Q: Will player B skip his next combat phase?
Q2: If player A casts cloudshift to Dignitary while Path is on the stack, what's gonna happen? Path fizzles and then player B skips his next two combat phases?
My opponent played Angel of Sanctions and targeted my Loxodon Smiter. When he cast that, I played Dromoka's Command, chose +1 +1 to Loxodon and let it fight with Angel of Sanctions.
Can Dromoka's Command interrupt Angel of Sanctions' triggered ability?
We are confused when we tried to resolve this, so we would be happy if you could explain us what happens in this situation?
We will be happy if you could help us with the following case:
Let's assume that I have 3 dragons on my side and dragon tempest. On my turn, I cast a new dragon spell which enables me to deal 4 damage to my opponent or a creature that he controls. After I cast the dragon I wanted to assign the damage to one of his creatures. Then my opponent played brave the elements and give all his creatures protection from red.
So, what happens now?
One theory is: Brave the elements resolves first, so I would not be able to assign damage to his creatures so I have to assign damage to player directly.
Other theory is: Because of protection from red, the damage assigned to his creature would do no harm to it and the opponent player also does not dealt any damage.
We would be really very happy if you could help us for this case. We are really confused
Player A activates Triskelion's ability to deal damage (1 damage at a time before resolve)
Player B casts Path to exile after first 1 damage of Triskelion, then Player B's response was Cloudshift.
As a result, Cloudshift resolved, Triskelion returns battlefield with 3 +1/+1 counters on it, Path is countered, and triskelion deals 3 damage to creature or player. Can you explain it with rulings?
Thank you
Can Lavinia of the tenth detain permanents with hexproof?
Here is the scenario:
1) Player B casts a spell with 2 CMC.
2) Player A responses by casting cloudshift that targets Mistbind.
Here is the result:
Mistbind leaves the battlefield, Spellstutter returns, B's spell is countered. Then Mistbind returns, cahmpions the Spellsttuter or Miscreant and B's all lands tapped.
Am I right?
What if the other way around?
Player A casts Path, PLayer B attempt to respons with sacrficing Hauler to deal 2 damages.
Hauler's activated ability resolves first, then exile is countered, am I right?
- Player B tries to respond it by casting Path to exile to Hauler.
Can Hauler deal 2 damage even after Path to Exile resolves?
http://www.mtgsalvation.com/forums/magic-fundamentals/magic-rulings/785910-angel-of-sanctions-vs-dromokas-command#c4
In this case it doesn't seem that ETB triggered ability independent of the source. Why, what is the difference?
- Player A casts Stonehorn Dignitary
- After triggered ability went onto stack, Player B casts Path to exile to Dignitary.
Q: Will player B skip his next combat phase?
Q2: If player A casts cloudshift to Dignitary while Path is on the stack, what's gonna happen? Path fizzles and then player B skips his next two combat phases?
Any rules reference would be appreciated.
Thanks
We played this like this:
1) First Angel of Sanctions enters the battlefield.
2) Fight occurs and Angel of Sanctions dies.
3) Then its triggered ability resolves and Loxodon Simiter dies.
4) Finally, Loxodon Simiter comes back into play without +1 +1 counter because Angel of Sanctions has left the battlefield.
Cheers!
My opponent played Angel of Sanctions and targeted my Loxodon Smiter. When he cast that, I played Dromoka's Command, chose +1 +1 to Loxodon and let it fight with Angel of Sanctions.
Can Dromoka's Command interrupt Angel of Sanctions' triggered ability?
We are confused when we tried to resolve this, so we would be happy if you could explain us what happens in this situation?
Thanks!
What happens if I have Dragon Egg on my side and my opponent casts Anger of the Gods?
In Anger of the Gods' oracle text it says: "If a creature dealt damage this way would die this turn, exile it instead."
Would I get a 2/2 red dragon token (because Dragon Egg dies first and then exiled) or not?
Cheers,
meocan66
We will be happy if you could help us with the following case:
Let's assume that I have 3 dragons on my side and dragon tempest. On my turn, I cast a new dragon spell which enables me to deal 4 damage to my opponent or a creature that he controls. After I cast the dragon I wanted to assign the damage to one of his creatures. Then my opponent played brave the elements and give all his creatures protection from red.
So, what happens now?
One theory is: Brave the elements resolves first, so I would not be able to assign damage to his creatures so I have to assign damage to player directly.
Other theory is: Because of protection from red, the damage assigned to his creature would do no harm to it and the opponent player also does not dealt any damage.
We would be really very happy if you could help us for this case. We are really confused
Cheers,
meocan66