2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - A peaceful town - Town Win
    we wouldn't have that problem if Tome gave us the pocketwatch in the first place. scum tactic.

    and given the amount of protectives (Killjoy possibly proven) along with Wuffles, SK is still likely.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - A peaceful town - Town Win
    ZE all over again. shoot Tom please
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - A peaceful town - Town Win
    ZE all over again. shoot Tom please
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - A peaceful town - Town Win
    also, bye~ idk why I care, but I aint a gamethrower
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - A peaceful town - Town Win
    Quote from Grapefruit21 »
    Do you not realize I'm voting cantrip? What do you think I'm advocating here?
    I see you're advocating for Tom who hasn't been confirmed, to give us fake results. in the worst-case scenario, we mislynch and misfire, while 2 scum are out there INCLUDING Tom who gives us fake results. you're advocating something.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - A peaceful town - Town Win
    3. if scum avoid the plan entirely, it still helps the PoE. Cantrip will still remain a waste of space.
    this is in reference to it resolving something. unless you mean Killjoy will die anyway thus not confirming me, then it means the NK will definitely not be Tom and he will be alive to give us the results from tracking me.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - A peaceful town - Town Win
    Quote from Grapefruit21 »
    And I misunderstood. If tom claims he was blocked or otherwise interfered with we'll have a super narrow pool to look at because of the way we're distributing items today so most players will have a item and ability that they are expected to use and prove.
    ..... this is not a reason.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - A peaceful town - Town Win
    Quote from Grapefruit21 »

    We can avoid the worst case scenario by not vigging which I have advocated for.
    And I don't believe there is an ability or item that says "target a player, that player's results will be false that night." I know you do given the way you've handled the KJ mess but I refuse to believe that item exists.
    Lastly KJ BG'ing you resolves nothing. What if scum don't shoot at you and hit him? Then it does nothing.
    1. nobody has agreed to it, so I'd assume we're still in that worst-case scenario. not a reason.
    2. refusing or believing something exists is not a reason.
    3. if scum avoid the plan entirely, it still helps the PoE. Cantrip will still remain a waste of space.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - A peaceful town - Town Win
    also, idk why I'm the only one supposedly suspicious of Tom when in reality, Rhand and Terry are also suspicious of him.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - A peaceful town - Town Win
    Quote from Grapefruit21 »
    Quote from Cyan »
    He probably included that because the more you post today, the more you seem like scum. You appear to be actively opposed to every plan we come up with to try to solve the game. It's really disconcerting.
    my plan works though. Tom isn't gonna be confirmed by anything, but I can be confirmed either way (unless scum have 2 NKs). resolving NAs by confirmation is more helpful to PoE than getting fake results to delay a correct lynch. the plan everyone is advocating for is too long-distance, and scumsided.

    But your plan is actively avoiding trying to catch the scum who targeted you last night. And doesn't really do anything other than give you a chance to prove you can track which incriminates KJ. It unlike the rest of the plans doesn't find out who targeted you and triggered your coin and is 100% scum. Or fabricated. Which is what I believe at this point.
    I stilllll don't see how my results incriminates Killjoy. even if I can prove I can track, it doesn't change the fact I'm not voting him now. and I already proven I can track since Rhand Shrugs
    I suspect Killjoy for different reasons, which everyone doesn't agree with, so this seems like a good compromise
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - A peaceful town - Town Win
    Quote from Grapefruit21 »
    Only way we don't have the numbers is if it's two living scum, and an SK, and we mislynch toDay, and misvig toNight, and we lose people to the mask via sanity death.
    And I added it because I had to repeat myself about 7 times for you to grasp that tom has to give us scum or die. You ignoring/not understanding that and worrying about not being able to trust tom makes me think that you were actively trying to discredit him.

    1. it would be wise to consider the worst-case scenario then. Killjoy bodyguarding me to say "truth or not" resolves the lynch between us, while Cantrip's lynch can help us place Tom (not clear, mind you).
    2. what if Tom just claims being tampered with? there is no 2 ways around that kind of solution. hmmm but ok. if you're misreading anything, I don't trust Tom unless proven otherwise. all the info he's given makes him more and more suspicious .-.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - A peaceful town - Town Win
    Quote from Cyan »
    He probably included that because the more you post today, the more you seem like scum. You appear to be actively opposed to every plan we come up with to try to solve the game. It's really disconcerting.
    my plan works though. Tom isn't gonna be confirmed by anything, but I can be confirmed either way (unless scum have 2 NKs). resolving NAs by confirmation is more helpful to PoE than getting fake results to delay a correct lynch. the plan everyone is advocating for is too long-distance, and scumsided.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - A peaceful town - Town Win
    Quote from RE1031 »
    What are the chances of a mafia back up?
    no idea .-. I hope there isn't cuz that would bring back bad memories lol
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - A peaceful town - Town Win
    Quote from Grapefruit21 »
    Sure but he is self resolving at this point. He either gives us the scum who targets you and we lynch them or he lies, we mislynch one person and then correctly lynch him.

    4. Also Dota is confirmed two shots. Plus the vault allows items to be removed so they aren't willed to people if you're unsure of who to trust. Same with my Chruch Vaults ability.
    1. isn't incriminating.
    2. is wine
    3. is him stealing from scum

    And again he has to give us scum from his pocketwatch watch or he gets lynched immediately. So there is no point in worrying about trusting or not trusting him now unless you have something to fear from him watching you.
    I see. fair enough. do we have the numbers for it?
    and I don't see why you had to include "unless you have something to fear from him watching you". calm down please~
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - A peaceful town - Town Win
    I'm.....quite sure I've been talking about this for a long time now?
    1. he heisted the map, but hasn't claimed the N2/6th item steal.

    2. Shadow willed him everything.
    3. he stole Proph's gold, which proves he's a thief.
    4. why would town have a vault if the main interaction was with town? DoTA flipped only a 1-shot steal iirc.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.