All users will need to merge their MTGSalvation account with a new or existing Twitch account starting Sept 25th. You can merge your accounts by clicking here. Have questions? Learn more here.
Dismiss
 
Magic Market Index for April 20th, 2018
 
Pauper Review: Dominaria
 
The Limited Archetypes of Dominaria
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - Day 2 Break In!
    2. you were talking about the Tommy Gun for a while. and about the AH deadline. it's kinda similar to DoTA's ISO, lots of quotes with few lines of your thoughts.
    3. we didn't know Wuffles won the Potion of Truth though. unless I overlooked something. at least you suggesting yourself take it would look better than asking Wuffles to waste it, then say you can't mechanically clear yourself.
    2. Again, I spent like a half page of my iso on the tommygun and auction house while I was catching up. Not two pages. You can reread it and look for yourself. And if you think I have "few of my own thoughts" in my posts, well, you're either not reading them or are intentionally misrepresenting them. I have plenty of thoughts and stances in my posts.

    3. Wuffles had already claimed the potion when I made my first post of toDay, I'm pretty sure, but regardless there's literally no way I could have gotten the potion, period. How do you suggest that I could have gotten the potion other than having Wuffles will it to me and die in my place? And this isn't related to mechanical /clears/ anyway, it's related to the fact that if I'm in the PoE based on my behavior (and it looks like I am) I'm going to look mechanically /guilty/ if I don't end up mechanically /dead/.

    well I doubt this will get anywhere. I made my point and that's how it is. I'll be reviewing you and make a proper case if I find anything. for now, you stay a suspect (which isn't even lockscum so I wonder why you're so worried).
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - Day 2 Break In!
    Unvote
    guess I'll sleep on this. gonna backread for those who townread Shadow. and I guess this puts Proph in a better light, since his vote was on DoTA and he suspected Shadow (doublebusing is insane).
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - Day 2 Break In!
    Quote from Grapefruit21 »
    @DBS looking at your stats you have played about 10 more games than I have, and we have the same number of scum games iirc mine correctly. I don't think it's a particullary relevant conversation but you are very obviously experienced enough to bus. Also this being either your third or 4th game here is enough where you're not really even "new" here any more.
    I have? guess I should've asked you for your stats to review before assuming. but ok, sounds fair. if I was experienced to bus though, you'll need to point that out in my records. afaik I suck at busing, but that's self-meta talk.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - Day 2 Break In!
    2. it was coupled with AtE though. as for the case itself, I've also said it already - 2 pages of mechanics and 2 pages of questions, with the latter half page 4 being deadline-driven (which looks more like wanting to get a lynch rather than gamesolve).

    3. ok I see. as I said, having you take the truth potion would be a good alternative. you suggested Wuffles take it instead - it is only your fault if you have no way to clear yourself mechanically. it's unreasonable to complain about lack of mechanic clearance when the Potion of Truth was still available. so yes, shooting you is optimal.
    2. That isn't a real read. There's barely a half page of mechanics, it's practically a straight-up lie.

    3. There's absolutely no way to get the potion into my hands short of Wuffles willing it to me and someone shooting him, which isn't much better from an objective standpoint. I couldn't have drank the potion even if I wanted to.

    2. you were talking about the Tommy Gun for a while. and about the AH deadline. it's kinda similar to DoTA's ISO, lots of quotes with few lines of your thoughts.
    3. we didn't know Wuffles won the Potion of Truth though. unless I overlooked something. at least you suggesting yourself take it would look better than asking Wuffles to waste it, then say you can't mechanically clear yourself.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - Day 2 Break In!
    also..
    Vote: shadowlancerx
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - Day 2 Break In!
    Quote from Rhand »
    I indeed visited Shadow, so DBS’s action is confirmed (can still be scum tracker, but occam says town).
    @DBS: I don’t need the puzzlebox. I was one-shot.

    I used my shot well tho. I copped Shadow. He is scum.
    We should shoot Shadow / lynch KJ or the other way around.
    hmmm only 1-shot.. but good to know you hit scum.

    Vote Puzzle Box: TheRealStinkyJoeTerry
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - Day 2 Break In!
    Quote from Grapefruit21 »

    I don't have much experience, so busing is really not in my meta.

    lol

    ahahahahahahahahahaehah


    bwhahahahahahahahahahaehahahahhahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

    I know for a fact you've been playing longer than me or Wisp. And neither of us are exactly noobs. And especially not to the point where we wouldn't be comfortable bussing (which for me was the more comfortable play to make as noob scum but ymmv)
    even if I played longer than you, I have less on record than you (who played on multiple sites), besides also having rolled town more than any other alignment.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - Day 2 Break In!
    1. considering meta should factor into reading someone. someone with more experience is more likely to bus over someone who just started out, since getting used to pushing your partner will take a while to learn. I don't have much experience, so busing is really not in my meta.
    2. you hadn't asked me to case you since I haven't suspected you. I suspected you could be scum or I would've not assumed your Leniency Talk was AtE.
    3. what is mechanically incorrect play? what are you referring to?

    1. I don't know what experience you may or may not have from playing at MAL, but bussing DoTA would have been like bussing a fish out of water. He wasn't even around to complain about it.

    2. I literally asked for you to give a real read on me when I said I had been being lenient after you voted me yesterDay.

    3. I'm referring to the fact that I'm not going to be able to clear myself and will likely end up lynched unless I'm extremely lucky. It's better to just shoot me because I will likely end up dead due to forces beyond my control by D3 if not sooner, /but/ I don't expect anyone to actually believe that. If I'm actually alive, I'll likely be investigated and lynched forthwith, but I'm town, so shooting me now is optimal.

    1. if you don't know my meta from MAL, then shouldn't you assume I'm starting over on this site? it still boils down to me having less experience.

    2. it was coupled with AtE though. as for the case itself, I've also said it already - 2 pages of mechanics and 2 pages of questions, with the latter half page 4 being deadline-driven (which looks more like wanting to get a lynch rather than gamesolve).

    3. ok I see. as I said, having you take the truth potion would be a good alternative. you suggested Wuffles take it instead - it is only your fault if you have no way to clear yourself mechanically. it's unreasonable to complain about lack of mechanic clearance when the Potion of Truth was still available. so yes, shooting you is optimal.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - Day 2 Break In!
    Vote Twin Scepters: Gemma
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - Day 2 Break In!
    Quote from Lastwhisper »
    Dawn
    Why do I alwways end up believing these ***** AtE's?
    unvote
    vote: Gemma XD
    it's your weakness lol
    but can you explain why Silver could be town with this? is he tunneling? doesn't look like it.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - Day 2 Break In!
    I mean. It doesn't matter whether you have bussed before or whether you claim to be interested in it or not. Obviously, if you're DoTA's partner, you aren't going to admit you bussed him.
    Before, I was just explaining why I hadn't forced you to give a real read on me yet. Because you can't use the stuff from the QT until the game is over. Now you... still don't have a real read on me, you're just saying I'm scum because I think you may have bussed DoTA. Which is... basically the definition of OMGUS. I'm apparently supposed to "know" that you'll never bus and just take your word for it and if I don't, well, I must be scum.
    And yeah, it's not AtE, I actually /do/ want shot. Mostly because I'm not interested in rehashing yesterday or the D1 of every game I've been in ever, but also because I did a thing I knew not to do last night and I'll probably be dead by D3 anyway. If I'm in the PoE, shoot me now. That's not AtE, it's me telling you that's the mechanically correct play.

    1. considering meta should factor into reading someone. someone with more experience is more likely to bus over someone who just started out, since getting used to pushing your partner will take a while to learn. I don't have much experience, so busing is really not in my meta.
    2. you hadn't asked me to case you since I haven't suspected you. I suspected you could be scum or I would've not assumed your Leniency Talk was AtE.
    3. what is mechanically incorrect play? what are you referring to?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - Day 2 Break In!
    There are three scum left. There's either one bussing DoTA or the wagon is clean.
    Terry was the counterwagon to scum, which means busing was unlikely. and if you want to talk about busing being a thing, Prophylaxis has bused before (I have yet to even establish my scum meta). why aren't you looking into someone who has bused from record, but would want to assume that about someone who has no record of it yet?
    typo lol. Vezok, not Terry.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - Day 2 Break In!
    There are three scum left. There's either one bussing DoTA or the wagon is clean.
    Terry was the counterwagon to scum, which means busing was unlikely. and if you want to talk about busing being a thing, Prophylaxis has bused before (I have yet to even establish my scum meta). why aren't you looking into someone who has bused from record, but would want to assume that about someone who has no record of it yet?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - Day 2 Break In!
    Quote from tomsloger »
    Dawn do you think we can just pass items around willy nilly?
    Terry seemed to be the target with the wording of DoTA's abilities, so he should is closer to conf!town.
    Puzzle Box might help Rhand, if he did visit Shadow as suspected.
    the others should know how to use AH stuff better than me.


    Case please.

    And it didn't seem like you were super interested in lynching DoTA until he was already a wagon... I'd hardly call you the "wagon starter." But even if you were, bussing is A Thing. A thing I don't think Cyan was doing but that I think you could have been.
    I did start the wagon, after analyzing that Vezok's claim was more town than scum. Cyan hopped on. only in that duration, things happened that made me not the 1st vote. please backread.
    I haven't bused in meta nor am I interested in it. assuming that about me is shade.

    Actually, whoever gets the gun /should/ just shoot me.

    And then everyone can lynch DBS/Tom when I flip town. Thanks.
    this would be the idk..2nd time I've seen AtE from you. the 1st time was when you talked about being lenient with me.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Arkham Horror Mafia - Day 2 Break In!
    Quote from Grapefruit21 »
    Why is everyone claiming everything.... In ways that don't help us with anything. Stop claiming unless you have a reason to.
    I got excited for about thirty seconds thinking the heist confirmed the number of scum in the game... It doesn't.
    I kind of really want to either lynch Iso or Derp clear him. Don't think there is an in between.
    I'm still moderately shocked that Vezok flipped town.
    I can't tell if this is scum!wisp acting scummy or town!Wisp being oblivious. My gut says the latter but there is so much wrong with the last few hours of posts from him.

    1. information is power.
    2. not sure how you can think an ability confirms scum numbers.
    3. derp-clear him.
    4. I doubt we were. he's been more town with his claim than not.
    5. this is more like town!Last.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.