Quote from rcwraspy »Fair enough. I still feel Preordain is the lowest risk unban, followed by Probe then Twin then SFM. But the gap after Probe is fairly large.Quote from tronix »Quote from rcwraspy »I posted the meme, but it was more satire than anything else. I'm still in the "leave SFM banned" camp. Everybody's arguments leading up to my post basically boiled down to the same tired drivel of "T3 BSkull is nuffink compurred to teh combos" and I decided to meme it. Not the best of decisions, but oh well. Nobody seems to understand context, nuance and consequences when discussing unbans. Or they understand it and simply choose not to engage with it. The problem with SFM has never been about the T3 Batterskull and whether that beats any decks. It's about the shell that the SFM package fits into and the inevitability the package provides. SFM and Twin both occupy that same space, so it's really no wonder that there's such a large crossover in the people discussing both.Quote from ktkenshinx »Posting memes, one-liners, and other such low-effort posts doesn't even try to convince people. It's just regurgitating tired tropes and repeating the exact same kind of minimum-content complaining we've heard for years on mediums like Twitch.
ive pretty much been saying the same thing about the context of decks that might play SFM. the difference for me is i want the card unbanned because it wouldnt break anything, but i have hopes for it to be a force of change in the format. not huge mind you, just decks that i wouldnt mind seeing more of getting an upgrade. its asking decks to answer a simple question (can you kill it), and is a solid roleplayer across the spectrum of value, clock, and defense. expecting decks to fold to it outright would be nonsense.
all in all im still in agreement with the opinion that its the lowest risk unban option, will almost assuredly happen someday given modern doesnt die out, and will likely come at a time when wizards can capitalize on it because why not.
Let me make sure I'm understanding you correctly: you believe Git Probe is a safer unban than SFM?