- Registered User
Member for 1 year, 8 months, and 15 days
Last active Mon, Jun, 18 2018 09:06:58
- 0 Followers
- 43 Total Posts
- 12 Thanks
Jun 18, 2018He's fantastic if he's built around a little like you said, but he is by no means necessary. Depends what you want in that 4-drop slot. New Karn ends the game if he goes unchecked against midrange and control, but in some metas something like Thought-Knot Seer would be much more useful. Personally, I love the 3-rock, 1-2 New Karn builds and I'm gonna keep playing him but for example my last FNM was Burn, Bogles, Burn, Ad Nauseum, Drop Rnd 5 and I wished he was literally any other card in those matchups.Posted in: Control
Jun 13, 2018I prefer not to play them at all because I'm liking the artifact heavy ramp/Karn strategy atm, BUT when I was playing TKS it felt great against Burn if you see a lot of it. Strips a burn spell and is a thicc enough body to absorb all their attackers. In order to remove it they have to point burn at it for a turn. As others said it's also good against combo and forces an answer from Control to potentially clear a path for your bigger things. Only matchup I don't like it in is the Hollow One/Affinity/Elves type decks that barf out their hand super fast. It's definitely a powerful and diverse card and has a place in the 75 if you're not scared of getting cut off of casting it (Blood Moon went from being a minor annoyance to a real problem when I main-decked 4 TKS).Posted in: Control
I'd vote 1 maindeck and some more in the board if you really like it.
Jun 11, 2018https://www.reddit.com/r/magicTCG/comments/8qadma/m19_jugement_infernal/Posted in: Control
Tells Wurmcoil Engine to go to hell, but I don't think it will see much play. Of note in only hits colorless creatures so it doesn't hit other important pieces like walkers, O-stones, Mindslaver, etc.
Jun 5, 2018Thanks for the great info @Barrin. Love to see that winrate vs Mardu Pyro, it is probably the #1 most played deck at my shop outside of Burn.Posted in: Control
I've been keeping a spreadsheet with all my matchup info as well (currently on Shok's last posted 5-0 list) and hope to get it out soon. At only 10 leagues I just don't feel like it's enough data and my winrate with it is only 54% atm so I'm kind of burned out.
Jun 2, 2018Mindslaver is our inevitability against Midrange and Control and if you're able to stay alive a Slaver without the lock against Combo usually ends the game by disrupting them. People are scared of it too and spend resources to keep it at bay. It's only a liability against aggro, in which case just board it out for more removal and jam in some more Wurmcoils. I think it's 100% insane to not play at least one (I do 1 main/1 side) and I haven't seen anyone REALLY advocate for removing them entirely.Posted in: Control
May 21, 2018It's not a bad card to use at all, it's just meta dependent. I loved it when shadow was a big deal and keep it sleeved up in my maybeboard. There's a lot of matchups where it's just not impactful though so I prefer to start with it in the board.Posted in: Control
May 18, 2018There are some post-board matches where you might cut both so look at it on a case by case basis. Sometimes you have to go down wincons to board in all your removal just to stay alive and Platinum won't cut it in games 2-3 when they board in artifact removal (Destructive Revelry, Kolaghan's). I wouldn't go insane and drop every Wurmcoil/Mindslaver/Angel, but going down 1x Slaver 1x Angel isn't a bad idea. You should still have enough Gearhulks, Sundering Titan, boarded in Wurmcoils, Ugin etc. to finish the job.Posted in: Control
May 16, 2018@ BloodyRabbit_01 - Dismember is still great removal and I wonder if the B splash for Damnation is still better than R or W. What sweepers did you have in min d for those colors? Something earlier like Pyroclasm? Probably too off-topic for straight U Tron but it's something I always want to just dabble with and I chicken out before starting a league because the manabase looks so bad with 2 colors.Posted in: Control
May 16, 2018@ Jokersrwild - thanks for the continued information about your matchups in leagues. Definitely been high on Aetherspouts and glad it's back in, especially with Gearhulk. It's backbreaking to every single deck I have had trouble with since I started on the deck. I am still skeptical on Karn, but seeing you post specific matchups where he has won you games definitely makes me want to try him out. I am assuming you will continue to keep him at 1x so you don't get clogged up with him (same reasoning for Ugin) but at 4cmc maybe that's not a problem?Posted in: Control
May 15, 2018Man you guys just love jumping on Bloody. I am and probably always will be a "Shok-type" player for most events, but if you've ever tried their list it really is more consistent at pooping on aggro and their card evaluation seems well thought out. Pie is probably my favorite card evaluator in U Tron and he wasn't high on Karn either, you gonna go after him too?Posted in: Control
Keep in mind Shok/joker/Agnara and the like are just really good players, period. Shok/Joker just posted great records with 1x Aetherspouts (now missing in the list but has personally won me more games than any other singleton in the last couple weeks) and I remember Agnara 5-0ing with 1x Jace. Sometimes these 1-of card choices pan out over time or are great in specific metas but they're often not going to make-or-break your deck, especially when not fetchable (praise be to Ugin, the GOAT). The real "innovation" (not really new, because tons of lists used to run 3+) are the 3 Talismans to power things out. On paper it feels too slow, but lately I have been able to take some beats on T2/T3 and then make a huge game-swinging T4/T5. Stony Silence is nowhere to be seen in my shop so I'm on that plan until it comes back in real numbers.
I went ahead and grabbed 1x baby Karn just in case because I like that it can grind out games when people go after my tron pieces. I have seen him take over games FAST if left unchecked. Guy at my shop has whooped me on Affinity two weeks in a row solely because of Karn and the new angle of attack he gives them. Maybe he turns out to work for us too and gives us a reason to plop down some maps instead of pitching to Thirst.
May 8, 2018I really do dig Oblivion Sower as a fun-of. I don't think it's actually good, but it really is a reasonable body. Just comes down too late against the one deck you really care about (G Tron).Posted in: Control
Jokers where you at bb? Saw you put up another 5-0 with a stock-ish list. Do you remember your match-ups? Being able to rip off multiple 5-0 finishes is definitely impressive with the amount of Humans and Hollow One around so I'm wondering how you did it or if it's just volume. Did Damping Sphere do any work for you?
Apr 18, 2018Posted in: ControlQuote from topkyle »Shok posted two 5-0 leagues yesterday with meta-calls Aetherspouts and Aetherize. With Boggles getting really popular I think it's nice to have a mass bounce spell mainboard and it also happens to be great against Affinity and Infect which are popular at my LGS so I'm gonna give it a try.
Those looking for the list:
Shoktroopa 4/17/2018Magic OnlineOCTGN2ApprenticeBuy These Cards Land = 23
1 Academy Ruins
1 Gemstone Caverns
1 Oboro, Palace in the Clouds
1 River of Tears
2 Snow-Covered Island
1 Tectonic Edge
1 Tolaria West
4 Urza's Mine
4 Urza's Power Plant
4 Urza's Tower
Spells = 18
1 Cyclonic Rift
1 Gifts Ungiven
4 Thirst for Knowledge
Non-creature Artifact = 11
1 Chalice of the Void
4 Expedition Map
1 Oblivion Stone
2 Talisman of Dominance
1 Talisman of Progress
Creatures = 7
1 Platinum Angel
1 Snapcaster Mage
1 Solemn Simulacrum
1 Sundering Titan
1 Treasure Mage
1 Walking Ballista
1 Wurmcoil Engine
Planeswalkers = 1
1 Ugin, the Spirit Dragon
Sideboard = 15
1 Chalice of the Void
1 Crucible of Worlds
1 Engineered Explosives
1 Field of Ruin
1 Ghost Quarter
2 Spatial Contortion
2 Spreading Seas
2 Surgical Extraction
1 Wurmcoil Engine
Apr 18, 2018Shok posted two 5-0 leagues yesterday with meta-calls Aetherspouts and Aetherize. With Boggles getting really popular I think it's nice to have a mass bounce spell mainboard and it also happens to be great against Affinity and Infect which are popular at my LGS so I'm gonna give it a try.Posted in: Control
Apr 9, 2018My land situation seemed fine and I didn't notice the lack of a 4th map, but there is only so much you can infer from 7 rounds of play. It's the first card I look at siding out in a lot of matchups so starting at 3 was kind of a non-issue for me although I like 4 to start since it keeps the artifact count up.Posted in: Control
I was surprised how much I enjoyed Supreme Will, but I don't know about 4x at the expense of TfK. My first instinct is to try out a 3/3 split and see where that takes me.
2x Snapcaster seemed fine. I guess you look at what it's taking the place of. Compared to lists I usually run let's say that is Trinket Mage. This list is not running mainboard Chalice and just naturally finds Ballista since that is at 3x so Snapcaster is just better. I kind of wish 1 of the Snaps was an Obstructionist though. The flying is sometimes relevant.
3x Dismember was critical in my wins. Maybe 3x is too many, but I dunno...felt fine. The 4 life doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things when that Hierarch or Devoted Druid needs to die immediately. I was happy with them. My gripe was not having things in the sideboard to replace them with in dead matchups. Dispel and Negate seem narrow when I think of a broad meta, but I sure wish I had them in the board on Saturday. 7 targeted removal in the 75 just nullified CoCO + Zoo but was useless against Scapeshift. I guess that's just a U Tron problem. It's hard to plan for everything. 4x Chalice in the board was a similar problem. When you want them you REALLY want them and when you don't you wish they were anything else. I'm really down on them atm.
Overall, I like the shell and definitely appreciate it being shared with us. I think my favorite aspect is the multiple Ballista and River of Tears. Everything I would try and change is just tweaking numbers to see how it feels. I'll start with 3/3 Supreme/Thirst split, dropping a land to 24 (and 60 cards overall), going back to 4x Map and dropping either 1x Remand or Dismember. Probably toy around with 1x Nimble Obstructionist in the main.
Apr 8, 2018Was also at SCG Milwaukee and it was great meeting another U Tron player (Mister_Lamp) to share some bad beats stories. The other U Tron player from my LGS was also there.Posted in: Control
I played the Classic today with the UB variant of Colorless Eldrazi and after 15 paper matches I'm too tired to write a full report buuuuuuut...
Topkyle @ SCG Milwaukee Open w/ Bloody_Rabbit01 (exact list):
Round 1- Ironworks Combo (W 2-0) 1-0 overall
Round 2- Bring to Light Scapeshift (L 1-2) 1-1 overall
Round 3- Bring to Light Scapeshift (L 1-2) 1-2 overall
Round 4- Titanshift (W 2-1) 2-2 overall
Round 5- WG Vizier Company (W 2-1) 3-2 overall
Round 6- Naya Zoo (W 2-0) 4-2 overall
Round 7- Humans (L 1-2) 4-3 overall -- DROP
My takeaway is that U Tron is powerful, but it's just not a good deck for a super-wide meta. This list performed amazingly in the matchups it was prepped for. Vizier CoCo and Naya Zoo were super easy. I would not have expected that with the normal lists. I did not expect to hit Scapeshift decks three rounds in a row and it had a tilting effect when my post-sideboard games were neutered. The BTL lists especially were chaining Negates and Dispels against me and I have way too many slots dedicated to removal. This list felt more competitive versus Humans, but this matchup can't be made positive. I was constantly scrambling for answers as he applied pressure and kept me off O. Stone. I almost wish I had 4x Engineered Explosives but that's not realistic.
After seeing the top 32 I would absolutely bring something close to this list to the next Open or GP if I was to go and chalk my losses up to a strange run of matchups or some questionable play decisions. 100% Walking Ballista was my best card on the day btw and I am with Bloody_Rabbit that it needs to be played in multiples. Chalice was the worst card on the day and just rotted as a 4-of in my SB for almost every matchup.
- To post a comment, please login or register a new account.