I'm not going to dredge up my old reasoning to vote Stormblind - what finally brought my vote is new information, so I guess it would be kosher to share that.
Stormblind's questioning of Niv's role was the tipping point. I felt he was leading Niv into some post that would make the role seem silly. SB's questions, imo, were much less Townlike than HE's, for example (who I consider a Townlike player this game).
I'll go on record saying we should not lynch Niv - I believe what he's giving us: bad play does not equal scum when one owns up to what they've done, imo. The backtracking ones who play bad are the scum.
Translated: "I support the Niv wagon but not officially. I'd rather not be associated with it when he comes up town and instead I'll finger a scum buddy."
lol
Please lynch my scum buddy instead of me. That way we'll lynch scum, y'know.
I've honestly not tested much, because Standard is more pertinent at the moment. However, if white turns out the way to go, I think Feudkiller's Verdict is a must.
Right now, PDog is still my top pick for scum. @PDog: Why would you feel the need to point out overlooking Niv? I mean, he's an uncounterclaimed cop. You're now saying that suddenly, you're suspicious of Niv? If that's not what you're implying by the statement of "I completely looked over Niv because of the claim, too." please explain to me what you did mean by it.
I made mention of overlooking because I overlooked it! Nothing simpler than that, honestly. I was also using it as a sort of reminder that claim != alignment.
It is suspicious that Niv would visit the witch instead of continuing the investigation. However, I'm more currently interested in CM and SB.
Pdog Crusader (atlseal)
Currently my top scum pick; here's why:
Post 84: BHB (me) says something really stupid. Bateleur, StormBlind, AlphaInsidious, and Niv jump on him for it. This is a terrible wagon; the reasons for the wagon were fine, but the fact that BHB was put at -3 to lynch within a matter of 3 1/2 hours is ridiculous. This wagon obviously formed way too quickly.
I'm not going to answer for atlseal, but I do have a question: do you think that there was scum in this quick bandwagon?
I completely looked over Niv because of the claim, too.
PDog then replaces in and Vampyr makes a case.
Post 551: PDog responds to Vampyr's case mostly by asking questions back and dodging the rest. There is very little in the way of real responses here. To top it off, he ends by adding a vote to the Bate wagon.
I reread that post just now, and I honestly don't feel I was being dodgy.
Kraj: it counts game days. I can spill the full amount of what I know at the town's request, but I'd rather keep it a secret, as what I know and will know tomorrow isn't exactly going to be game-breaking. what I find out after that has a good chance of being a breaker.
This is only slightly ludicrous.
Hey guys, don't lynch me for a couple Days, OK? I'll win the game by then!
"Ah, yes sir. I'd like to learn from you and the fine mages of this House. I'm willing to help when needed, and hope to increase my knowledge along the way."
Yes, I think the shift to mono blue is necessary. The only big reason I would go Uw is for Judge of Currents, Harpoon Sniper or Feudkiller's Verdict - if this can't handle speedy aggro, the lifegain may be necessary to stabilize.
Slithermuse is quite tasty, indeed. I also added Latchkey Faerie into the side. Between Reejery, Surgespanner, and Cryptic Command, a rogue will get through, making it worth playing for the Prowl cost.
After rest, he was ready for some action. He wandered down to the lobby and scanned the room for the blue kami.
Stormblind's questioning of Niv's role was the tipping point. I felt he was leading Niv into some post that would make the role seem silly. SB's questions, imo, were much less Townlike than HE's, for example (who I consider a Townlike player this game).
I'll go on record saying we should not lynch Niv - I believe what he's giving us: bad play does not equal scum when one owns up to what they've done, imo. The backtracking ones who play bad are the scum.
Please lynch my scum buddy instead of me. That way we'll lynch scum, y'know.
Let's lynch Stormblind.
vote: Stormblind
If you read all of the first post, I started out thinking white specifically because of Judge of Currents and Pollen Lullaby. What do you think of Ego Erasure as a pseudo-fog effect?
I've honestly not tested much, because Standard is more pertinent at the moment. However, if white turns out the way to go, I think Feudkiller's Verdict is a must.
Also, good call on the Mothdust Changeling, and some valid points on Merrow Commerce.
It is suspicious that Niv would visit the witch instead of continuing the investigation. However, I'm more currently interested in CM and SB.
I completely looked over Niv because of the claim, too.I reread that post just now, and I honestly don't feel I was being dodgy.This is only slightly ludicrous.
Hey guys, don't lynch me for a couple Days, OK? I'll win the game by then!
What, mafia kill me? No, not a chance!
>
I ssee no reason to say that unless you're scum.
Bateleur had to be lynched, though; I feel there was no other way around Day 2.
Hawkeye(Matjoeman, Bate, Pdog/Inhim, Xyre)
Bate(Suth)
Xyre(BHB, SB, Niv, Zionite, Vampyr, CM, Hawkeye)
Well, obviously, if you're going to finish up the off-lynch, you would want to vote me. I'm not advising it.
Niv? Any news?
Walker of the Grove = peacock. lulz
2. Rogues/Warriors
3. Druid - looking to be broken!
EDIT:
Declaration of Naught isn't living up to snuff - Negate comes in against those playing mass removal (Austere Command, Final Revels, etc.)
Slithermuse is quite tasty, indeed. I also added Latchkey Faerie into the side. Between Reejery, Surgespanner, and Cryptic Command, a rogue will get through, making it worth playing for the Prowl cost.