A player just asked this on Twitter...I answered, but he's getting a lot of answers that is opposite of me...
Player A controls a Deciever Exarch enchanted with Splinter Twin. He makes a copy...In response, Player B casts Turn to Frog on the Exarch. Does the Frog still have the "Make a copy" ability?
I said that yes, it would. That the creature is being granted the ability by the Splinter Twin.
I don't understand how the **** you people think Vampires is an autowin. In fact, it's literally unwinnable for me. I'm 0-5 lifetime vs. vampires. I literally cannot win, no matter what I do. They always keep hands of 2 lands, 3 threats, and 2 removal. Absolutely nothing you can do to that.
Seeing as how I asked for tier 1 decks, you should probably learn to ****ing read. Don't try to smear my name on here without giving some more detail. Nice try at trollin' me, bro. People around these parts know I'm not a saint. And you know what? They don't give a ****, because I give them good logs against scrubs like you, who think your "brew" can beat anything. Yet, you 0-2 drop every large tournament you play in. So don't come onto these forums that I've been apart of for four goddamn years and try to blast me just because you got butthurt because I didn't want to play against your janky ass discard deck.
Anyways, I digress. A log. When plans A, B, and C don't work...Accuse your opponent of cheating and leave before they can explain what happened...By the way, he has a Chalice of the Void on 0.
It is now turn 22 (Hix360)
It is now the Beginning Phase, Untap Step
Hix360 untaps his/her permanents
It is now the Beginning Phase, Upkeep Step
It is now the Beginning Phase, Draw Step
Hix360 draws a card
It is now the Precombat Main Phase
Hix360 plays Show and Tell from Hand
Hix360 taps Island
Hix360 taps Ancient Tomb
Hix360's life total is now 15 (-2)
<Hix360> Ok?
Yaw plays a facedown card from Hand
Hix360 plays a facedown card from Hand
Hix360 flips Hive Mind over
Hix360 puts Show and Tell to Graveyard from Play
Yaw flips Tawnos's Coffin over
Hix360 plays Slaughter Pact from Hand
Hix360 plays Summoner's Pact from Hand
<Hix360> gg?
<Yaw> no i have mana
<Hix360> 7 mana
<Yaw> 7
<Hix360> witness doesnt tap for mana...
<Hix360> you have 5 lands and a birds
<Yaw> but next my upkeep
<Hix360> that is 6
<Yaw> u end?
It is now the End Phase, End Of Turn Step
<Hix360> End My Turn
It is now turn 23 (Yaw)
It is now the Beginning Phase, Untap Step
Yaw untaps his/her permanents
It is now the Beginning Phase, Upkeep Step
<Yaw> ok?
<Yaw> resp
Yaw taps Verdant Catacombs
Yaw puts Verdant Catacombs to Graveyard from Play
Yaw is looking its Library...
Yaw puts Bayou into play from Library
Yaw shuffles library
Yaw stops looking its Library...
Yaw taps Bayou
Yaw taps Taiga
Yaw taps Swamp
<Hix360> Ok
Yaw taps Vault of Whispers
Yaw taps Forest
Yaw taps Birds of Paradise
Yaw taps Eternal Witness
<Hix360> no
<Hix360> witness does not produce mana!!
<Yaw> what mo?
It is now the Precombat Main Phase
It is now the Beginning Phase, Draw Step
It is now the Beginning Phase, Upkeep Step
<Yaw> what no?
<Hix360> why do you think it does?
<Yaw> wait
<Yaw> Ok
<Hix360> jeeze
Yaw is looking its Library...
Yaw puts Birds of Paradise into play from Library
<Yaw> Ok?
<Hix360> know what your cards do
Yaw shuffles library
Yaw stops looking its Library...
<Hix360> no?
<Yaw> why?
<Yaw> i have a copy
Yaw untaps Eternal Witness
<Hix360> ok
Yaw taps Birds of Paradise
<Hix360> its in your hand
<Hix360> not in play
<Yaw> Ok
<Yaw> g2?
<Hix360> i guess
<Opponent is requesting a new game>
Yaw shuffles library
<Yaw> I am ready.
Yaw draws 0 cards
Yaw draws 7 cards
Hix360 shuffles library
<Hix360> I am ready.
Hix360 draws 0 cards
<-------- New Game Started -------->
Hix360's Security Code: 7B0A040E [Type 1.5]
Yaw's Security Code: B34EE2CE [???]
It is now turn 1 (Hix360)
It is now the Beginning Phase, Untap Step
<Yaw> Kp
Hix360 shuffles library
Hix360 draws 7 cards
<Hix360> Keep
Yaw plays Verdant Catacombs from Hand
<Yaw> wait noob
<Hix360> ???
<Yaw> a have chalise 0!!!!!!!!!!!
<Yaw> gay
<Hix360> so?
<System> Player Lost
PS. Yes, I know I will get a flaming warning/infraction. But you know what? It was damn worth it. Pieces of **** like this give Salvation a bad name.
EDIT: Ooh and don't forget this log, posted just 3 days ago by Falknir exhibiting your lack of knowledge of the game. Falknir's Log. So grow up and learn the rules, kid.
Not sure if this is going to be Thornling or not, but Kelly Reid over at QS posted the tweet in the image below. Unless there's some sort of "new" green Morphling, I will assume that Thornling is back...
Feel free to update this thread as-needed as more information is posted.
EDIT: Thornling's name cannot fit into the Name/Number Crunch...
You must have either Suture Priest or Soul's Attendant on the battlefield as well as a Leonin Relic-Warder. You cast Phyrexian Metamorph. As it enters the battlefield, it becomes a copy of the Relic-Warder...The Metamorph/Warder's triggered ability happens...It exiles itself, because it's also an artifact. This triggers the "leaves the battlefield" trigger. So the Metamorph comes back. Repeat as needed.
Alrighty. First you must have either soul's attendant or suture priest under your control as well as a leonin relic-warder. Cast phyrexian metamorph. It enters the battlefield as a Leonin Relic-Warder. Both the Sister and the "Warder" trigger. "Warder" targets itself because it is still an artifact. Effect resolves, exiling metamorph. This triggers the "Warder"'s leaves play ability. This brings the Metamorph back to the battlefield and you start the combo over again.
It's about time a "nice" log was posted in here. lol
<-------- New Game Started -------->
IWASHI's Security Code: 06FB21F9/sb [Type 1.5]
Hix360's Security Code: E94B694A/sb [Type 1.5]
It is now turn 1 (Hix360)
It is now the Beginning Phase, Untap Step
Hix360 shuffles library
IWASHI shuffles library
It is now turn 2 (IWASHI)
It is now the Beginning Phase, Untap Step
IWASHI draws 7 cards
Hix360 draws 7 cards
IWASHI takes a mulligan
<Hix360> Keep
<IWASHI> kp
It is now the Precombat Main Phase
IWASHI plays Bayou from Hand
IWASHI puts Bayou to Hand from Play
IWASHI plays Marsh Flats from Hand
IWASHI's life total is now 19 (-1)
IWASHI puts Marsh Flats to Graveyard from Play
Hix360 rearranges cards in Hix360's Hand
IWASHI is looking its Library...
IWASHI puts Swamp into play from Library
IWASHI shuffles library
IWASHI stops looking its Library...
IWASHI taps Swamp
IWASHI plays Putrid Imp from Hand
<Hix360> Ok
IWASHI plays Grave Titan from Hand
IWASHI plays Jin-Gitaxias, Core Augur from Hand
IWASHI puts Grave Titan to Graveyard from Play
IWASHI puts Jin-Gitaxias, Core Augur to Graveyard from Play
It is now the End Phase, End Of Turn Step
<IWASHI> End my turn
It is now turn 3 (Hix360)
It is now the Beginning Phase, Untap Step
Hix360 untaps his/her permanents
It is now the Beginning Phase, Upkeep Step
It is now the Beginning Phase, Draw Step
Hix360 draws a card
It is now the Precombat Main Phase
Hix360 plays Seat of the Synod from Hand
Hix360 plays Lotus Petal from Hand
Hix360 plays Goblin Welder from Hand
<IWASHI> Ok
Hix360 puts Lotus Petal to Graveyard from Play
Hix360 plays Tormod's Crypt from Hand
<Hix360> gg?
<IWASHI> oh
<IWASHI> nice
<IWASHI> gg
<Hix360> lol
<Hix360> gg
<System> Player Lost
If you don't see it...The guy is playing Reanimator...I go turn 1 welder & tormod's crypt...They can never reanimate things, barring necromancy shenanigans.
Or, you know...You shouldn't put all your eggs in one basket. That's why I think my vengevine build is better than the mono white version. I also just cut a Vengevine for Melira, Sylvok Outcast.
With Melira, Sylvok Outcast on the battlefield under my control, can my opponent proliferate my poison counters? My initial answer is no, but I want to make sure.
That is incorrect. Platinum Angel say's you can't lose the game. THat's just what it means. You can't lose. Until Platinum Angel is destroyed, Transcendence just sits there shaking its fist at you and gains you life.
Player A controls a Deciever Exarch enchanted with Splinter Twin. He makes a copy...In response, Player B casts Turn to Frog on the Exarch. Does the Frog still have the "Make a copy" ability?
I said that yes, it would. That the creature is being granted the ability by the Splinter Twin.
Anyways, I digress. A log. When plans A, B, and C don't work...Accuse your opponent of cheating and leave before they can explain what happened...By the way, he has a Chalice of the Void on 0.
It is now the Beginning Phase, Untap Step
Hix360 untaps his/her permanents
It is now the Beginning Phase, Upkeep Step
It is now the Beginning Phase, Draw Step
Hix360 draws a card
It is now the Precombat Main Phase
Hix360 plays Show and Tell from Hand
Hix360 taps Island
Hix360 taps Ancient Tomb
Hix360's life total is now 15 (-2)
<Hix360> Ok?
Yaw plays a facedown card from Hand
Hix360 plays a facedown card from Hand
Hix360 flips Hive Mind over
Hix360 puts Show and Tell to Graveyard from Play
Yaw flips Tawnos's Coffin over
Hix360 plays Slaughter Pact from Hand
Hix360 plays Summoner's Pact from Hand
<Hix360> gg?
<Yaw> no i have mana
<Hix360> 7 mana
<Yaw> 7
<Hix360> witness doesnt tap for mana...
<Hix360> you have 5 lands and a birds
<Yaw> but next my upkeep
<Hix360> that is 6
<Yaw> u end?
It is now the End Phase, End Of Turn Step
<Hix360> End My Turn
It is now turn 23 (Yaw)
It is now the Beginning Phase, Untap Step
Yaw untaps his/her permanents
It is now the Beginning Phase, Upkeep Step
<Yaw> ok?
<Yaw> resp
Yaw taps Verdant Catacombs
Yaw puts Verdant Catacombs to Graveyard from Play
Yaw is looking its Library...
Yaw puts Bayou into play from Library
Yaw shuffles library
Yaw stops looking its Library...
Yaw taps Bayou
Yaw taps Taiga
Yaw taps Swamp
<Hix360> Ok
Yaw taps Vault of Whispers
Yaw taps Forest
Yaw taps Birds of Paradise
Yaw taps Eternal Witness
<Hix360> no
<Hix360> witness does not produce mana!!
<Yaw> what mo?
It is now the Precombat Main Phase
It is now the Beginning Phase, Draw Step
It is now the Beginning Phase, Upkeep Step
<Yaw> what no?
<Hix360> why do you think it does?
<Yaw> wait
<Yaw> Ok
<Hix360> jeeze
Yaw is looking its Library...
Yaw puts Birds of Paradise into play from Library
<Yaw> Ok?
<Hix360> know what your cards do
Yaw shuffles library
Yaw stops looking its Library...
<Hix360> no?
<Yaw> why?
<Yaw> i have a copy
Yaw untaps Eternal Witness
<Hix360> ok
Yaw taps Birds of Paradise
<Hix360> its in your hand
<Hix360> not in play
<Yaw> Ok
<Yaw> g2?
<Hix360> i guess
<Opponent is requesting a new game>
Yaw shuffles library
<Yaw> I am ready.
Yaw draws 0 cards
Yaw draws 7 cards
Hix360 shuffles library
<Hix360> I am ready.
Hix360 draws 0 cards
<-------- New Game Started -------->
Hix360's Security Code: 7B0A040E [Type 1.5]
Yaw's Security Code: B34EE2CE [???]
It is now turn 1 (Hix360)
It is now the Beginning Phase, Untap Step
<Yaw> Kp
Hix360 shuffles library
Hix360 draws 7 cards
<Hix360> Keep
Yaw plays Verdant Catacombs from Hand
<Yaw> wait noob
<Hix360> ???
<Yaw> a have chalise 0!!!!!!!!!!!
<Yaw> gay
<Hix360> so?
<System> Player Lost
PS. Yes, I know I will get a flaming warning/infraction. But you know what? It was damn worth it. Pieces of **** like this give Salvation a bad name.
EDIT: Ooh and don't forget this log, posted just 3 days ago by Falknir exhibiting your lack of knowledge of the game. Falknir's Log. So grow up and learn the rules, kid.
Flaming Infraction
Feel free to update this thread as-needed as more information is posted.
EDIT: Thornling's name cannot fit into the Name/Number Crunch...
IWASHI's Security Code: 06FB21F9/sb [Type 1.5]
Hix360's Security Code: E94B694A/sb [Type 1.5]
It is now turn 1 (Hix360)
It is now the Beginning Phase, Untap Step
Hix360 shuffles library
IWASHI shuffles library
It is now turn 2 (IWASHI)
It is now the Beginning Phase, Untap Step
IWASHI draws 7 cards
Hix360 draws 7 cards
IWASHI takes a mulligan
<Hix360> Keep
<IWASHI> kp
It is now the Precombat Main Phase
IWASHI plays Bayou from Hand
IWASHI puts Bayou to Hand from Play
IWASHI plays Marsh Flats from Hand
IWASHI's life total is now 19 (-1)
IWASHI puts Marsh Flats to Graveyard from Play
Hix360 rearranges cards in Hix360's Hand
IWASHI is looking its Library...
IWASHI puts Swamp into play from Library
IWASHI shuffles library
IWASHI stops looking its Library...
IWASHI taps Swamp
IWASHI plays Putrid Imp from Hand
<Hix360> Ok
IWASHI plays Grave Titan from Hand
IWASHI plays Jin-Gitaxias, Core Augur from Hand
IWASHI puts Grave Titan to Graveyard from Play
IWASHI puts Jin-Gitaxias, Core Augur to Graveyard from Play
It is now the End Phase, End Of Turn Step
<IWASHI> End my turn
It is now turn 3 (Hix360)
It is now the Beginning Phase, Untap Step
Hix360 untaps his/her permanents
It is now the Beginning Phase, Upkeep Step
It is now the Beginning Phase, Draw Step
Hix360 draws a card
It is now the Precombat Main Phase
Hix360 plays Seat of the Synod from Hand
Hix360 plays Lotus Petal from Hand
Hix360 plays Goblin Welder from Hand
<IWASHI> Ok
Hix360 puts Lotus Petal to Graveyard from Play
Hix360 plays Tormod's Crypt from Hand
<Hix360> gg?
<IWASHI> oh
<IWASHI> nice
<IWASHI> gg
<Hix360> lol
<Hix360> gg
<System> Player Lost
If you don't see it...The guy is playing Reanimator...I go turn 1 welder & tormod's crypt...They can never reanimate things, barring necromancy shenanigans.