MTG Salvation

I'm sure there are others to add but wanted to put this down for anyone browsing looking for ideas.
we now have soulherder and Thassa, Deep-Dwelling.

I might start considering cutting supreme verdict as well. Azorious has quite a few options so I might need to ponder a while to figure out what change I want to make

so i finally got a hold of Daddy Teferi, Trying to decide if I should cut Supreme Verdict or Geist of Saint Traft. I think Supreme Verdict is the better card, but I have been thinking that Geist might be better for the cube at my current size of 411. I am not sure if I really need the wrath with Day of Judgment, Wrath of god at 4 CMC, and Winds of Abandon as a new edition.
Thoughts?

I cut thing in the ice for Brazen borrower and it's been a nice change. They go in such different decks though it's hard to say which is better

I would cut the abbot

Didn't see that you are running so many talismans... with that many, yeah dack is probably worth it

Call me crazy, but in your cube, I think I would consider cutting Dack to test royal scions. They both offer a draw ability, but dack's ability is really hit and miss in an unpowered cube, where as the Scions pumping your creatures is a lot less dependent on your opponents deck

Great write up, i am not quite as hot on fabled passage. I think i would rank it around 7 or 8.

I think I like memory lapse the most out of those.

Pick 2.
Charming Prince, Imposing Sovereign, Wall of Omens
(basically, Should I make a cut for charming prince, or not. If I do, What should the cut be.)

This has played great for us. Forcing discard and sacing a creature to me feels like the stonger choice most of the time. If your connecting with him in the air it seems bad to let your opponent try and draw for an out.

Quote from opterown »

Certainly a good card, but Blue is insanely hard to make cuts to...

I might try this out over thing in the ice

Great Card, I don't think this will fit into my cube though. I have 10 other cards that I run that are not part of the shock / Dual / Fetch cycles, and I don't think I have room for any more at 405. Probably a good consideration at 450+ though

This isn't exciting to run, but probably the best red utility land. I think the decision to include this is probably very cube dependent. If your heavy red decks tend to have a lower than 50% win rate (even 45% or so) this is probably worth running, becase the difference between running this in a deck vs another mountain is a big upgrade. It may not be exciting, but it will make decks better.

well, I was hoping for a constructive debate on the cards not just this card is better, but more info on what makes each card worth running and when...

For this weeks discussion, I am proposing Black 4 Drops.
I currently run the following:
Braids, Cabal Minion
Nekrataal
Ravenous Chupacabra
Skinrender

Of course, we have a new goody being printed in Rankle, Master of Pranks.
I am excited to have a 4 mana beater that can play well in a variety of decks.
There has been some discussion on what to cut for Rankle with some thoughts on Skinrender.
How does everyone else feel about there 4 drops?